Zerio's

Great find... Sandwiches are amazing. They were so huge that each sandwich fed two people. On top of being a great value, the taste was amazing. Next time we are in the area for a soccer game we are definitely coming back

Ordered doordash so can't speak to atmosphere but the chicken cutlet sandwich they made me was worth writing this review for. So worth the money in size, quality, and value. They were out of the bread I ordered, so they made me a panini. It was outrageously good. I've never had a bad sandwich or meal from this place.

Your six foot giant grinders were a big hit at a family party! Many compliments, and plenty of food! You might have some new customers coming your way!

As a Door Dasher I visit lots of restaurants. I live 5 minutes from here and never stopped here until I had three deliveries in a row in two days from here. They had samples of their grated cheese pizza and I tasted one while waiting for the DD order. It was amazing! I gave my daughter a piece and she agreed we should go back for dinner. We had a small pizza and a meatball and ricotta panini. Both were amazingly delicious! The flavors are so rich you can’t help but want more. The sauce in the side to dip in had me thinking I need to order an extra next time….because there will be a next time!!!

We live right around the corner and order pretty often.. it’s a struggle to not order here more!! Have always been treated kindly and the food is so consistent and amazing. We love everything we’ve gotten. Just a great family owned business. They take pride in their food!! Try a meatball ricotta pizza (or any pizza) or their soups/salads!

Lived in town 20yrs, can't believe it took us so long to try this place. Service was fast and friendly, the food was great. The panini was the size of a dinner plate, the chicken parm grinder was put together perfectly with the right amount of sauce and delicious cutlets. The chicken wrap was fresh and delicious. Can't wait to try the pizza. We'll definitely be back for more.

Holy cow this place is ridiculous. Had meetings in the area and it was suggested to go here.
Well done. Had soup and panini. Soup was buffalo chicken. Yes you heard me right. It was delicious and I loved the texture. Meatball and ricotta panini. Sauce on the side and some pickles. I'll be back.

OMG OMG I found this place by taking the wrong turn. But for me that was the BEST wrong turn😊 I got a steak and cheese ginger😋 IT WAS GREAT. The ladies there were so nice. I will safe this spot for sure👏🏾👏🏾👏🏾👏🏾

Delicious! Love their chicken salad wraps and classic sauce pizza

Great food, great service, great people! They cover the big 3 criteria. I'll stop before I make this about me!! Best Italian sandwich I've ever had

I'm stranded at the hotel down the street. Looking for a local restaurant. Decided to try a slice at Zerios. They had something called Parmageddon. How do I resist? Way too much stuff on it but I knew that when I picked it. They warmed it up and served. It was delicious. Best pizza I've had in a long time. I don't think I've ever had such an airy light fluffy and crispy crust like theirs before. It was new and perfect.

Authentic! Check out their big sandwiches on Italian bread!

Really the best place and people on earth… food… everything is amazing, can’t go wrong!!!

This place is a hidden gem! The portions are gigantic with tons of Italian options. There is hot or cold and even tables to dine in. Mostly people have take out and order ahead pick ups. I love the soup, lobster roll to die for and the desserts are killers! There’s a refrigerator with “take and gos” for a complete dinner for 11 bucks. I buy these just to keep in my refrigerator for a no worry option. Oh wait- one more thing the pizza from a by gone Middletown icon “Marino’s” rectangular pizza. Doesn’t get any better dan dis !!!!

Absolutely the best grinders, the grinder rolls are the freshest I have ever had!!!!!!!
Absolute must try!!!

Food is amazingly good and the service is fast!

Great place for lunch or dinner. I come here frequently for lunch and every sandwich is delicious. Would highly recommend if you are in the Cromwell / Middletown area.

Did a Google Search for pizza in Cromwell and there were many listings. I selected Zerio's for our group of 9 because of the positive comments and raves about the food. We were not disappointed! The staff was busy but attentive and friendly. You can tell this is the spot that many locals get their lunch. Which is a good sign. The case was filled with delicious looking sandwiches. Many were in line picking up and placing orders. They offered samples of their parmesan pizza and I had to add one to our order - which disappeared fast. The deep dish meat lovers pizza was amazing as were the margherita and a simple cheese. The best part...some left overs to fight over at home. take home. Definitely will be a stop when we are in the area again. We see why they earn such good ratings. Nice!!

Our go to for catering for any occasion!

Best Catering Dish: sausage and peppers

Best take-out: BLT with mayo and oil & vinegar

Kids love the free slices of Margherita Pizza!

They’re all so sweet, good grinders!