The Toy Pit

Store is amazingly awesome! I’m 47 years old, and just to walk through here brought back so many nostalgic memories of my childhood that I cannot help but to thank these guys for the respect of the iconic toys!

I will be back!

P.S. The staff is friggin awesome too! Just an added plus. ✌🏾

This place is epic! So many collectibles to look at! We definitely are going back because we need more time to look. The guys that own/work there were extremely helpful and super nice! I highly recommend checking the store out for epic finds!

I go to the toy pit every weekend and there are always new things there. They have a wide variety of different things, but for me what makes it cool are the nice workers and GODZILLA things they have. I always have a good time if I’m getting something or just looking around.

Awesome toy shop. I would highly suggest visiting the parking lot sale. Fantastic bundles of 3 for 15 and 3 for 30. A huge selection inside with very fair prices. A must visit for any collector. Very friendly staff. Will be returning when I have more time!

Best selection of Funko pops I’ve ever seen! Super helpful staff. I always find myself coming back to look for more to collect!

We have been coming to Toy Pit for about 5 years. Friendly, helpful and informed staff have always been consistent in our visits over the years. They’ve always had a great selection of all around toys both vintage and new. Toy Pit is my favorite all around toy store in America and definitely Indiana.

From outside and as you walk in the front door, this place does not seem like it's going to be well organized. Once you're in the store, you realize that they have a very wide selection that is well organized and clearly priced. There is a huge selection of pop figures, and lots of classic action figures and collectibles. Overall, this is a really excellent store for toy collecting and memorabilia.

I did business with The Toy Pit out of necessity, having found them as a result of one of their eBay listings. In this particular case, it was for the sake of a rarely seen 2003 Gotham City Darkstorm Batmobile incl. Darkstorm Batman. While it was priced accordingly, they shipped it on a Tuesday and I got it in SC on Thursday.
Upon receipt, I immediately opened her up, and gave it a good inspection. After a simple wipe down with a baby wipe, she was shining like a jewel. And I was just so ecstatic to be holding this piece after trying to find it for a year, I just needed to give The Toy Pit a call.
I was lucky enough to speak to Stockton, and he was just as congenial as could be. Thank y’all for the opportunity and the fast turn around. I hope to do business with these folks again.
Please check out my Instagram content featuring this piece.
IG: ActionFigureAWD

Best place around for action figures and records. fire hip hop selection and fair prices. best collectible shop in the Midwest hands down

My son is really into action figures and collectibles, he found this place after searching and visiting many other shops. The staff is extremely kind and talked to him and treated him like an adult by answering his questions and showing him around the store. They showed him all the options for what he was looking for and asked about his interests! The store itself is very clean and well organized! He paid with his own money and used manners, the staff threw his a free t shirt afterwards for checking them out! We will definitely be back!

Amazing store they keep a good variety of items to appeal to all interests prices are great and staff is always super helpful and friendly always prepared to help you get stuff off of high shelves and do it with a smile I couldn't recommend this place more

Nice friendly staff and helpful to what I was looking for. Will be recommending to friends. Mark and Stockton are outstanding.

The selection was incredible and they were super friendly. They had a lot of cool anime stuff

As a seller: Great place, great people, great owner. Really amazing to find a true deal for your prized treasures. So happy to see somewhere that knows the value and place for so many cool and unique pieces.

The Toy Pit is such a cool store!! Great selection of toys for all types of fandoms. There is something here for everyone! The staff are always kind, welcoming, and helpful when I stop in. Prices are reasonable, and I love the wide variety of items with certainly lots of awesome toys, but also video games, records, and vintage clothes. They also host meet-n-greet events with celeb guests from different fandoms. I love their TMNT and Power Ranger selection. Pictures don’t do this place justice, but I’ve added a few here…I encourage folks to check this place out! The Toy Pit is the premier vintage toy store in the Indianapolis area!

I brought in several items to sell and they were very attentive to what it was worth and its selling factor. I know it would have taken me forever to sell them for more in the private sector. These guys are great, and the Trade-In was even better. I recommend this place. Also, they have a LOT of things to buy. Go visit!!! You won’t be disappointed!!!

Stopped in on a whim and now I can't wait to drop by regularly to see what's new in store. The sheer scope of the variety of products is overwhelming! It's like wandering through a nerd museum in the best sense of the term. There's going to be something in the store for every interest and with how frequently they get new inventory it's certainly worth visting time and time again to see what new treasures await! The staff was very kind, welcoming and friendly, definitely made the whole experience that much more pleasant. 5/5

This place is awesome... All the old collectibles you could ever imagine. My son was looking for a transformer toy and found hundreds of them in the store. The owners were kind and enthusiastic about their business. They let us pick out a free t shirt from a box. This place reminds me of the toy shop at the corner street, unlike the cold Toys R Us that we are so used to now. Go visit it and get something to remind yourself of childhood again.

This place had so many pops, marvel, transformers, and so much more. We visited Indiana from Japan and were interested in checking this place out from the reviews. When we went, the staff was so friendly and helpful. The young man working helped us find interesting transformer goods that we wouldn’t be able to find in Japan. They accommodated us and made us feel comfortable asking questions and taking our time. We will definitely be back! Thank you for the great experience!

This place is great! I had a flashback to a simpler time. Ah...the 80's. Toys were built to last, great quality and details. If I wasn't such a responsible adult, I would have bought way more than I should have! Great place, great friendly staff. Will stop by next time in the neighborhood.