Suzy's Tomato Pizzeria

The Pizza is delicious so is the food , can’t beat his prices either! He’s not their to break your bank ! He is here to make his customers happy and make sure they come back, and we keep going back! On the mountain and free delivery! And Great Prices!!!!! What else could ya ask for? We enjoy the food!

Thank you, Mike, once again for the delicious pizza and for being so accommodating to use my vegan “cheese”! My birthday dinner was fantastic!

Mike is the best he knows my order and it taste amazing everytime. Philly cheesestake wings and fries.

I ordered a chicken parm sub and a side salad. Both excellent! Chicken was fresh and lots of it on the sub and the salad had a good selection of mixed greens

Absolutely. THE BEST. Pizza in the area. We are pizza snobs and moved to the area a few years ago. We are regularly disappointed with local pizza quality- too soggy, too much dough, not enough toppings/ topping to cheese ratio.. ect. We tried Suzy’s for the first time and WAS SO HAPPY, JOYFUL LEAPING PIZZA HAPPINESS! Excellent crispy flavorful dough, perfect topping to cheese ratio, delicious sauce- all around a mouth watering delight. Loved the huge pepperoni!! And the mushrooms were perfect! Not soggy/ can-water water logged tasting- but juicy and earthy. So Suzy Tomato- my heart is yours- we shall be back again for your delicious pie!

I’ve been reading , new people took over? I’m sad mainly because I was looking forward to visiting and having my favorite spaghetti and sweet sausage.

I wish I wrote a review sooner. I lived “up on the mountain” for a while before moving to Oregon.
If anyone reads these, I was the horse gal that lived in the tiny home at a horse farm.
The cook and the delivery guys were all awesome to me as I didn’t drive and they brought me what I ordered which sometimes include a good handful of my favorite Monster drink and a gallon of milk.

Your food was awesome. You were all awesome. The deli crew too, making me PB&J everyday. Totally worth the $2.75 per sandwich because I just couldn’t get it to taste the same. Lol.

New to the area and stopped in for a slice. I was super surprised how good it was! And I'm a pizza snob haha. I will be back!

I had a bad experience a couple years ago. I've been ordering from down the mountain since. Tonight i gave them another try...it was great ! Delicious! And I got it within a half an hour! Keep it up Suzy's tomato! You're my new go to!

Great local Pizzeria/restaurant. They deliver ! I've ordered for delivery, and pick-up, have also eaten there with family. Great spot for the local kids too. Their menu is pizzeria/grill style and well stocked, they also do catering. Definitely one of the better restaurants in Hewitt/West Milford.

Good pizza, great service. Always friendly. They also sell their pizza dough at a reasonable price- always a nice go to if you need fresh, local dough. Works well a for a variety of recipes.

We love this place. The pizza and wings are so tasty! The service is excellent. So worth the drive for us

I love their cheese pizza and salads! The meatball sandwich is great as well!
Everything is fresh and delicious at Suzy's Tomato!

Mike is a great guy,that makes a fabulous
pizza as well as other foods

Great Customer Service 👌! Pizza was delicious, I'm coming back.

Consistently good Pizza and always friendly people behind the counter...recommended

Great food!!! I also love that they have a really sexy tomato as the mascot!!!! WOULD HIGHLY RECCOMEND

Surprisingly nice cozy place the food was excellent service was excellent a very enjoyable experience

Suzy’s is my fave

Pizza was delicious. Large pizza is huge. Well worth the cost.

Love this pizza! One of my favorites.