Jake's Pizza Company

Hands down best pizza on the island, Jake single handedly puts all other pizza places to shame. Great cheese to crust ratio with the perfect amount of crunch 👌🏼 Highly recommend!

Had a sausage and onion pizza and it was some pretty delicious shore pizza. Will be back next time we're in Cape May

Best pizza/calzone/ Stromboli in Cape May county . Have recommended Jakes many times and never disappoints ! Even though he frowns apron lettuce tomato and onion in his Stromboli’s he did it anyway and was absolutely relishes !

Got a large pepperoni on lunch and was blown away so for dinner I ordered a Philly chicken steak pie and just devoured it. Great service, brothers 2 right next door is not good at all, will always buy from Jake's ,

The best pizza in Cape May. I Definitely recommend this place to every pizza lover. These guys really know how to make a proper pizza.

Having lived the majority of my life in the New York metropolitan area, I was not excited nor had high expectations for pizza made with Cape May water vs. NY’s stellar tasting water, but I was so pleasantly surprised by the pizza Jake’s delivered to my resort room while watching over the wife who was feeling under the weather. Cheese and sauce were very flavorful and the crust really surprised me. Great job guys…keep up the good work!!

Best $20 I spent in cape may, fresh hot and delicious pizza! If you are from north jersey you won’t be disappointed. Staff was so friendly too.

Jake's is the Best Pizza in Cape May. Great food especially the stromboli! Very friendly staff great service with a smile
You won't be disappointed

Had never been before. Needed something in a pinch and very glad I decided to go. The pizza is fantastic. Well seasoned and delicious crispy + flaky crust. Will definitely be back next time I’m in Cape May.

This pizza was better than expected. After 10+ years of Cape May we have never even seen this eatery and yet it was some of the best pizza that we have gotten. A little bit cheaper than Mario's and the pizza was overall pretty good. Very legit pizza and the staff was extremely friendly. More than ample outdoor and indoor seating allow for a large crowd. Highly recommend for the nights that other pizza places are very backed up.

Was craving New York style pizza… and Jake’s delivered ! Large cheese slices with just the right amount of herbs in the sauce. The best part: the pizza crust. The perfect ‘crunch’.

Mr Jake deserves a 5.0.

We've tried many pizzas in Cape May, and stumbled on Jake's a few years ago. Love this pizza! The sauce is perfectly spiced and delicious, the crust is crunchy and thin, and the pizza is scrumptious! All ingredients are fresh and homemade. Jake treats you well and asks for cash only...and who doesn't like cash? Highly, highly recommend Jake's!

Great pizza! Perfect crust, just enough sauce, young and melted mozzarella cheese, fantastic prices for Cape May, fun outdoor picnic table eating, and friendly fast service! What more could you ask?

Small town pizza place, always has great tasting food. I would reccomend a Stromboli for sure

Delicious Cape May pizza and excellent staff. Ordered 5 different pizzas and everybody raved on the quality and taste. Delivery was spot on for the time committed and pizzas were hot. Keep up the great work!

Jake's crust is possibly the best I've ever had, including the NYC shops! The toppings are abundant, you don't need to order extra. The sauce is really tomato-ey without being over spiced. The crust is just as crisp on a medium pie as it is for the large. There isn't enough I can say about Jake's, all good. By far the best pizza in Cape May if not anywhere. Prices are excellent as well. Cash only.

Really good plain pizza with good crust only a couple seats inside but some outdoor seating available. Wings are a good choice also.

For the past two years, my roommates and I have been on a quest... to find the best pizza in South Jersey. We’ve gone far and wide, from Camden to Cape May, in search of a holy pie. Jake’s Pizza is that pie. The crust, crisp but tender. The cheese, melted and gooey but firm. The sauce, ROBUST. To quote my roommates: “good mouth feel, quite excellent.” “Yum.” If you need pizza in South Jersey, there’s only one option: Jake’s.

I LOVE Jake's pizza. I buy a large pepperoni pie at the beginning of my trip and have it for breakfast every morning, really helps with a hangover. WAY better than domino's and yummy too

We recently found Jake's Pizza through a co-worker. It's the best around and the owner is a sweetheart