Wooster Street Pizza Cromwell

Years ago I had a Peanut butter Pizza! Tried it on a lark and it was SO GOOD! Well they still have it and it's still Awesome. When I remarked to the cashier that I was surprised that it was still available and she replied it was one of the most popular. Seriously.

The price was AMAZING and the decor was so fun. Definitely a little gem. I will definitely be returning here!

Been eating here since Summer of 2001. My absolute favorite pizza joint on the planet. And they have that Hydro Thunder arcade game there, that's always a fun time! I've been out of the state for 15 years at this point, but every time I visit CT, I always stop in! Absolutely love Wooster Street Pizza!

Fried calamari was excellent. Sausage and pepper pizza was very good. Not as well cooked as the last time so next time I'll ask for it to be a little more well done. Great service and pretty fast.

Great pizza shop! Grabbed a quick meal for family on road trip. Was easy to have individual pizzas for everyone. It is in a convenient location to our hotel across the street.

Service was great! Staff was busy yet attentive. Looks like a popular place based on the door traffic for pickups while waiting for our order. Pizza was great, and chef;s salad was well put together and fresh.

The restaurant has nice road/collector car decor. The tables in at least one section of the restaurant has interior car/train scenes. Really neat!

The pizza is fantastic and the Wooster sticks are by far the best breadsticks I've ever had anywhere! The staff is friendly and courteous and the inside is fun and comfy.

I know it sounds boring, but sometimes I love a great cheese pizza. (They make an amazing cheese pizza) I live right down the road and I am so lucky to have a place like Wooster next to my home.

Hands down, the best pizza I've had in the area. Just moved to Rocky hill from the New haven area where the pizza is great. We had the shrimp scampi, sausage and peppers and a cheese pie as well as the calamari. Everything was delicious especially the shrimp scampi! We definitely found our pizza place. Please don't believe the bad reviews, try it for yourself and make your own decision. The negative reviews seem sketchy, maybe from competitors and the missing food in the delivery sound like a grubhub driver error not the restaurant. My pizza had plenty of cheese and the only foul smells are from some of the reviews on here.

The pizza here is amazing, the wings are so flavorful and crispy. The food is absolutely delicious. I would recommend this place over any other pizza restaurant

We moved to area at end of august and we were getting frustrated not finding good Italian pizza. We tried Wooster and our hearts sang joy. When you come from New Haven area, its hard to find comparable pizza but Wooster marked all the stars for us.

My wife took me there for lunch and I gotta say, hands-down the best wings I’ve tasted in a long time. Their garlic Parmesan wings and teriyaki wings are absolutely delicious! I’m going to have to find a way to eat there more often. I definitely recommend and I hope this helps.

Thin delicious crust. Pure quality. Try the buffalo chicken pizza.

This is a wonderful place to go for quality New Haven-style pizza. I am a huge fan of their pizza, and their "Wooster-Sticks" (Breadsticks) are the best I have had.
If you're planning to eat in, there are lots of cool decorations inside that make your meal an experience.

This post is referring to the last review from Cassidy she ordered two wraps and two orders of frys,sat for a few minutes because she ordered up front she had to wait as Wooster st makes everything fresh. She never paid for a $15 wrap she paid for two wraps and two frys. She never called the restaurant to complain and wrote a bad review. Our resteraunt makes things fresh and we sell hundreds of wraps a day. We always go the extra mile to make things right if we mess up. Also her wrap was huge the owner made it and I cut it so i know. Also no one was rude to u as I was the one to take ur order and I am the manager! Plz don’t take ur a review from a woman that could be from anywhere. Other resteraunts send ppl just to make us look bad because we are doing so well try us out on ur own.

Great experience. Food is also amazing. My wife and I dined in and loved every bit. Definitely will be back before our trip back to southwest Florida.

This was my first time going to Wooster Street Pizza. I wish I had discovered this place earlier. They exemplify what New Haven style pizza is all about. The crust is the perfect balance between chewy and crispy. The sauce really made the pizza, though-- it was great.

This is the best pizza in Middlesex County. The staff is very friendly and makes you feel like you are at home. The owner is the nicest woman I have met, every tip you give her she donates to kids with cancer or gives it to another employee. All their food is amazing and made to please you. It doesn't matter what you order, you will enjoy it and this is coming from a fat guy that is very picky with what he eats lol. I will not eat anywhere else in Cromwell, not because there isn't good places, but because this place is just the best. Don't take my word for it, try it for yourself, you won't regret it. Also, your order will always be done in a timely manner, it doesn't matter if you eat in or pick up, it doesn't matter if it's Tuesday at noon or Friday night. Please do yourself a favor and try their food, you'll fall in love with the place.

Excellent pizza. Just as good as New Haven pizza in my opinion

I will come here with family members when you guys were placed in Wallingford brings back the nostalgia!

I really liked this place. I had an anti pasta- huge; their signature breadsticks, a buffalo chicken pizza - very good; and baklava.
All the food was excellent, and the owner and staff were very friendly