Elliott Bay Pizza & Pub

Solid pizza and meatballs! Sauce and crust were fantastic. Food came out much slower than expected. The place was less than half full when we ordered and we were the only non-bar customers, but I guess there were a lot of to go orders. I think they should prioritize dine in orders and not let them get buried behind the togos. Will definitely be back to try some more pies and apps.

Arrived around 1:30pm, seated and helped immediately.
Appetizer: Garlic bread. It has THE perfect crisp and the marinara sauce is hands down one of my favorites.
Drink: Peach Bellini cider, great drink!
Pizza: Piazza Chicken pizza (minus the red onion, added olives) I LOVED the olive oil garlic sauce!
Can't wait to come back and try more!

Staff is great and welcoming. Food was amazing and found out from a owners daughter it’s a 12yr old sour dough starter for the pizzas. That makes for some AMAZING bread for the pie. This is a must stop if your in the area.

Looooooong time favorite for delicious pizzas, subs & craft beers!

My beer loving brother and husband insist this place is a five. Great beer selection and good food. Always consistent.

I live super close and this was my first time here. Don’t know why they only have 3.5 stars on yelp because this place is money!! Great place for kids with a huge menu selection. Beer list looked good although I had wine on HH. Pizza was so delicious. I had the Boston add pepperoni. Side salad was tasty too with fresh veggies and a yummy Italian dressing (there are more dressing options of course) 10/10 would recommend trying Elliott bay!

Great pizza and awesome customer service.
Probably the best cheese sticks/bread I’ve ever had, and I’m the kind of guy who tries cheese sticks at every pizza place.

Always a great experience. I like how you can customize a pizza without the fast food feel of Mod Pizza. Wednesdays are fun with some always challenging Trivia and the beer tender is the absolute best!

I love the subs at the place. They're pricey but they're huge! Bring an appetite. They hav few great pasta and pizzas with 30 craft beers on tap. I highly reccomend this restaurant. Give them a try.

My close friends live up the street from Elliott Bay pizza and this is one the spots we can always rely on. The pizzas are fantastic and the sandwiches are some of the best around. Trust, if you want a place to grab some quality food and a brew. This is a great spot to check out.

Everything is on point! I always get the Greek spaghetti and blue cheese wedge salad. Family gets kona on fire and pineapple pepperoni pizzas! We have eaten a lot of other things, but these are our favorites!!! Can't go wrong!

First time I've been here.
Good service.
I had the Garlic Cheese Bread. It was really good!
I also had the Christmas Ale to go with it. I like Porters and Bock's typically. The Christmas Ale was pretty good.
I will return.

Great local pizza spot. 14 Hands wine but lots of beer choices. Delicious pizza with hand made crust. Thin, kinda greasy...delish! House salad was good and fresh and the sesame ginger chicken salad my friend had looked fabulous. Cute decor and friendly staff.

Long time customer. A friendly place with delicious food. The pizza takes a little longer because it's real, and when you take your first piece off the pan, hot steam follows it. They have a great array of hot sandwiches as well made the right way. Good happy hour I think 3-6.

This place is legit. I was born and raised in New Jersey so I know good Italian food. The food here is really good. They have a great selection of beer on tap as well. Has a nice small town feel inside that I really enjoy. Come by and have a sub you won't be let down!

Best sourdough crust around. A true Seattle style pizza, killer grinders, and a kickass beer program.

Excellent pizza! Hot and fresh in less time than quoted for pickup.

Top notch pizza, pasta, salads and appetizers, but the big draw is a phenomenal beer list with friendly and knowledgeable staff. There were 3 Russian River beers on tap. Can't beat it!

I love this place and go often. Their pizza is so satisfying, I have yet to try their sandwiches or salads, which other patrons enthuse over. Very friendly staff and a nice neighborhood atmosphere. You'll want to keep coming back.

They forgot my spicy sausage on the pizza. It was still very good, a bit of a bummer when I got home, and it wasn't a complete order. I won't take stars because they were very nice about the situation.