Pie Five Pizza

We came with about 45 min to get someplace. It was fast and delicious.
They serve personal size pizzas made to order. I had the high five and it was really good. My wife has the Margherita pizza and it was very good too.
Prices were reasonable and service was fast and friendly.

Update: stopped on my way thru town, had Mikes Sticky Finger pizza, did not disappoint!, but glad I dined in as it was on the messy side for sure. A little heat, a little sweet… Absolutely delicious!! (Tables could still use some attention.)

Great little pizza joint! Not a “quick” as traditional fast food, but considering it’s fresh and it’s pizza it came out rather quickly. Pizza was done by the time I ate my salad so perfect right!?! Service was on point, professional and thorough and seemed to be having fun amongst coworkers. Pizza was delicious, better than the chains for sure and not even close to being as greasy!! (Tables could be wiped off a bit better would be my only complaint).

Love this place. The 9in pizza is plenty for one!

Great staff good prices and the pizza is great

Kenny was so nice and efficient! We had a bigger order with lots of special requests and he was so kind and accommodating! The pizza was great and the service even better! Thanks for being so friendly Kenny! You’ve got Great employees, Pie Five!

My family is obsessed with it. I'm not a big fan but I've stolen a bite or two. It's just not the kind of pizza I'm interested in. It's that kind you'd find at a mom and pop restaurant. But unlike most mom and pop pizza places I go to I can eat this. So while I'm not a big fan myself I know others enjoy it.

Great pizza! Fast pizza! Good prices. Cauliflower crust is gluten free and you don't even know it is cauliflower. Delicious! Good kid's combo and price. Nice service. Love that i can pick my own ingredients.

It's subway for pizza. Prices are decent, especially if you like to pile on the toppings. And the flavor is good. The only complaint I have had is that with online/app orders, the pizzas generally aren't ready when they say they'll be.

Pizza was hot and fresh. Not greasy which I greatly appreciate. The manager named Lizzy knocked it out of the park. We can be difficult customers when the children act up, and she was nothing but patient and friendly.

Will be back!

The pizza was some of the best I've tasted in a while. It was new and different. I love the fact it only takes 5 minutes to cook. This place has potential to be one of the best fast food places in Garden City.

Love love love this restaurant. My other momma friend and myself always enjoy eating here. With three littles lunch time can always be a hassle. With one of the littles being gluten free, it is wonderful to have the cauliflower crust available. I personally enjoy the 9inch personal pizza, I love all toppings and they do not shorten you like some other places. Today I think I have 5 meats and 6 different veggies 😂 (I know your think what a pig) but the point is you can get whatever you want and it's not extra. If you have never been it like to compare it to subway, but just pizza you can pick anything you want on your crust. They are fast, clean, and healthy (well as healthy as you can get with pizza that is) but they do offer other items than pizza. It's a little more pricey than a greasy delivery pizza place but to us its soooo worth it!!

Monday Madness and the crew took it all in stride, the guy who created my pizza took it up a notch. Idk if trained, cooking passion or just making his day fun, but took his time adding toppings in a way that was almost artistic, (normally plopped on and tossed in the oven) mixed the toppings, balanced them asked, good? After each topping.
Manager jumped in the cook line during the rush and after it calmed down he came back out apologized for the "wait" and to check on how our lunch was

As soon as we walked in everyone greeted us. Very friendly staff. Food tasted amazing! Definitely going back! Love the order online option definitely great option to have for when you limited on time!

This place is a hidden gem! One of the best pizzas I've ever had. Staff was extremely polite and helpful. We will definitely be returning.

Live five is really good do people who work there are really nice. The energy they share just makes you happy. And when they bring out your pizza it’s the best thing!

Felt like trying something new and different so we tried Pie Five. It was so delicious with a friendly staff. 10/10 recommend. New favorite pizza place in Garden City!

A great pizza place! Staff is always friendly and courteous!
Wish they had their sandwiches still!

Excellent pizza at reasonable prices. Definitely worth a try if you like good pizza that you don’t have to wait a long time for.

Probably the closest you'll find to homemade pizza in Garden City! Very good food, and a personal pan will easily fill you up every time!

It's like subway...except it's pizza!! You can pick a style they have listed and you can customize it to your liking. Or just tell them what you want and they will make sure you get enough toppings.