Jeremy B Schafer: Allstate Insurance

Unlike other insurance agents you feel Mr. Steve wouldn't pressure you for anything and you literally can feel that he is in your team, He perfectly details and explains things so when you leave you don't carry any question marks with you. He is the best in the area. These guys helped us for our new home and auto insurance, and not only saved us lots of $$ but also make us feel welcome since the first moment, represent their offers perfectly, explained in detail then we made our comparison with other companies and it was no brainer to be back and work with them. 5 stars all around. !!!!

Awesome experience.. Fast easy and very convenient.. just one call and Steve Wilson had a quote done ready and set for that afternoon.. you won’t be disappointed with their service and friendliness..

The team at Jeremy's office do a great job of explaining my options, and helping me get your coverage that's right for my situation.

I've always had good experiences with allstate. They are always so friendly and helpful.

Awesome team! Provides quick responses to any questions or quotes I may need and are always friendly.

Absolutely no problems even when filing an accident report.

I had homeowner's insurance through this office. They added a fireplace to the policy that never existed as well as increasing premiums year over year without any claims being made. I purchased a new home and found a better insurance provider. After canceling and service and letting them know my current address to send my refund too. They instead sent it to the previous address that I do not live at. I gave them a follow up call to see what is going on strangely enough they were able to tell me the address that they suppose ably sent the check to. Guess what its been a month and a half and still no check. Called customer service and they were able to cancel the old check and will be sending it out. Just need to wait another month or so. I will never use this place for anything. Literally nothing...

I was an Allstate customer for 10+ years, covering home, auto and umbrella. Through all of this years, all agents I had were responsive and proactive. Well.. until this past summer.
Long story short, I moved from a different city a couple of years ago and decided to switch to a local agent, when I chose Jeremy Schafer. As I refinanced my home mortgage this past summer, the agency and the bank had a miscommunication about the insurance, consequently the payment was not on time. It cost me about $350 extra. The agency was never proactive enough to let me know the delay, or made any effort to compensate me. I decided to quote with other insurance companies and have moved all my insurance to another company.

I had Jeremy Schafer All-State for a few years. When I changed to progressive I had to call up 3 separate times to cancel my policy.

The first time I called up was a month prior to the renewal. They did not cancel EITHER of my policies and if I hadn't turned off auto-renewal, I would've been charged.

The second time I called up, after they sent me late fees and additonal bills for a policy I had already tried to cancel, they then cancelled only my auto policy, I was sent more notices of payment due for the renters.

The THIRD time I called them, I was told the renter's wasn't cancelled due to a "glitch in the system"

My cancellations didn't go through due to:
1.) Carelessness on Jeremy Schafer's part
2.) Lack of attention to detail
3.) This one is unlikely but, hoping I didn't notice potentially.

Be aware of this experience with this insurance agent.

I have since moved all my insurance to another company, I recommend the same to others.