Anglers Restaurant & Proper Pour

The owner and I go way back from my bartending day's. He and his brother use to come hang out with me. Have been going to his family's restaurant for many years. Steve, George and Michael were all hoot's. Awesome food and spirits. Nice family atmosphere on one side. On the other side more of a ambiance vibe. May God rest your soul Steve.

The seafood buffet tonight special was great! You always do a great job on your food and service. The old fashioned drink is one of the best. Keep up the great work.

The catfish basket was excellent, my daughter loved the shrimp tacos, my husband ate his whole mushroom and Swiss burger and the ribeye was good. The service was Great and the atmosphere was great. I will definitely come back and recommend to all my friends 😊

Spur of the moment decision to come here. No regrets at all. Both food and service was excellent. Best smelt I've ever had. And I've had a lot over the years. Definitely coming back. And it was located less than 10 minutes from the Indiana Beach Campground.

OMG ....If you have never been to the restaurant in Monticello, In you are definitely missing out. The food was absolutely wonderful, the service was excellent, and the atmosphere was relaxing. I don't live in the area but I'm town almost every weekend. And this us where I like to eat. You all need to come in and see for yourself. They also have a full bar.

Food is always excellent!!! Last 2 times I've had the breaded tenderloin. It's a meal by itself.. previously had catfish and fries. It was super good!!!!!

Cornbread and cabbage was very good. Excellent service by waitress.

Great food, service and atmosphere. Steak special for two included appetizer, salad or soup, and two sides. The soft warm pretzel with cheese was really good, Steak was seasoned very well and cooked to order. Great value for the quantity of food. This was our first visit. We will definitely be back.

Great food, great atmosphere, great experience! I miss the old salad bar, but everything else was awesome! Thank you!!

My husband was going to meet me at Indiana Beach and took a wrong turn. He went in to this restaurant to ask for directions. The people he talked to were helpful and he decided it would be a good place for dinner. We had the best server and unfortunately I can't remember her name, but I am guessing great service is not a rarity here. My husband thought the broccoli cheese soup was the best he had ever had. He got the fried chicken special and said it was the best chicken he had had. He also liked the jalapeno cornbread. I use a walker and when we left the hostess opened both exit doors for us. This place really deserves MORE than 5 stars and we will certainly be going back.

Amazing place!! A MUST when visiting Monticello!!! Great food (amazing quality and presentation), prices are so reasonable as well as affordable and amazing service!!!! The owners are truly hands on checking on all customers and the staff is very efficient in all areas. Food timely and cooked to perfection, while service didn't skip a beat. Thanks for such an amazing experience.

Great place for some tasty fish. We got the Opa appetizer that came with pita bread and catfish.

We were in town after being at the park all day, and needed a place to eat later in the night with kids. Called and asked if they could accommodate our party of 13 only about 45 min before they closed and they said absolutely. We had the best service ever! The staff was so accommodating for our little ones 3rd bday; they all came out to sing him happy bday and even did a “bday shot” with him lol it was so cute and special! The food was delicious and very fairly priced. Caribbean chicken & shrimp, potato skins & hush puppies were highlights. Drinks were delicious and they even crafted a special drink for me. Will definitely return when we’re in town. We were so grateful for their warm service and awesome hospitality!

Atmosphere and employees were amazing!
Food was delicious and filling. Been awhile since weve had drink actually made properly by a business and they knock it out of the ballpark with ours! Lovely staff, great portion sizes and right by the lake. Lovely stop for dinner and a drink.

Excellent staff and the best salad bar in town! Coconut shrimp for me and gyros for him.

This place has been our 'go to' for dinner in the Indiana Beach area. The chopped steak is delicious, but they have a variety of options. The fresh rolls are a treat as well. It was nice to see a new selection of cocktails on the menu.

Great atmosphere! Awesome staff and amazing food!! Bartender Don was so entertaining and really interacted with the customers. He made great drinks and really knew what he was talking about! Would definitely recommend checking this place out! We're big foodies and this place definitely checks all the boxes!!

Very good place to eat. Nice people and good prices. Love the atmosphere.

Took my husband here for Father’s Day today. We both got the steak and shrimp dinner special and it was amazing. Thank you anglers staff for making Father’s Day special for my husband ❤

The recent updates are great! Super clean. Very happy to see a family dining side. We look forward to going back with the grandkids. The owner, management, and staff were very friendly. As out-of-towners we felt very welcomed. Our food was really good. Don't hesitate to go!