Michaelangelo's Pizza & Subs

We really enjoy the pizza, and they are our goto for the kids. The sweet thai chili wings were also a highlight and definitely worth trying!

Went with my go-to of thick crust with Canadian bacon. Super chewy crust and loads of high quality cheese and toppings. I need to spice up the sauce a little, but other than that, this is my favorite pizza in the area! Friendly staff are always amazing!

Really good service. Manager on duty was very attentive with everything that was going on. No one standing around and all customers needs were met instantly. Food was a good value in todays world and had great taste.

It is one of the best, if not the best pizza place in the area! nothing hits better than a slice of NY style pizza after a long day on the beach!

Delicious!! I went in and ordered a pizza but saw they had a stuffed pizza. I asked what was in it and it sounded so good so I asked if I could change my order. Even though they had started the pizza,they said no problem and made the stuffed pizza! It is so good and so filling! And they give you a generous portion of sauce to go with it! It was so good and they were so nice. Would definitely eat there again!

Nice employees! Awesome food! Love this place. They deliver, you can eat inside or you can even pre-order and pick up. Your food will ALWAYS be ready when they say it will be. Their pizza is always so hot, fresh and great, love it! Awesome new York style pizza as well as stuffed pizza.....YUMMM on both! Also love their strombolis, calzones, Sub sanwiches (especially the steak and cheese, OMG), salads, appetizers (fried mushrooms, fried cheese sticks, garlic knots and more). Very clean inside. Nice decor with beautiful mural paintings on the walls. Sure, they are busy from time to time, but if a restaurant was never busy, then that is when you should worry, lol. :)

The steak and cheese sub is so good. Highly recommend this sub!

I been wanting some good pizza for a while and I found it!

Best pizza in the Crystal Coast and super-friendly staff.

Not all Michaelangelo restaurants are created equal. My family's originally from NE NJ (right outside NYC) and has owned a house in Emerald Isle for 24 years.
This Michaelangelos is worth the extra 10 min back over the bridge on 58
It's a good excuse to see the view more often than just coming and going from your weekly rental, anyway! Lol

Sandwiches, calzones, pizza ...all top notch!

Loved it. Food was excellent. Service was great. Music was playing. Staff was nice and accommodating. The salted caramel Cheescake was to die for!!! Will def return

Left the pier to get a couple of slices. Michaelangelo made that happen. Just like a slice from back in New York, Almost. The team there, didn't get names, yet, it seemed the young lady was running the show, Kudos. Polite, efficient, great personalities. Because of that, We'll be back!!! 😎

Literally the best pizza I’ve ever had in my life. Crust and dough are equal amounts thin, crunchy, and soft. Cheese is ✨chefs kiss✨ amazing. The employees were super nice as well!!! 10/10 we are definitely going here every time we visit Emerald Isle from now on!

As a return customer, I recently ordered pizza here. It’s definitely the best I’ve had in the area. The gentleman making the pizza was friendly too. Will continue to do business there.

Try the fried pickles and fried mushrooms they are so good paired with the meat tri pizza and they're quick with orders

Best New York Pizza around. Staff may be busy but the food is great. Call in to pick up and it will be ready when they say. Eat in is good and cup drinks are freshh. Calzones - KaPow!

Service is a little funky from time to time but generally good. Payment is simple. Delivery is accurate and on time.

Salads are fresh and well made. Good serving size. The large pizzas are a party treat. Plain cheese, pepperoni or several topping the pizzas are delicious. I appreciate the murals in the place. It’s great pizza at a great pizza place!

My family preferred Michelangelo's I've never been happy with their pizzas. Too few toppings an extremely greasy..
However they surprised me on Sunday 10 Oct., lots a pepperoni on the pizza and I didn't have to use a roll of paper towels before eating.

Order delivered to National Forest Campground. No only was the pizza good but it was delivered by a great person Hal. There was a small problem with the order but we were happy with it. Hal was not and wanted to make it right. He would not take no for an answer and went out of his way to correct the problem. Great job Hal!!!

Best chicken Philly and cheese in Emerald Isle! Awesome pizza as well!

These guys have the best pizza in the area. The only two Michaelangelo's I'll frequent is this one and the one in emerald isle. The pizza is made fresh and the prices are great.theres no comparison with other pizza places around. They also have pasta dishes that are excellent and if a salad is wanted,they have plenty with fresh ingredients. This place is a no brainer.

Food is always delicious! Can't wait until our next visit.