Benny Tesoro's

Let me start this review with saying that I LOVE pizza. By far my favorite food and go to comfort food. When we go on vacation we like to find new pizza places to try. We have several that we have found over the years that we go back to. Benny Tesoros here at Nags Head will DEFINITELY be a place we return to when in the Outer Banks! The pizza was delicious! My favorite part is the crust, it was crispy but not overcooked. Just absolutely perfect! The sauce was also top notch! We only tried the pepperoni pizza with marinara and garlic dipping sauce on the side. I have to rate it a 10/10. There's nothing I would change about the pizza. Everyone was so nice! The manager, I regret that I didn't ask his name was super helpful and made sure we had everything we needed. He even recommended we try the cookie spot next door. We are happy to find that they have a location in Raleigh, NC which is closer to us when we come visit NC. Can't wait to come back!

Great value for your money and by far the biggest slice I’ve ever seen. We came in on their grand opening weekend and were blown away. Welcoming atmosphere with a great location on the water and outside seating as well. Right next to a brewery too! The pizza has a perfect crunch on the bottom while maintaining that New York flop. Loved the Garlic Mushroom slice.

Good pizza by the slice and the atmosphere was great, they have a brewery right next door. Outdoor seating has a great view. A must try pizza place if you are in the area.

This was the biggest pizza I've ever seen!! It was delicious...we loved the crust it was really soft and the cheese and sauce was really good...the best pepperoni pizza I've had by far!! My husband put his hand on the box so everyone could see just how huge it truly was...was definitely worth the money and we will be back for more for sure

This place gets 5 stars. I've been all over the east coast where imo has the best pizza locations in the country, and this place was an accident that we stumbled upon but wound up being a top end pizza joint with the taste of New Jersey and NYC pizzas. If you don't stop here you really lived below your privileges. Kudos Benny

Great pizza at the beach. Giant size piece and beautiful view. Grew up on Jersey Pizza and this is a hidden gem. We'll be back!

Love this delicious pizza! Slices size is off the hook
Everything always tastes super fresh. It's almost 70 miles round-trip from my house or else would stop in a code of days a week

Great pizza! Thin crust with a nice chew. The owner was super nice. Will be back. The pizza is HUGE! You can order by the slice as well.

Awesome pizzeria on the Outer Banks! HUGE slices, great views, affordable price!!

Absolutely love this place! Great service! Great food! They even made a custom pizza for my girlfriend's mom who's vegan! Highly recommend.

Great slice of pizza with a view of the sound. The slices are huge so make sure you're hungry.

Have I had better pizza? Yes. But Benny’s IS really good and you can’t beat the atmosphere. And the size of a whole pizza is ridiculous.

We enjoyed a huge slice of pizza while having a beer next door at the brewery! The pizza was delicious and we saw massive boxes of pizza to do leaving the restaurant one after the other! We will definitely have another slice the next time we’re at Lost Colony Brewery!

This place is awesome! Got 2 pizzas by the slice and they were ginormous and so so good! Ate outside by the waterfront!

Incredible pizza! One slice is so big and delicious, especially for the price. It tasted amazing and you can’t beat the location right on the water. You definitely want to try this place out!

The pizza was phenomenal and the Staff was as pleasant as the pizza! HUGE pizza we got 2 slices and it definitely filled us all up. Great place, great pizza, great people highly recommend 👌

Ordered five of their huge pies for a friends surprise party. Absolutely delicious. Cooked perfectly. Even made one with “40” made out of pepperonis! Super helpful staff.

Currently writing this as I’m finishing my last slice! The best pizza I have ever had! HUGE slices, cheap pizza, fantastic service!!! Not to mention the view outside! On my list of places to come back to each time we visit!

My husband drove to Nags Head for business and stopped at Benny Tesoro to pick up a pizza to bring home because I wanted to try the pizza. I can say that being a former New Yorker it was just what I was looking for, first of all the biggest pizza I’ve ever seen and secondly delicious crust thin and crispy and from the pictures my husband took the ambiance and the mural painting are unique and colorful. They are also located on the water so if your there you can eat your pizza overlooking the water great option for Nags Head
When my travels from Virginias eastern shore bring me back to Nags Head I will certainly be a regular patron of Benny’s Tesoro’s

Such a great deal! Huge slices of boardwalk style pizza for an affordable price! We enjoyed it on the deck with great views of the water!