Mazerella's Upper Crust Pizza

I had the honor of trying the food that these people are trying to pass this exquisite masterpiece off as “pizza”! This was the best item of food I’ve ever had. The taste, the texture, the attention to detail everything about this food was just so amazing. It’s unreal. This is well deserving of way more than five stars. This Pizza made me say “Papa Johns who?!?!” In conclusion This is the tastiest restaurant around by far. What an amazing experience at this restaurant. Oh, and also the night manager I believe it was Josh a very intelligent and nice guy.. He is a true professional…. Oh, and into the owner, what a fine business you have here I would be honored to be able to shake your hand!!

We drove 2.5 hours to shop at Bass Pro. We read a review and decided to try the pizza. We highly recommend the pizza and breadsticks!

Went to Mazerella's Pizza for 1st time less than one year ago, and their pizza is absolutely phenomenal! Their lunch buffet is certainly the best in town and food is fresh with a variety of pizza's everyday. Excellent food, and prompt service every time!

They have a great pizza buffet at lunch at an extremely reasonable price... $10 Cash & 11 with card. Includes the salad bar, buffet & a drink. Very clean restaurant with a friendly staff. Certainly one of the best kept secrets in the southern Indiana area.

We stopped in to try this place when we were in town. Upon entering, we were met by a kind employee that helped us make our decisions on what to eat. Pizza was really good. There is a pizza buffet, and most of the patrons were dining from the buffet. There is also a small, basic salad bar available. We ordered a pizza, breadsticks, and a dessert pizza.
Space is limited. We squeezed four people around a table, but didn’t have a lot of room for eating. A couple of patrons were just holding a plate on their laps and eating.
If we venture back through this community, we will likely dine here again!

This was my first time here. I've tried many different pizza places across the country and this one by far is the best. I ordered a Meatza Calzone and an order of Maz Best Breadsticks thinking they wouldn't be that filling so I would have both. The Calzone was big enough for 2 people to eat, the Breadsticks were huge too there were 6 of them. Everything tasted fantastic! This is my new go to place for a Calzone when I'm in the area. 5 stars all the way!!

Just had your small big z delivered by doordash. Man your pizza was awesome. That little pizza filled me up thank you

Wow great pizza and salad choices. I went for lunch and went with the buffet to try all the different types of pizza. You won’t be disappointed with the taste!

This place is awesome. It is always fresh, hot, and tastes great . The staff has always been super friendly, even when your the last customer and they waited to close one night so i could pick up my food, lol . But seriously, it's a good place to eat, either in or takeout. Ive never had delivery so i cant speak on that.

Great food first time there and its up there with the best pizza I have had. Thin crust is the best here. Stays crunchy even with a ton of toppings. We had the Big Z pizza. Highly recommended. Will be back!! On par with Bearnos. Each place has its pluses both well worth the money!!!

I’ve been eating at Mazerella’s for many years! Love the meat lovers pizza!! Great meatball subs as well. I’ve never had the buffet but it looks delicious!!

My all time most loved ever .... The pizza they put out is no joke. If you never been then you are missing out on some amazing bread sticks and cheese and then ahhhh we get to the pizza. I swear the whole place is a 9.5 /10. Id id give it a 10 but i deducted .5 because I can't eat there every day. 😂 By the way I was the ice guy who always called ahead!

This place is absolutely fantastic...so great in fact I took a job there delivering food for them. The people are great. It does get very busy but I promise you the food is 1000% worth the wait. Everything is made fresh to order and all ingredients are fresh. Try the big z, you will not be disappointed if you are an "everything" person. It hits every taste sensory, be warned tho, it's heavy and if your not a leftover person then this big boy is not for you. I hope you give it a try

My husband loves their lunch buffet and I always get their meatball sub! Always delicious and if we deliver always on time with polite delivery guys!

We found Mazerella’s because of the great online reviews. And they did not disappoint. Craig and his team were timely and the pizza was tasty and fresh. Mmmmm. Mmmm. I wish we lived close by so we could eat here often.

Never disappointed! Love that you deliver to us and food is always delicious! Whoever made our pizza tonight, that was the best darn hand tossed double pepperoni I've had in a looong while. (not saying it doesn't always look like that, we just usually order a different pizza.) You all are rock stars! Thank you!

Mazarella's is one of my favorite pizza restaurants. I am a frequent customer, and I always anticipate the delicious food they serve. Highly recommend!

The pizza is great. Crust is so soft and fluffy, sauce is great, ingredients are great. Wish I didn't wait so long to try this place!

Delicious! I had the pizza buffet today which had breadsticks, salad, and pizza of course! 😂🤣 So good! Plus, it's conveniently located by my work. I'll be back!

Delicious pizza that we randomly tried when driving back to Charlestown State Park campgrounds! Took less than 20 minutes to make, pizza was delicious (even good warmed up next morning) and most reasonably priced pizza joint we have seen! Definitely will hit when camp there again!