Goody's Pizzeria

being from Queens, NY I would say this is one of the best garlic pies (they call it pizza here) you can get in Maine. Roccos in Old Orchard Beach is also a contender. This is simply a fact, like snow is cold. its its accepted as such because you can go discover it for your self. if you have an air fryer and need to sort of understand good pizza its here

We love this place and stop from time to time when passing through. We had our almost 2y.o Son with us and they sliced a part of the cheese pizza into mini slices for him. Small things like that are soooo appreciated! Thanks for going above and beyond and making delicious pizza!! 😋❤

I brought my kids in yesterday to try the pizza and we were very pleasantly surprised!!! The pizza was amazing!!!! The staff was friendly and helpful(they even asked if we wanted some slices double cut for my toddler!). We will definitely return!!!

I really enjoy this pizza joint. People complaining about the time it takes to make a pizza should keep in mind that there are only 2 people working here.... it is a small mom and pop place, not only could they likely not afford many other staff members, but we’re in the middle of a pandemic and there’s not enough room for many people to be behind the counter. My main reason for writing this comment though is because there’s a review saying the customer received a burnt pizza, and I know for a fact that these two would NEVER send out a burnt pizza. One time my pizza ended up being burnt, and when I told them that it was okay and I actually prefer crispier crusts, they looked distraught about sending me out there with a little blackened crust.

We encountered none of the drama experienced by the prior reviewer. Staff was friendly and helpful. Everyone got along great. The 10" pizza ($7) was the cheesiest I've seen. The large steak bomb ($9), which was excellent, overflowed with fixings, so much so I needed a fork to clean up what fell onto my plate.

Consistently an excellent pizza. Went here a few years ago and the new owners have done a great job. Every aspect has been approved upon. Tons of toppings and a crispy crust. Possibly the best pizza in Gray, Maine.

Was in Gray during the lunch hour waiting to take my car to the shop for a sticker. My husband and I drove by and decided to check it out. So glad that we did! We ordered a 16" cheese pizza with mushrooms on half, talk about awesome, it was super good!! The owners were super friendly too, I would definitely recommend it and go back if I'm ever near Gray. Very good prices too!

The owners are super friendly. Ive eaten here several times. I live the Teriyaki cheese steak, its absolutely amazing. The owner makes his own homemade teriyaki sauce. I told him he should bottle that stuff and sell it.

Have not tried the pizza yet, too in love with the cheese steaks.

Yum!

We love Goody’s. Perfect pizza and sub shop. I enjoy saying hi to Pamela and Brad when I walk in, and when I order on the phone and give them my name Brad says “I thought it was you”. Very personable! I highly recommend.

Honestly best pizza you can find in gray/new Gloucester. Family owned and they are some of the nicest people. Every time I’m there I always feel welcomed and the food is really good. No complaints from me

5/5 I ordered a chicken parm calzone that wasnt on their menu. But they were more than happy to give it a shot! These are great people that enjoy making good food and satisfying customers. The calzone was perfect!

It's a classic small town spot! Friendly staff, the sandwich was awesome. Makes me wish I lived closer! Definitely worth rerouting my travels, as they are just off the gray exit of the turnpike!

I absolutely love this place! The food is fresh and the quality is top notch! The owners are very nice and I always have a pleasant experience ever time I order their food. I would highly recommend this place to anyone!
-Mike Russo

Fabulous pizza, and amazing staff!!!!!! We told the staff that we were out celebrating my son's birthday. As we were eating, they brought out a whoppie pie with a candle in it!!! We will definitely be back to Goody's!!!

Probably the best place for getting great sandwiches at good prices. I've never had a bad experience here, everyone is super friendly and they even know my name (Probably because I work at the cemetery all the time and stop by any chance I get for lunch). If I had one complaint it would be that I don't live close enough to this place.

Delicious subs! This place is the real deal, they just don't make shops like this anymore. Terrific service to boot. Chef has come out to talk to us both times we visited. Stop reading and head on over!

Started coming here after a co worker recommended and am I glad I took his advice best food around the steak and cheese is one of the best I ever had and cheeseburger sub was beyond amazing. want great food at a great price come here

So delicious ! Stoped here for the first time a couple weeks ago and ordered a Greek pizza! It was to die for... so delicious 😊 the people there were very nice as well!

It's the best pizza in Gray! Cheaper and tastier than Jess n Nick's. Wonderful, kind family runs it. Bring your cash.

Best pizza I have had in a while. I ordered on the phone and it was ready when promised at the price I expected. Counter help was friendly and efficient. I will stop here again.