Pizza Shop

Had the pleasure of eating here today with my kids. It was my 3rd time but had been awhile since my last visit. It was still as fantastic as I remembered! Location is great. Lots of parking nearby. The vibe is awesome and the views are incredible. The staff was friendly and attentive. But the food…. There aren’t enough adjectives to describe how great it was!! We ordered rice balls, meatball sliders, Square margarita pizza, chicken francese, baked rigatoni & rigatoni a la vodka. We all loved everything. Portions are big but not too big. Everything tasted fresh and flavorful and was cooked perfectly. Can’t wait to go back!

I am basing this on only ordering by the slice. We didn’t get the full experience. The cheese and pepperoni pizzas were tasty. Kids loved it. It was $3.50 a slide for large pieces.

Came here a few times for pizza and it’s solid. Their sandwiches and salads are great. Good portions, a bit pricey but worth

I stopped by this place a couple years ago for an ice-cream on my way to the Newburgh Vintage Warehouse, and had wanted to visit again for all the deliciousness on display. I found myself in the vintage warehouse this weekend again so searched it out for a mid-afternoon snack with my husband. We ordered the artichoke roll and the gorgonzola walnut salad. While waiting, I went downstairs to the bathroom - and felt an impulse to take a photo, coz it was so immaculate! With both high quality hand soap and hand lotion - how considerate! The cleanliness of the bathroom at an eatery is always a plus for me, in that I'd trust the cleanliness of the food that they serve. Both dishes were super delicious! The artichoke roll was huge - it fed both of us and I was too full to eat dinner that night. The salad was beautiful, creative, healthy and tasty. While we were eating, the staff also had their late lunch. How well a restaurant feeds its staff is also a good indicator of how well they feed their clients, and if the serving staff are happy to work there. Let me just say that I would be very happy to work there!

Great, neat shop and great views of the water. The pizza was excellent always fresh and tasty. The staff were super friendly. Definitely a must visit place when in Newburgh.

Was visiting from out of town and met up with my family, a party of 10. They were very busy but the staff and management were VERY accommodating. They pivoted to alternate seating for us and still made us feel welcome on an obviously very unexpected evening. The food was excellent and the service was spectacular. I will be sure to visit again next time I am in town!

This was fire 🔥🔥🔥🔥🔥
Half Fresno Chili 🌶
Half curl n crisp Pepperoni 🍕
Pull up and have a seat and be ready for large and in charge eating

Hello Everyone,

We loved the pizza here. The staff is friendly and attentive, but most important, they were very accommodating even with all these COVID restrictions.

Kudos to the staff, we were able to tell they work hard to please each customer.

Great place to take the kids and we enjoyed our food too. Service was good; fast and attentive.

One of the best pizza stores around. Enjoyed their square thin crust pizza -- Margherita Pizza with fresh Mozzarella, Boom Room Pizza with roasted 🍄 . Crispy, cheesy, but juicy with mouth full of fresh Mozzarella. Tasted fresh and delicious!!! Excellent Pizza. I used to live in Brooklyn, NY. This can be compared with authentic thin crust Brooklyn pizza. A+. Highly recommend. For the best taste, eat pizza on site right after it is served.

Pizza shop has been a family favorite since I was a kid. I remember going there even before Hudson taco was next door. 100% recommend.

My husband and I were staying staying close and are not familiar with the area. We wanted gluten free pizza and after reading reviews decided to try out the pizza shop.
The reviews were right! This was one of the best gluten free pizzas we’ve ever had. Would definitely come back here whenever we are in the area.

Great spot-on the water-great pizza, salads, and awesome rotisserie chicken. Huge portions. Friendly staff.

Great spot for a consistently tasty nosh after an exam... or a long day... or after good news... or whenever! Friendly wait staff greet you at the door and are patient with even the most indecisive patrons. Order a Fishers lemonade and the short rib fries and tell em Daisy sent ya!

Great pizza place with a lot of options. They also have salads and sandwiches and dessert options. The rice crispy was soooooo good and we really enjoyed the Birch Beer. The employees are kind and helpful. We’ll definitely be back.

5 stars for concept. Quaint and modern. Fresh food. Good responsive service. Good owners. Known for their food and they also opened the Hudson Taco next door with full bar.

My family, ages 3-68, have ordered almost all Vegetarian and Gluten Free menu options. We are never disappointed! With the exception of three waitresses, service can be compromised by the busy-ness of orders being picked up. Tables are crowded, side by side by side, limiting privacy of anyone's conversation in the seated areas. Hudson Taco, the next door restaurant, has their service wait staff constantly walking through the Pizza Shop to serve outdoor customer tables. Both restaurants share the same restrooms which can back log during busy dining hours. Quite a bit of pedestrian traffic results. If your priority is eating great pizza selections, delicious salads, and tasty authentic sauces over diverse pasta selections, plan a visit ASAP.

Stromboli was pretty tasty! I took it home, cut it open and got the cheese all bubbly and melted under the broiler. So good you want to slap yo mama!

Delicious pizza! We had the garden veggie pizza. Great prices and the location is beautiful.

Love Pizza Shop! Everything on the menu is delicious. The pizza is great, the eggplant rollatini and eggplant parm heros are amazing and enormous, the ravioli is delish. My husband loves the wings. Italian food in general tends to lean salty so make sure to chug that water. And heads up, a freight train barrels past every half hour or so. The screeching become part of the charm once you're prepared for it:)