P.Jay's Pizza

Cheyanne is an amazing employee who will go above and beyond to make sure you leave a happy customer!! Every pizza I have had from Pjs it looks perfectly cooked, and tastes even better. I get gluten free in recent years and it's hands down the best I have ever tasted! I'm a big fan! So glad to have Pjs pizza and their friendly staff members so close by! Great job. Every time 🍕 ❤

This pizza was amazing. Chicken tenders were great also-I DoorDash, and was always tempted to try because it always smells so good in the restaurant and delivering, now I know why! I will for sure be back again soon

I was in Parma for the weekend for a class and our class didn’t get out until 9pm on Friday night. At first, I went to another pizza shop 200 yards away, but the dinning room wasn’t open at 10pm even though they closed at 11pm. So I drove down to P.Jay’s and they served me with no hesitation AND the pizza was very good. Next time I’m in Parma, I’ll certainly head back.

One of my absolute favorite pizza joints in Parma! Food is always yummy, delivery drivers are always friendly and usually early, I can't say enough good things about this place. My family has ordered delivery and carry out from P. Jay's over a dozen times in the last year, and we're consistently happy with our meals.

Pjays pizza 🍕 is all around the best pizza place in Parma. Lee and his crew are amazing and give the best customer service. We love pjays pizza 🍕 and won't go anywhere else. ❤ Thank you to Lee and his crew for always making great pizza but mostly for having amazing customer service.

Just tried this place out and it was sooo good. But a huge warning on the hot wings because my lips are on fire. Sooooo delicious but the spice bites back.. great service I would recommend this place to anyone. We will definitely be back over and over again.

I'm overall just impressed by this place. Had a small issue and the team went above and beyond to fix the situation. Totally shocked me how professional these guys are. As for the FOOD, no doubt this is the best pizza place in Parma. The sauce was dead on and the dough was the perfect blend of crispy but still doughy. Very generous on the toppings and they use premium products. Fan for life! Check these guys out you won't be let down.

We have ordered here too many Browns Sundays to count. The order always comes on time, fresh, and always taste great with some brews ona gameday with friends. Pjay's knows how to make a solid pie, if you live in Parma and haven't tried them, I suggest you do.

Staying at a hotel in Cleveland and ordered from here because it was fairly close and decent DD delivery time. Wife got wings well done and I got a pizza with garlic butter sauce, half double pepperoni, half pepperoni and ‘old world’ sausage also well done. Order was correct and delivered on time. Food was really good. Sausage had a really good flavor. Crust had a nice chew to it. I really liked that they have sauce options as I don’t like red sauce. Only thing better would be old world pepperoni and option to add some nacho cheese cups to dunk the end of the crust in. I love pizza and would definitely order here again when I’m in Cleveland.

First-time ordering their gluten free for a family member. Best gluten free pizza we have tasted yet !!! YUM😋 I am always pleased with the service and quality of food at PJays. Glad to have found a place that every one can order from together even with special dietary needs❤ very friendly and polite staff as well!

Picked up two Pies....both were really good..and prices are very reasonable!

We have loved PJ's for years. The last few deliveries were cold and lacking of ingredients. You have redeemed yourself! Today's delivery was hot, fresh, cheesy (ordered Xtra cheese) and delicious!❤

Excellent food, nice people.
Could have been a little cleaner.

I've ordered here about 3 times and they haven't disappointed so far!!! The pizza is fresh, you can order the amount and what kind of sauce, dough seems homemade. Not sure but my boyfriend tried it for the first time the other day and can't stop taking about it, mainly that I should of ordered a bigger pizza!

Whoever is the chef tonight 12/9/23 you made some mind-blowing bum azz delicious spicy garlic Parmesan chicken wings.

My half sheet pierogi pizza was amazing today!!

Love this place! I have been ordering from them for a few years. my Doordash order kept being cancelled for no reason. They offered to deliver it to me even though I am out of the delivery area.

Ordered online but they lost our ticket, the owner I believe came back out with our order free of charge and cookies! That’s what I call amazing customer service!

Driven past so many times and finally tried delivery tonight. The food was super hot and fresh. The wings were large and meaty- the hot garlic parm sauce was so good! We also got a pizza which was quite tasty. My favorite part of the whole meal was the apple dessert pizza- the chewy dough covered in apple pie filling, crumble, and an icing drizzle. Treat yourself and get one! We will definitely order from P. Jays again!

I rescind my previous review (Below) .... new ownership is top notch and delivers a high quality product every time ! I'm glad that we decided to give them another shot. Like I mentioned, new ownership matters, these folks are hard working and pleasant

5 Years Ago
"Quality has gone down a great deal as of late. When we explained that our pizza was not to our satisfaction, we received a very RUDE message in return. No business owner should ever treat a loyal customer like that...ever!

Probably not what Mario and Angelina had in mind!"