The Bay Pizzaria

Really really nice pizza. Pizza base and ingredients all outstanding. Friendly staff and beautiful dine in area . Must try when you visit the area.

Our family consider ourselves pizza connoisseurs so when we saw The Bay it was natural that we had to stop.

The restaurant was filled with people making connections over what looked like pretty good pizza.

Our wait for takeaway was 40 mins but the wait was easily fixed- we just took the dogs for a walk along the foreshore.

The Bay pizza was well worth the wait.

A crust that was crisp but not too thin or thick. A good selection of toppings and just enough cheese that the flavours weren't overwhelmed.

It was so darn good we went back a couple of days later for another, this time at lunch. We only waited 10 mins and it was just as good as the first.

If you're down this way make sure you visit; you'll fall in love with their pizza!

Crayfish pizza was yummy .. I don't usually eat desert but we also ordered the biscoff pizza .. again yummo.

We had a spicy buffalo chicken pizza and hot chocolate today.It was super delicious and we recommend it to everyone who love pizza 🍕 😋Thank you so much team for providing excellent customer service.. Good luck !

We stopped and had lunch here. The place looks really good for a little country cafe. The food is really good. We ordered a few dishes. The garlic and cheese flatbread was delicious, spicy buffalo chicken pizza smelt as good as it tasted. The honey soy chicken wings were cooked well, nice and crispy but could do with a bit more sauce, that sauce was too good. The marshmallow pizza was just perfect 😋😋😋 customer service was outstanding. The cocktails were good as well. 🍹🍹

OMG!!! The crayfish pizza is delish!!! The first ever tried and definitely a flavour bomb! We also had the Prawn Star pizza and was great too! Love the pizza dough. Not dry and cooked perfectly. Also had the finger licking good wings - both in House BBQ and Honey Soy seasoning. Definitely worth a place to visit! 👍

We love their pizza so much. Best pizza we ever tasted. The mixture between juicy and crunchiness is a kick. Highly recommended cafe if anyone explore an eatery at Port MacDonnell.

Well the girl I'm seeing must have enjoyed it because she asked me to go official after eating here. Must have been the pizza.
Vegan options are good. Pizza is delicious. Good range of drinks. If it wasn't nighttime, the view of the beach would have been even better. The staff were friendly. Would 10/10 add them to FB. Footy was on- big plus.

Wow, saw the reviews here so decided to try. Big statement but the best pizza we have ever had! We had the veggie and vegan veggie pizzas. If you are nearby or at Mount Gambier definitely worth the visit for pizza by the water 💯✅

Amazing restaurant with great food and good service. Prices are great also.

Came here for a feed after snorkeling at Ewen Ponds. The store looks nice with various seating options indoor and outdoor. We ordered a few dishes which all tasted amazing. The service here was very friendly.

Visited The Bay Pizzaria as it was recommended by someone in Mount Gambier. It did not disappoint and I highly rate their pumpkin pizza.

One of the best pizzas we've ever had. Generous on the toppings and superb with their service. They even helped me when my shirt got stained from the sauce cause we were just loving their food. 😄 Atmosphere is wonderful, too with a great view of the beach.

Lovely atmosphere and friendly staff the mini grazing board was delicious and the pumpkin pizza was divine with the pumpkin having been marinated in maple syrup and chargrilled adding a completely different element to the pizza complete with a marscapone base. My partner and I shared a pizza and the grazing board and we had an ice coffee and an ice chocolate both were very nice as well. Our friend had the tandoori chicken pizza which looked fantastic and he said it was as well :) we will be back again.

Absolutely great place. Staying just south of Mount Gambier, so this is only 20mins drive. Pizzas were delicious - I had the cray cray special - lovely and fresh and so tasty. Mine disappeared down my stomach too fast for me to stop for photos. Also really nice cocktails. For the indecisive they also do half and half pizzas. Definitely recommend.

We skipped over one age due to surcharge on the public holiday, and settled on Nay Pizzeria. Turns out they also had the surcharge, but I'm glad we skipped that first place.

I had a lime milkshake which actually came with ice cream, a rare treat for milkshakes these days.

The main dish was the 3 Little Pigs pizza, which had a delicious bacon jam on it.

I would 100% recommend this place, even with the surcharge !

Couldn’t fit the pizza in after having the Grazing Board. After stopping here for coffee on our last visit here, a return visit was always an option. The food was delicious, especially the Chilli Jam. Having a Porter ( dark beer) on tap just made the trip complete, not forgetting a take away coffee to sip on the way home.
I guess another visit for a Pizza is next….

12 months on from our last visit and the pizzas still havent disappointed.

Stayed in Port Macdonnell for the weekend - attended the Generations in Jazz 2023 festival - and needed a quick bite to eat. The pizza's were fantastic, hard to separate between the crayfish and meet the meats pizza. Crayfish pizza won narrowly. Service was excellent too.

Great atmosphere,exceptional and friendly staff
Pizzas perfectly cooked and very tasty…

Legit the best pizza within miles 💯.
Great staff, they are potentially few better place open till late on the remote location.
Just too good just cannot praise enough.