Supreme Pizza & Seafood

Can’t believe this place is finally back. Great food, great portion sizes, great people. Will be recommending to as many friends and family as possible.

Clean inside and they know how to make good food! Easy and classic setup. Easy to miss but worth checking out.

Bask in the legendary return of Supreme Pizza - one of the Front Street's pizza and related food emporiums big 3. I suspect Romeo's and Pizza Academy are shaking in their ovens (albeit - legends in their own right).

Great pizza and subs! The employees have always been very helpful over the phone and in person. I got the wrong pizza once and they rushed me a new one, delivered for free. Their pizzas always have the highest quality ingredients like grilled chicken and fresh vegetables. Their cheeseburger subs and buffalo chicken subs are my favorite! Give the spicy curly fries a try too. Good selection of pastries, cookies and other desserts.

Great little spot to stop for subs, pretty good pizza, and some other stuff. Nothing too special but the staff are nice

Welcome baaaccck!!!!!...chicken parmesan sub,,, nice big portions,and very tasty. Keep up the great work supreme.

I just ate here for the first time and the food was OUTSTANDING! I had the Buffalo Tenders Sub with Curley Fries and was extreamly satisfied.

I ordered pizza from the competition across the street; however, when I went to pick it up I came to the realization that I had actually ordered from Supreme Pizza. We made our way across the street to pick the order up and I must admit, wasn't sure about the little pizza place. That was a few months ago and I am glad that I made that error! The food is amazing, and the folks that work there are always friendly and very professional! On our last visit, we had to wait for our pizza so we decided to try an order of buffalo wings while we waited. They were by far the best buffalo wings I have had. Crispy with a great flavor. I highly recommend you try Supreme Pizza, you won't be sorry!

I have been visiting Supreme Pizza and Seafood for many years now. I was impressed that the owner is almost always there, working side by side with his employees. He often gave me samples of new products he was trying, always looking to improve his ingredients and menu.
I have tried almost everything on their menu and each item is as fresh and delicious as the next.
I also noticed that they retain most of the employees for many years. I am sure that is part of their quality as the employees are knowledgeable on the menu and ingredients. The owner must treat them very well as very few restaurants can achieve this.
Try any item at Supreme Pizza and Seafood with great confidence and you will experience the wonderful service and food that I have. “Thanks Guys”

Great food! I eat vegan, and I was able to order a veggie pizza without cheese. I was incredibly impressed with how crisp the hand tossed crust was- normally I’m having to juggle all the soggy vegetables on the slice. Today I got the Vegetable Minestrone and it was so tasty! Flavorful, hearty and hot- perfect for a day like today. The staff are all friendly and the service is quick. The place is always clean and tidy. I’ll be coming back often for lunch.

This rating is for the gluten free pizza. Surprising..I know! O my gosh so good! How many times I glanced back at the box and was like , it cannot be😂. I did not get sick. It’s in a foil pan and has a buttery crust like a pan pizza. Seems like they make the dough themselves, not a cardboard pre- made crust. If you are gluten free give it a try!! One tip though..I liked it better with less toppings.

I rarely give reviews, but circumstances were such that my mother's day dinner was to be pizza. I have frequented Supreme for years for their amazing supreme sub, but not the pizza. Due to our preferred pizza venue being closed, we went for the hand tossed at Supreme. Wow! Perfect amount of sauce, cheese, toppings and crust was NY style good, and btw I'm from NY! I got a kick out of the previous review complaint about toppings falling off and having to wait for it to cool. If a pizza is fresh and hot with generous toppings, they will of course fall off. If you prefer a cold, stay in place cardboard pizza, DO NOT go to Supreme

Supreme is the real deal! Authentic and delicious food every time. My family & I have tried many of the dishes on the menu and always leave satisfied. It’s here you will find the best steak & cheese sub anywhere in the U.S., and also delicious pizza (best crust) fresh and bountiful salads, great fries, and of course fantastic seafood and pasta dishes! Supreme is no chain restaurant. This is fresh food made by folks who care!

What you’ll enjoy most about Supreme is not only the delicious food offered across their entire menu, but also the friendly and helpful staff. The entire crew from drivers, cooks, to the very hard working owner is on top of their game. Always being satisfied, we’ll be sure to make Supreme a part of our family meals for years to come.

Always friendly and on time. Their hand tossed pizza is amazing. We are yet to get an inconsistent meal.
Sean is so friendly on the phone and a little darling at the counter. Manny did a good job raising him!!!!

I've been a foodie for 30 yrs. When I returned to Exeter a yr ago I never thought I'd find the best fish n' chips at a local pizza shop. There's always plenty of consistently fresh haddock. Pieces are thick and the fried coating is delicious, it's never greasy..The fries are terrific too, not your run of the mill thin shoe string fries. 5 stars to these guys who are always pleasant & reliable.

of the mill shoe string

Absolutely delicious! I got the chicken gyro dinner, my fiance got a meatball parm calzone. We both haven't stopped wishing we ordered more to bring home! Stopping here really rounded out a great day of traveling (he drives a tow truck, we had to pick up something nearby), and made the trip home delightful. If we ever head back that way, you can bet your behind we'll be stopping here again! Easy online ordering, made fast. Love it.

Went in the other night with my children. The place was decorated way above average pizza places. Beautiful dining sets and artwork all around. The staff were extremely friendly! I had ordered pizza for the kids to split and i had gotten the haddock dinner. The portions were huge and the food was absolutely delicious! My kids are beggining me to go back for pizza there! Deffinetly our favorite pizza restaurant!

Supreme pizza is our favorite. They offer more than one kind of crust, (hand tossed is our favorite) and they do their best to cater to special requests and preferences. Both pickup and delivery are both time friendly, and their Rewards program makes it easy to save money and rack up points for coupons.
Entire menu is fabulous- from pizza to steak tips to pasta dinners you can’t go wrong :)

Best calzones, steak and cheese, pastrami subs, and the best feta cheese you'll ever try. Staff are extremely helpful and hard working. The open kitchen is very clean and they are always busy. Always had a great experience here.