Mama Nita's Pizza

Stumbled into the place by accident. Was in line for subway and the 15 dollar subs did not seem worth it! I opted for the buffet. It was awesome and salad bar was fresh and well stocked and good.

Very fun and friendly atmosphere. The prices are much more reasonable than other pizza shops in town and the food is superior.
The buffet is always fresh at peak meal times, but is available all day. The employees are always happy to freshen it up :) Cheese sauce is available upon request. The bacon barbecue chicken is awesome!

Awesome service and the food was excellent. The salad bar was delicious and the pizza was divine. You are the Best!

This is my absolute favorite pizza place. Very friendly, amazing food. A queer-friendly place in an otherwise not-so-accepting town.

This is my favorite place to eat in New Palestine.

Update: still my favorite spot. I come here every time I pass through. I love the staff. They are friendly but don't make you feel awkward if you don't have time to have a long conversation.

I hadn't heard of this place until I recently received a coupon & decided to give them a try today. So glad I did! Employees were friendly, delivery was quick, prices were reasonable & everything we ordered was delicious. Thank you for an all around positive experience. Mama Nita's is my new go to for delivery. And that bacon cheeseburger pizza is fantastic!

The service is awesome. The atmosphere was friendly. I ordered a specialty pizza, a 10" with EVERYTHING. It's so delicious! The many cheeses made the pizza tasty. I will be back often! Thank you!

We ordered 2 pizzas they were both wrong hour n half delivery. Called store talked to manager he had them remade and were to us in 30 minutes. We live 16 minutes from store. Had a long day lots of errands and family events. Manager made things right kids have full bellies. We took care of the deliver drivers. I love this place never once had an issue and when we did they went above and beyond. Would recommend to anyone even if it's a drive for you.

When calling in, or picking up my orders all my dealings with the employee's, is always poistive experiences.
Hot, yummy, & great tasting food! They have the best pizza's, never oil soaked, or leaking through the pizza boxes. The classic brushed butter, & garlic bread stick's, aren't chunks of chewy hard dough. Other items on menu sandwiches, salads, pasta, & the list goes on, alway's are hot, fresh, & BEST tasting. I highly recommend Mama Nita's! Great food, & experiences!

Very friendly staffand the buffet was well stocked with hot pizza. If you have a certain preference they will make it for you and put it on the buffet. I recommend the BBQ. My only complaint is the cups are maybe 16 oz and I had to get a refill 5 or more times

Very recently went to the buffet and we had absolutely no complaints. We were a little worried because we had heard they changed management. We are asked what pizzas we'd like on the buffet and they made exactly what we wanted. They also seem to have changed the hot ranch to a more tolerable buttermilk ranch which I love and appreciate so much. When we were ready for dessert, my husband discovered that they brought back ice cream sandwiches to the big freezer (HUGE plus!) and they made one of the most delicious dessert pizzas I've ever had. Of course we'll be back, and we really appreciated all the changes they've made.

We ordered 2 pizzas and a calzone. Everything tasted amazing and was prepared just right.
The toppings were abundant and the taste was fresh and herbaceous on both calzone and za. The crust: 4/5, tasty, a little chewy on hand-tossed. Sauce: 5/5, unique and zesty. Toppings: 5/5. The bacon=🤤 cheese was abundant!!! 💯 also, those banana peppers were über alles!
With a carry-out deal of buy one large, get one 50% off, this will be the new pizza joint for us.

Great food, great prices, Not just pizza.

We got the family portion of the fettuccine alfredo. It's a good size, we liked it, the kids liked it. Awesome fresh Italian salad. The staff is friendly, and our carryout order was ready on time.

We each ordered a 7" pizza of our choice. They were delivered to our table hot. We all agreed the pizza was delicious. We dined in and it wasn't as busy as I thought it would be for a Saturday night. A few people came in for carry out while we were there.

Tonight was a different experience than my 1st hence now a 5 from a 2. Pizza was flavorful and well baked with lots of cheese and the right amount of sauce. You should be okay with any pizza from here but be cautious about ordering the Mediterranean Veggie... it was not good in my opinion. Mama Nita's will be my go to local pizza.

After moving from New Palestine to downtown Indy, it has been quite awhile since I've been at Mama Nita's.

Very happy we went. The bread sticks were delicious and it's nice that there are individual cups of cheese and marinara sauce out for dipping.

The pizza selection/variety was great. From basic pepperoni to their specialty pizzas. Really delicious.

Oh...and of course there's the salad bar for the greens...and most of all...the DESSERT PIZZA!

Had five wonderful women working tonight and they did an awesome job! You could tell that they were busy but they worked so well together!!! Keep it up! Wish I could have you all work for me at my restaurant! Your teamwork shows!

I love Mama Nita's Pizza they have always been so good to my family and me! These people make all of there customers and workers feel like one big happy family! I love that they have a little freezer with ice cream in it so people can have a nice little thing of ice cream along with some delicious pizza!
Thank you Mama Nita's Pizza for being so good and friendly!

We stopped in on our way through NewPal and got a pizza. It was delicious was in Greenfield the next day and happen to see they had another location. Stopped in for lunch and had the buffet and it was so good they have good desert's too!!

Establishment is well lit, clean and cozy Pizzas were fresh and there was a wide variety
Staff were pleasant and accommodating.
Prices are more than fair.
Ice cream sandwich for dessert included in the price