Sabatini’s Pizza

I’ve been coming here since 2015 and if you want the best pizza and beer selection in not just NEPA but the country - this is it!

World class craft beer and imported beer selection. Best selection of imported Belgian beer I’ve come ever come across

Stopped by Sabatini’s for lunch on a coworker’s recommendation for my first NEPA pizza experience. It did not disappoint. I got a small avellino with pickles (also a recommendation) and my coworker got an (unpictured) pie with hot sausage and banana peppers. The crust was nice and crispy with a good structure on both. I enjoyed the sweeter sauce more than I expected - especially to balance out the hot sausage.

They have a sizable beer selection as well, and our server was quick to make a recommendation for options.

Lived up to the recommendation and I will be back when I’m in the area again. Service was friendly and speedy. We ate in the original building and while yes, it’s older, it has character that you don’t get everywhere. Cash only but atm is available with a comparatively small fee if needed.

Quick pizza and delicious too! Took it to go for the family. Overall atmosphere and service, great and fast.

Called to order pick up for 2 }pizzas. The grill who answered said it would be 15 minutes. I only live right down the street so I immediately went down there and decided to sit and wait. The pizza was ready in 15 minutes exactly as promised!
Both pizzas were prepared exactly as we asked. One large with extra cheese mushroom and onion, the second a medium pizza with pepperoni. Both pizzas were made with all the toppings to the edge, almost no crust! What a huge relief, no waste! Will definitely be ordering there again! As a side note, they are a cash only business. Which I am relieved for because it saves them as well as myself any additional service charges by using a card.

Love their pizza, hate their parking lot.
It has a nice thin crust which I like. If you've never tried this pizza...it is definitely a sweet sauce. You have to like the sweet sauce on pizza. Just a head's up.

I got two buffalo chicken cheese steaks and they were bangin. Following week I ordered three and they were trash. Cheese wasn’t melted and the chicken looked like beef Jerkey. Ordered a third time and it was great. I work right around the corner from sabs so it’s convenient plus I know how good it could be! So I guess it’s hit and miss with how it comes out of the kitchen.

I always knew they had the best craft beer selection in NEPA, and I've heard the pizza is really good. What I didn't know is that they have THE best bourbon selection that I've ever seen. No bottles to go (FWaGS owns that monopoly), but you can get 1 or 2 oz pours. Great selection, including some of their own store picks, and the prices were reasonable. They also had an extensive list of scotch & Irish.

Get yourself a hot and fresh slice of Exeter history. The food never disappoints and if you're an avid fan of a good adult beverage - they have an incredible selection; something to suite everyone's taste.

Great buffalo bites and cauliflower pizza. Our server was fantastic and all of our items came out very fast. Very satisified with my visit to this local favorite

My son has celiac disease. He loved the gluten free pizza here!

The best pizza to date! Great tasting and totally worth the trip every time. Appetizers were pretty good too....had some popper and veggie mix battered. Affordable prices and decent family atmosphere. Very busy on Fri. and Sat. Enjoy!!!

I always love Sabatini's Pizza. I come down from Moscow to get this pizza. If it were closer I would get it more often. I am a fan of the bottle shop, it's the Walmart of beers. There is something for everyone!

I've been getting pepperoni (the best) for so long that it was like a brand new Sabatini's when I added onions. Tried pickles, extra sauce, & thick crust. All really good, but decided to see if any reviewers had a recommendation. I was shocked to find that someone actually gave one star-- to Sabatini's?! Then, I realized it's just the nature of online reviews. Somebody gets upset about the flow of traffic on Wyoming Ave. or for having to pay cash (some people still believe there are no costs for payment processing because it's built into prices, although more places are adding convenience fees). Another called the building "aged." Damn right, it's aged! Sabatini's is such a classic, and they've managed to keep prices reasonable for their awesome pizza. I've met a few who don't like the pizza, and even they've admitted it was good but for their own personal preference. When I see traffic is crazy busy, I go around the damn block. When I don't bring enough cash, I use the ATM. I pick up an order at least 2-3 times a month and have been going to Sabs for years, and no parking 'nightmare' or payment method is going to stop me! I haven't had a bad order once. After years of that delicious pepperoni, I'm trying it with sausage!!! And I'll park down the street, or wait outside in line (like COVID times), if need be. But 99.9% of the time, I'm able to stop right in front or there are plenty of available spaces, & I can run in and out in 2 seconds.

Go here whenever I'm back to my old hometown roots. My top 5 N.E.P.A pizza joints. Always delicious and good service. Let me know when you guys start shipping pizzas. Would buy 10-15 pizzas at a time if you ship to Florida. Sure many others would buy also. I remember when it was sold at stores as a kid. And school. Lol.

This is the best pizza in NEPA! Love the lightly crisp crust. Even on busy nights, the pizza comes out pretty quickly.

Great old school pizzeria! Friendly but not in-you-face staff. Meat eaters pizza and chick-parm sub were fantastic!

Unbelievable beer selection. If there is a beer that you are looking for then there is a very good chance you will find it here. Also, it's fun to walk around and checkout new beers that you've never had before. You can order pizza in the beer store and that is good as well.

When a pizza shop thrives in a pandemic there's only one reason. I was fortunate to have discovered the reason the other day and what I can confirm is that Sabatini's pizza is the best!!! Yes I can't leave out their meatball sandwich... also the best!!!

Top-notch pizza, but...we're here for the beer. Head and shoulders above ANY other place in the area, and the ONLY place to find this mad selection of specialty beers. Belgian Trappist ales like the ones pictured (that's a glass of the brand new Chimay Green, and it's on DRAFT), obscure and rare American craft beers, German and Austrian lagers...a stunning draft selection, and many available for takeout in the bottleshop. Plus an excellent selection of whiskeys and tequilas, and friendly, knowledgeable service. You'd never expect it in Exeter, but I guarantee once you find it, you'll be back.

It's my favorite pizza place in NEPA with great pear martinis. Plus, the pizza warms up well the next day!