The Pepperoni Grill BSL

This is such a little hidden Gem!!!!!!’ I’m giving 5 stars because I can’t give 10!!!! Nichole our server was so awesome!!! She made menu suggestions and overall just a complete joy to do business with. We are from out of state and truly enjoyed the food and OUTSTANDING service we received!!! Whoever is doing the cooking keep up the amazing work!!!! We will for sure be back to dine before we head out of town!

We stop by quite often to get their pepperoni pizza. Just this most recent time I decided to try their fried pickles… was not disappointed! Love this place. Food is always hot, take-out doesn’t take too long at all, and decent employees! 🍕❤

My boyfriend and I love this place, it is always good and the staff is always nice. Pizza never disappoints. I totally recommend this place.

Got 2 single slices of a specialty pizza the budda it is so good and fresh love this place. And the workers and so nice and amazing. No matter how busy you still get your stuff quick and it's always so good.

I came in got a menu and ordered a quick pizza for my granddaughter. She had some time between classes. Molly was so pleasant and was on top of it with a plate and napkins for her. Then I called and placed an order and one again. Molly was so pleasant taking the order and making sure she had the proper order and pick up time were correct. I came in and picked up dinner and I just can’t say enough about the crew and the food is amazing! Every time I come to see the grands I make sure I get food from there. Not only is the pizza on point but the salads are fresh and delish. Keep up the good work

This is our go to local pizza / Italian restaurant! They have a good variety on the menu of pizzas, sandwiches, and salads. We have pretty much had everything on the menu and it's delicious! The Italian stallion sub is my favorite and they let me switch the ham for turkey. Also and probably most important their ranch dressing is the best in town!

Great pizza, great price. It was close to our campground cabin.

My daughter and I loved this place. It’s a locals favorite. You’ll see BSL cops and businessmen pile in during lunch. That’s kinda a potential safety warning since some of these folks are “big boned” and the space is indeed limited. Other then that the food is always great. I brought myself and my family here more then enough in two months alone to make me consider a diet review, or at least a better belt. They’ve never messed up an order or skipped out on the level of service. They are very quick to learn who you are and what your order mostly.

Work of advice, get the wings. I know you don’t normally have them; but this time treat yourself boo.

The pizza is fabulous! They offer several daily specials. If you dine in they give you 4 garlic knots with dipping oil and they are so good! Beverages are self-serve and bottomless. Service is very quick. Seating is limited inside. It is our favorite pizza place!

Everything we have had from here as been delicious. The inside is small but does have a few tables if you want to eat in. We usually get ours to go. The staff has always been very friendly!

I always stop in for a pizza and garlic knots to take home when I'm in BSL. Love Pepperoni Grill!

I got their lunch special, which is 2 pieces of pizza and a drink for $8. Their slices of pizza are huge,

The best pizza I've ever eaten. The garlic knots alone will bring you back and the soft drinks are ice cold. The staff are like family. I love this place.

Great pizza, always fresh and made just right. I especially like the daytime 2 slice and drink special, always worth stopping in for...

The pizza is delicious and the garlic knots as well, soo soo good! The staff is always very nice, what else could you possibly want?

The woman behind the counter introduced their specials for the day which was honestly an awesome deal! Their small is a 16" for like $10-$11 but their special was a large pizza with garlic knots for $15, practically a steal! Food came out fresh, hot, and ready and the staff was extremely helpful and friendly! The pizza was pretty decent too!

Awesome slice deal, I will definitely return. The fact that they give you garlic knots with every order seals the deal! Top-notch NY pizza hole-in-the-wall! Go today if you have the chance!

Excellent pizza! Crust was perfect. The best garlic knots I've ever had! I need this pizza shop where I live!

Visiting Grandma who lives near here and have had pizza at a few places but this one was the best so far. The price is what it is but my review is for the food and the food was good. We had a veggie pizza and a pepperoni pizza. Get the large though if you think you'll be hungry.

If you're looking for good New York style pizza, this is the place. (If you're in the Billing Springs Lakes area) I live in Winnabow and drove past this very friendly eatery a thousand times and had no idea that there was a pizza jewel just waiting to be found. The staff is kind and courteous. And while I'm no so sure about this busy times, the were quite speedy with my order. There's not a lot of room to dine in and the parking can be a bit rough, but don't let that stop you from enjoying this great little slice of heaven.