Shelby's Sugar Shop

It’s wonderful! Upon walking in, it’s a sensory paradise, visually, it’s so colorful & inviting, the scents of chocolate, coffee & sugary delights made me feel like a child again. They candy I have seen since I was young made me happy. Could decide what to buy, I finally picked the key lime ice cream….AMAZING!!!!!!! Will be visiting here when I visit Youngstown.

As soon as I walked in it smelt like coffee and candy, it was amazing! It was like I walked into sugar heaven, candy everywhere! Some things were a bit expensive (5 dollars for a coin about the size of my palm, which I have tiny hands so it's not very big) but some things are great! I found a mini bag of chocolate coins and I saw some other candies like wintergreen icebreakers and they even have CAKE! I loved this place, would recommend going.

Actually amazing! So many sweets and so cute! I just love all the taffy flavors! Going back tomorrow! <3

I go here once a week and get my favorite gummies!! Yes a little pricey but totally worth it! And they have deals sometimes which is awsome!! I am obsessed!! 😆😆😍❤

Very good selection and value. The staff is not only present but helpful. Your presentation is what drew me in at the Southern Park Mall location

amazing! So cool and so cute! Going tomorrow!

Good as southern park Mall gets.

great ice cream good candy

Great candy, great prices

Nice employees

They have boxed gift sets. Pricey $$, the sweets aren't made by them, they're purchased, my buckeye was a tad stale , kinda crumbley. Cute store, kids will like it.

Very expensive. Spent $43. Candy is ok. The Chocolate covered pretzels were stale. They need to seal the chocolate candy better so it doesn’t go stale. But Good customer service.

A nice selection of different candies, old and new, but slightly overpriced. I can find a lot of this stuff cheaper at any candy shop in PGH. I bought a couple of their truffles, as they looked nice, but unfortunately they were awful. The chocolate is mediocre at best, and they tasted almost nothing like their corresponding flavors. What even stranger... If you inspect them, it's almost as if they are buying cheap truffles that are already filled and coating them with flavored and/or colored chocolate... Whether the store themselves or the company. Either way, this method being used creates a two layer chocolate shell that is very hard and unpleasant to bite through. It also means the balance of chocolate to filling is entirely off. These were just bad. And at like... $2.50/pc? I can go to Sinful Sweets in PGH and get on-the-spot hand-made truffles all day for that price that are half the size but knock these out of the park. And I know there are similar places in the Youngstown area. This place is nice if you're looking for something novel in the mall. But don't let it fool you, this is someone's flimsy pet project that they threw together.

Very very stale you should sample everything before you buy it.