Sweet Tooth Bakery & Cafe

This bakery is amazing and unique in this decade we live in. The order was a custom
Cake phone order to be delivered in the State College area. All details from ingredients to decoration including delivery were followed flawlessly. In addition, I received in the mail a receipt, picture of the cake, and a handwritten thank you note from the owner Cheri. I wish I had discovered this bakery sooner while my daughter was attending Penn State. She still has friends at Penn State so we will be using Sweet Tooth
Bakery in the future!!❤❤

Cheri is the owner and she was awesome to work with. She helped me customize my daughter’s birthday cake. I sent her a couple pictures and we spoke over the phone to create the perfect cake. The end result was just what my daughter wanted!

Cherish is awesome..have been getting picture cookies from for years..4 generations of my family have beautiful memories. Cakes are beautifully decorated and tasty. So easy to work with!A+++

I wanted to do something special for my daughter, on Valentines Day, who is a student at Penn State. Cheri was great to work with and provided delicious and beautiful sweets. My daughter told me how nice Cheri was to her. The treats were absolutely delicious and beautifully done. Thanks Cheri for a great experience! I would definitely recommend you to anybody that wants quality goods and great customer service!!

Cheri made a great custom cake for a colleague's birthday. She was great to work with and helped bring my vision to life. The whole process was very smooth and the cake turned out fantastic. I would highly recommend Sweet Tooth Bakery & Cafe. Thanks for everything, Cheri!

Sweet Tooth Bakery made a BEAUTIFUL cake for our daughter’s birthday! My daughter said the cake was so delicious and she loved it!! Cheri was wonderful to work with and was so accommodating to our requests. This was a quick request on an already busy week for her bakery. Thank you Cheri for helping this out-of-state mom surprise our daughter with an amazing cake that also looked like a piece of art! And a shout-out to your delivery driver for making sure the cake was left in a secure way while my daughter was in class. Highly recommend this bakery!

Such a wonderful bakery! Ordered a cake and balloons for my PSU student’s birthday and they couldn’t have been easier and more pleasant to work with. Highly recommend!

I called from out of state less than a week before my son's wedding when I found out the couple could not afford, and therefore were going to skip, a cake. SweetTooth to the rescue! The staff was attentive and the cake was delicious. I'd definitely shop there again.

I highly recommend Sweet Tooth Bakery!!! My daughter, a PennState student just turned 21 on April 26th! I live in Philadelphia, I called the bakery to order a cake and ballons to be delivered to my daughter, they were amazing!!! The cake was beautiful and delicious plus they mailed me the receipt and pictures of the cake and ballons also a thank you card from the owner!!! Thank you!!! A beautiful experience!!!

My father was visiting us and wanted a Black Forest cake for his 70th birthday. I called a few other local cake shops and none were interested in taking a custom order that deviated from their standard menu, but Cheri at Sweet Tooth was happy to give it a try. The cake she made for us was outstanding - it was moist, flavorful, and my dad loved it. Very highly recommended!

Wanted a birthday cake for my niece. Unlike other bakeries in town, Sweet Tooth didn't need two weeks notice. I submitted my request online a week in advance, and was contacted the next day by phone. We ordered a two layer dark chocolate cake with strawberry filling and buttercream frosting. It was beautiful and a huge hit! My fiance loved the frosting so much he's requesting a cake from Sweet Tooth for his birthday - and he usually hates cake! The 2-layer 10" round cake was more than enough cake for 10 people.

Cheri is just an awesome lady! She baked the perfect chocolate cake for my husband's birthday in just one day notice. While I am writing this review, I am still craving for the leftover cake. My husband is equally happy too. Thanks Cheri, for making the day special. I promise to come back.

Cheri did a wonderful job on a cookie bouquet for my daughter's 21st birthday. Not only was it so pretty but it tasted great too! Her follow up and picture sent home to view was an unexpected and appreciated touch!

I called on my daughter’s birthday to see if there was anyway they could deliver a cake on the same day. Cheri recommended a cookie cake decorated with chocolate covered Oreos and pretzels and told me she will call me back so she can get the cookie baking. My daughter called me 2 hours later to thank me for the cookie cake. Cheri, thank you so much for going above and beyond to make my daughter’s birthday special. I will be visiting you when I come up to see my daughter in Penn State.

We ordered two cakes for my daughter's birthday and also 24 cupcakes for her class. The cakes and cupcakes were moist and delicious. The frosting was a little sweet for my family's taste, but it could be because we don't eat cakes very often. I would highly recommend and I will definitely purchase a cake and cupcakes from again.

My husband surprised me with a Dalmatian cake from Sweet Tooth for my 40th birthday. He was running out of options as no bakery would agree to make a specialty cake this close to Christmas. He talked to the owner at Sweet Tooth who readily agreed to make the cake. She had no ideas for how to make it look like a Dalmatian and not a cow, lol! I think that is pretty much how everyone feels. She came up with a great design. Not only did it look amazing, it tasted even better! We would definitely recommend Sweet Tooth!

Sweet Tooth Bakery made (and delivered!) a seriously DELICIOUS tiered wedding cake for my parents' 50th anniversary party. My guests all raved about it. Also ordered some vegan cupcakes for guests with food allergies. They were delicious as well.

Called this place on a whim because I didn't want to go with a store brought cake. They did such a fabulous job on a beach themed cake! Oh and it tasted so good too! I would recommend!

The owner Cheri, helped me today. What a lovely bakery and lovely owner. The cookies and Oreos were fantastic!!!

Incredible work here. Listened to EXACTLY what I wanted and it came out perfect. Being able to print images onto cookies made this one of the best places for any kind of birthday gift, wedding gift, anniversary gift, or fundraiser. I love parking downtown and walking into the sweet little shop, it makes my whole weekend