Decoy Restaurant

My husband and I had a great meal. We both had the fish fry. It was cooked perfectly with green beans and your choice of a side. There are 12 side options. The meal also comes with a salad and bread. The waitress was wonderful and such a lovely atmosphere. Very reasonably priced. We will be back soon for prime rib on Saturdays.

After getting to Seneca lake at 12pm...hitting a couple of wineries and Muranda Cheese Co. We came here to eat....OMG! SOOOO GOOD! I got the scampi in garlic sauce...could not stop eating! I was with four other people and they all enjoyed their entrees so much! Hailey was a great waitress and the whole staff was amazing! Will definitely come back in the future!

Little restaurant on the Seneca wine trail. Great food, good portions and our server was very attentive. Breaded mushrooms and mozzarella sticks were tasty. It was prime rib night and wow! It was huge! Cooked to medium rare as ordered and was very good. The au jus that came with it added the perfect amount of saltiness. My husband loved his chicken parm - 1/2 inch thick breaded chicken breast with yummy melted mozzarella on top served over spaghetti. He was full about 3/4 through his meal but liked it so much he finished it! Meals came with a salad and a side. We'd definitely visit again! Of note is that they don't take reservations.

The food was great, There was a bit of a wait, but for a small restaurant it was worth it.

Delicious prime rib & italian food! Great owners and staff, very cozy atmosphere. Always a fun and yummy time at the decoy!

We sat outside on a beautiful Friday afternoon. The atmosphere was nice and "supper club" like. Service was great! Local wine choices were on the drink menu. All the food was delicious. I never had chicken medallions and I would recommend trying them! The pasta Primavera was a favorite at our table. Our daughter loved the boneless wings. Actually we all did!

They have the best food around. It's a great family setting to get out and enjoy some really great food. They staff is amazing and goes all out to make sure every experience you have there unforgettable.

We are able to get in and be seated quickly. The waitress was very attentive. It was the best fish fry I have ever had in my life... Amazing!!
A very large portion, one meal you could feed two people!

Was there sat 9/23 and had prime rib. Service was spot on as well as the food, meat was cooked exactly how I wanted. Only issue is I wish they were in my hometown 😏. Drive from Horseheads is not bad!! Great place

We had dinner here on our first night to Watkins Glen. The Prime Rib dinner along with the cheesecake dessert was delicious, and service is exceptional. Local family owned restaurant, which is rare nowadays. We'll be back next time again 🙂

Reliable restaurant with friendly service, good food and a relaxed atmosphere. I have gone to this place for 30 years and it hasn’t changed a bit…which is why I always come back. The burgers are great and the pasta is excellent.

I love this place! Our server was great, friendly, funny too. I ordered the shrimp scampi and loved every bite. They have good drink options too. It's small inside, so try to beat the rush, or it'll be hard to find a seat.

The Decoy is really a gem! The people are wonderful and the food is great so far for us. We always do the take out meals. The burgers are up there with the best we've ever had. Excellent quality, nice and big and juicy, topped and cooked the way you want. The onion rings are also excellent. We also thinks it's one of the best fish fries we've ever had. I highly recommend this place for take out meals. Atmosphere inside as I have picked up my meals seems really nice, friendly and happy. People come in and eat at bar, and at tables and there is outside seating as well.

Unassuming little place but impressive service, great food and friendly atmosphere. Stopped in with a party of ten and was warmly greeted by the owner. Highly recommended 👌

😎 Absolutely 💯 worth it
Staff very helpful and knowledgeable. Will definitely return ✌

I am from Florida and this is the first time there. I just want to say that my meal was excellent and the French Onion soup was the best I have ever had. Our server, Lisa, was very attentive and served us with a smile.

The Decoy is a great local spot! The food was great and reminds me of home cooked food. The staff was so friendly and the atmosphere is very infectious with all the great people we had sitting around us. I would definitely recommend them if you are looking for a place to eat on Seneca Lake.

The food is great. The service is excellent. We hadn't been here in years. We are glad to find it's just as good as we remembered!

Delicious food and great service.

Wow! Nice little surprise! We didn't want to go all the way to WG or Geneva so we ended up here and what a nice surprise! The blackened Mahi and Shrimp scampi were amazing. Good portions and reasonable prices. Lovely service! Highly recommended!