Nothing New Thrift Shop

I have been going to nothing new thrift shop for several years, from their first locations to their latest location. Through the years, I have always dealt with the owner Jodi, who is an absolute ANGEL. Her staff are all wonderful as well. Dina, Nella & Faith are simply AMAZING. They are friendly, personable, helpful, and accommodating. When you walk into nothing new thrift shop, you’re not just going there to buy secondhand, it’s like catching up with friends. You’re always greeted with a smile and they genuinely seem happy to see you. I will be a customer there for the rest of my life.

I really love this store, even though I don’t live nearby. Great things, great prices, owners are very friendly! Every time I leave with my purchases I am delighted! Thank you, guys!!

You name the item and odds are Jodi has it at her store. Mainly home decor ,pictures, books , candles , silverware /dishes etc. Even a spacious basement choc full of childrens toys and Christmas decor. Staff is super friendly. During my last venture , I scooped up these 3 candles. It’s not a expensive place either . There’s always a sale going on …Check it out— you won’t be disappointed

This is a great place to find tiny treasures or massive dressers. I always find something.
It's also a great way to give a new life to gently used items. Some items we picked up for our granddaughter were a table lamp, a cupie doll, and Raggedy Ann and Andy wall mounts.

I always have the best time when going to Nothing New to shop! Jodi and John are amazing and their staff Nella and Dina are just incredible and very friendly. When you walk into nothing new you will always find something new and incredible! There’s always something great to find! I would recommend Nothing New to Everyone! This is the best place to shop in Staten Island, better than department stores!

Outstanding organization and pleasant people. Today was my FIRST time visiting this store. Also, this was a sale day by two things and get one free. There are a lot of things and it has two floors. VERY VERY VERY WELL ORGANIZED. I will return to buy some more items and to donate in the near future.

I’m not sure why it’s not posted online, the fact that it was closed or they have moved. (Sign says “we moved across the street” but across the street was a veterinarian clinic). At least post the new address. The restaurant blocked off that portion. But thank you for replying will be passing by. Thank You

This is the best thrift shop in Staten Island. The staff is so nice and helpful, and the owner is just the sweetest lady ever. They are always getting in new stuff and if you're looking for something they don't currently have, they are almost always able to let you know when they do get it in. In addition to having all the awesome thrift-store finds, they are moving two doors down and will be having a coffee shop inside too! Every first Friday of the month, they also have an open mic that is open to everyone. I go every month and always enjoy myself, hope to see you there!

I went to this thrift store today not really knowing what I wanted and not sure if I would get anything, I left with enough stuff to decorate a entire wall in my bedroom!!! The best part about it is that I got it all at a extremely low price! The customer service was incredible! The woman who helped me was so nice and friendly. I will definitely be going back there again!

Always a fun time shopping at Nothing New. Jodi and staff display the merch beautifully. I always come home with one of a kind finds at super cheap prices. Designer Clothes, fashion jewelry, toys, fancy home goods, art and furniture. You name it. And on top of that, they run sales.

One of my favorite thrift stores! Everything I’m wearing in this picture comes from this store.. Tommy Hilfiger sandals, Liz Claiborne dress and the highlight is the Authentic coach bag! The dress and the sandals i got from their $20 Fill a bag promo which is definitely my favorite! Tons of selections and very nice and generous people 😊 follow their Instagram account for recent updates! nothingnewthriftshop 😊

This seemingly off the path mom and pop shop is a real treasure trove of good quality stuff, well taken cared of by the owners, donated and selectively curated by the owner. The rotation of goodies is always fresh, so visit the shop once a month or two and you are bound to find something new that catches your eye. The prices are more than reasonable. If donating your stuff, do ask the owner first, don't treat it as a trash dump for unwanted stuff.

This thrift store is my favorite place to shop. I must have been in there at least an hour. I brought a friend with me who lives in N.J. and she was very impressed as well. The store is organized and the ladies were friendly and accommodating. There are so many interesting things in there. Make sure you have time to shop. So many good finds.

Despite it being a little cluttered, overall it was great! The owner is a very wonderful person, her store has a variety of things here and there from home goods to clothes. Make sure you go downstairs and check out the rest. Thumbs up! great place.

Very nice experience. Jodi is very sweet and helpful. The quality of the products are amazing, the atmosphere is very welcoming- loved the music and incense, and the shopping is hassle free. I will definitely be back. Even got a complimentary cookie on my way out.

Great place, clean, organized, decent prices. Look forward to going there whenever in Staten Isl. Love the other one too!

Such a cute little shop with tons of hidden treasures. The staff is the absolute sweetest and everything is priced sooo reasonably. Made a trip over the bridge from Jersey to check them out and it was more than worth it. Follow them on Instagram to keep up with their daily additions. Thanks for an enjoyable thrifting experience ladies!

Visited this shop a few times now. Very well organized and they have lots of cool things. Best part for me is the people working there are super nice and attentive and always helpful. Definitely recommend.

My mom and I are visiting from North Carolina and we love thrift shopping so we stopped in today. Let me just say, I am so glad we did!! The store is awesome and the staff is soooo friendly and kind! I found some fun treasure and the prices were great!! I definitely recommend giving this thrift store a look and follow them on Instagram! Thank you to the owner and staff for being so friendly and helpful!! We loved meeting you!!

Stopped here while I was visiting the area and received such a warm welcome. Everyone was so friendly and there were many nice items for sale. This store is a gem!