Sherrilli's Pizzeria

Pizza arrived hot, as usual. Super nice delivery person! The 9-10 year old here for a party love it! Thanks for keeping things the same- delicious! (Also love the discounts via text messaging!)

Dudes working here are very friendly... Try the house flavor wings!!!! They are straight money!! The pizza didn't look anything special but it was cooked perfect, then the crust was thin and crispy, just right on point!!! My kids absolutely loved the large soft pretzel with warm cheese.... Again props to the owners/management as these young dudes working were right on point with everything... Can't wait to stop back in next time we're in the neighborhood

I've been coming here for years, I've always loved their pizza! I love the consistency of their pizza, how I know anytime I order it's always the same (unlike other places where pizza is over/under cooked or something). Anytime my family gets together and we don't feel like cooking, it's always a convenient option in terms of price and that everyone loves the pizza! Highly recommend.

This was our first trip, but it definitely won't be our last. The pizza was delicious. I requested one of the pizzas be cooked well done, and it was cooked perfectly.

Always great pizza and fast friendly service. It’s rare to get takeout anywhere and not have something go wrong. Not the case at Sherilli’s. Consistently good food.

The people are very very nice and friendly. The pizza is so delicious and a very good prices!! We drive about 20 minutes and pass several other pizza places on our way to Sherrilli
's Pizza!!

We love the pizza but I specifically love the crustless pizza.

We love the pizza and the people that work here. Always speedy service and an amazing place to eat.

Friendly staff, did call ahead and told them what time I would pick up and as I walked in the door, they were pulling my pizza out of the oven. Very good food, service and quality for the price. See ya next week!

The food is so good and the buffet is always fully stocked and clean. Very nice staff.

The pizza here is super good. The thin crust, square shaped kind is how their pizza is. Which happens to be my favorite. The service couldn't have been any better either! The young lady who took care of us was extremely friendly and helpful!

Ordered delivery, even though I live in a different city the pizza arrived quickly and hot. The driver was awesome and the food was amazing. I had never had their chicken bacon ranch pizza before and almost finished the entire thing by myself. I can't say enough Good Things based on my first experience I'll definitely be going back.

I eat here often. Staff is friendly and price is right. My favorite pizza.

Love their pizza!!! We drive 30 miles to pick this up. Great food and friendly service ❤❤

We are big fans of Shirelli’s. We tried the garlic cheese bread on this trip and love it.

Great pizza, great service, great atmosphere, great people. Right on the money for a family outing, and beyond responsible pricing.

They have a Monday through Friday lunch buffet, and like 11:00 to 4:00 on Saturdays and all day Sunday buffets.
Always fresh hot pizza if they don't have what you want on the buffet they will happily make you what you want at no extra cost.
It's always been a good pizza for me and I've always had a really good experience there.

First time here. Employees friendly, clean inside, clean bathrooms. Delicious pizza! we’ll be back!

I’ve been looking for my “go-to” pizza place in southern Indiana & I’m pleased to have found it here!!

Pizzas were ready on time. Cooked perfectly. Person waiting on me was very friendly