PizzaPie

Today, we happened into a great pizza establishment, and I have to admit that it's been a very long time since I've had pizza that was quite as excellent as this one. Both the cheese pizza and the veggie pizza that we tried were fantastic, but the veggie pizza was our favorite. Therefore, if you are in the area and looking for a pizza restaurant, PizzaPie comes highly recommended due to the excellent customer service, brick oven pizzas, and many other options they offer. Fantastic choices for families with young children.

Awesome place to get food from! Everyone who works there is super polite and does their best to make sure you have the best possible experience. They have plenty of tables to sit at, both indoor and outdoor. They place is very clean and spacious, and the pizza tastes great being cooked in the brick oven. This place shares a space with a Gyro place next door (I assume it is the same owner). Please like this review if you found it helpful! =)

Brought my family for dinner on Saturday. The pizza is incredible here! Nice, thin crust pizza, avocado salad is freshly made and is absolutely delicious. I really enjoyed the nice atmosphere and friendl service. MUST TRY THIS SPOT!

Good -- and I mean GOOD -- pizza is hard to find, but PizzaPie achieves it! Quality ingredients from flour, sauce and cheese. Intriguing décor mixing rustic and artistic motifs. Friendly, foreign staff. Bottled refreshments on sale. Al fresco dining area used in season. Tiled bathroom and desserts attractively displayed in a vitrine.

Not THE best pizza (the competition in CT is fierce), but definitely in the running, if you like wood-fired, brick oven, thin crust pizza. I think it is the best best pizza in the area until you get to Middletown. Additional pluses: best garlic knots around; Greece options like stuffed grape leaves and gyros; really good salads. The general manager is really nice. It has a nice, clean, Mediterranean atmosphere; not your average strip mall, bare-bones pizzeria.

The young girl who works there is always super friendly! The gyros are bussin, don’t think it gets better than this

Modernist dècor with some rustic touches. The pizza itself is delicious and fairly priced. Very nice staff. Clean bathroom. Outside in the lot, parking is plentiful. ..

Our friend has recommended this place.
We got pepperoni pizza, lamb chops, mashroom burger and boneless wings. The pizza and chops taste so good! The burger was really tasty as well. But the wings were not my favorite.
The seating area was pretty. Would come again for sure

One of the best pizza 🍕 i ever had.. it’s so good and the crust is thin and the taste is so good

Super tasty pizza in a very detail-oriented ambience. Service was good too! Pro-tip: You can enjoy the food from PizzaPie and GyroLove in the same premises!

Amazing and a unique place… very delicious food…., friendly… really friendly staff… Thanks Christine and Moe…

I love the food here. They have meatless options and it's all tasty. A little pricey but I always go back.

The food here is always delicious, my favorite is the falafel gyro and greek fries. The kids enjoy dining in,the staff are always so friendly the decorations are done really well and it's super cozy.

So the pizza here was absolutely delicious and I ordered some mozzarella sticks and they too were very delicious the service was standard friendly enough also

***((FYI the pizza pie is in a connected building with gyro next to mizzu Asian bistro & hibachi not the building with Firestone auto.))***

Best pizza in Cromwell! The slices are YUGE and very reasonably priced and are cooked in a wood burning oven. The selection is amazing and if you go for lunch on a weekday there are at least 10 different kinds ready to be sold by the slice. They also have amazing bread. You can sample it at the cash register and if you like it you can order your own platter and it'll come with a side of homemade marinara for dipping! The beverage selection is great! They have many varieties of Sanpellegrino sodas as well as juice and lemonade and your standard Coca-Cola products. The owner and the staff are all very pleasant and seem genuinely happy to be there. Very, very nice people! The restaurant is beautiful inside and decorated nicely. It's spotless! I mean when I say spotless even the restrooms are spotless! I highly recommend Pizza Pie. The Z place in town is really good too but guess what? Pizza Pie could become your new favorite. It happened to me.

My wife and I order from here whenever we are craving pizza. I think it’s the best in town and they never disappoint us! The staff is friendly and they always leave us with a smile on our face!

Loved the ambiance, food and staff. Will definitely return when I'm in the area.

Great place we found while passing by. Excellent pizza and the bread was amazing!

Impressed with the ambiance! Beautiful romantic cozy lighting, nice woodsy fire smell, decorated beautifully! Everyone was nice. We went on a dreary cold day, & the contrast was SO pretty with the nice warm twinkly lights inside. Liked the pizza and awesome gyros ! 😎 👍

best brick oven pizza ever very nice and friendly staff, Beautiful unique decoration don’t miss it
Come and check out the delicious gyro