Old Chicago Pizza + Taproom

I can’t stress how happy I am with trying Old Chicago for pizza this evening! The pizza was hot, exactly as ordered, plus they have a courteous and professional staff which is unlike some other pizza places.

It’s too bad I can’t give more than 5/5 stars. I will definitely be enjoying Old Chicago pizza again soon!

The environment was very clean and nice. We are there for lunch and I had the Sicilian Pepperoni Rolls. Plenty of food - I took half home - and they were delicious!

I have been to this old Chicago three times now. Even on their busiest day my family and I are treated nicely. The food is very good. This last time I went, my fiancé ordered the beer burger (his favorite). I ordered the Tuscan chicken with spinach pizza. We had bruschetta as a starter. In the past, I have had ma’s lasagna for dinner and the Sicilian pepperoni rolls as an appetizer, both also very good.

Fantastic lunch special! I was able to get a pizza and unlimited salad for only $11! Since my wife wanted the same lunch special they told us we could even share the pizza and they gave both of us an individual (unlimited) salad! They have fantastic service here and my wife absolutely loves their gluten free Pizza! They were so accommodating to what toppings we wanted on them too! 100% recommend Old Chicago!

This was our first time there and we will definitely be going back. The service was wonderful and the food was absolutely amazing! We barely had to wait for any of our food.

Customer service was superb, couldn't have ask for better. Food was absolutely delicious. We work all over the lower 48 and always stop here when coming thru. Never been disappointed.
Thank you

Everything was absolutely delicious! The waiter was polite and did a great job also! We ordered the meatball sub, spaghetti and meatballs, sweet Asian chili chicken salad,aaron and cheese with brats and the dessert pizza cookie, and the dark chocolate cake! The cake and the macaroni were amazing! All food was so good! The full moon beer was good also.

This is our favorite go to meal place in Garden City! The food is great , and service is excellent always! As restaurateurs, we truly appreciate the hospitality! Thank you!

After along drive, we decided to stop for lunch. The restaurant was still pretty new, restroom was nice and clean, food and service was good. Thank you for the nice lunch.

Within walking distance of our overnight hotel stay in Kansas City, Kansas. Delicious, tasty pizza just the way you like it with your favorite toppings. Wings were good also, but didn't get a pic.

The spaghetti was phenomenal!! Hands down the best I have had in a long time. The other person in my party had the chicken fried chicken and they said it was phenomenal also. They get a 10/10 for sure. I do not know what they could do to be better.

Delicious pizza and sports on. Hard to beat that combo. I don't drink anymore but it looked like there was a very good beer selection. Would recommend.

Stopped here on a storm chase and we all had a big get together and the food, service and staff were amazing! Pricing was pretty on point and the location was great. Right near all of the hotels and stores.

Our server Nikki was so amazing, very attentive! The manager, I believe his name is Brandon, who went above and beyond. I didn't like the new chips that come with the dip, so they fried me some regular chips. HUGE win! Our food was hot and fresh, and the patio area was a great vibe for the weather! Overall, it was a great experience

Great food and great wait staff. Today though the hostess was having a bad day. Threw her pen down. Sat us at out booth. I said Thank very much and never responded. Never smiled.
I have bad days also but will always still smile at my customers. Actions speak very loud

I haven't seen or been to a bad old Chicago yet has always had excellent service.

Absolutely awesome food and a great atmosphere with a wonderful staff

Great food and atmosphere! Great service and good selection of beers that most places don't have. Will definitely be a regular!

I came in after a long day of work. Dirty and smelly and placed an order of spaghetti and meatballs with extra garlic bread to go and the hostesses and the waitresses by the front door we're outstanding. Treated me gracefully and went out of their way to take my order and get me out the door as quickly as possible and I couldn't have been happier. It's that type of customer service that will always have me come back and dine in when I'm clean... thank you everyone for being so kind.

We are from Utah and wish we had an "Old Chicago". It has great pizza (especially the thin crust), awesome cheese sauce and amazing sandwiches! Prices are a little high but it's worth it!