Portland Pie Company

We had half carne asada half burnt ends pizza and both sides were great. Probably liked the carne asada special a little more. We also had awesome stuffed mushrooms and nice some cold Maine Brewing Lunch to go with everything. Definitely will be back the next time we are up this way

The Philly steak sandwich was fkn incredible and I highly recommend it. We didn't have pizza, but it really looked good and about 10 of them left for take-out while we were there. Strawberry spinach salad in season, and it was super tasty and fresh. Get food here!

Amazing service, great bartender! Love the cheesy breadsticks.

We loved everything about Portland Pie Company!!! Roasted brussel sprouts, buffalo chicken slices, and gluten free cheese pizza were the big winners!!!! Also the servers at this location were terrific!!!

Portland Pie Co was amazing. We were visiting from out of town and the friend we visited brought us here. The pizza options were generous and the server and cook managed to get our whole party of about 20 people served in under an hour, absolutely stunning. I thought when our local pizza place closed that I would never get a mashed potato pizza ever again, but Portland Pie Co was there for me with the Country and it was perfect. I can't say enough good things about this place, I very highly recommend it!

Ordered a lg buffalo and lg half cheese half loaded. I was amazed at how different it was compared to the Scarborough location. Hardly any toppings and very little buffalo sauce. The quality control is terrible between locations. I’m willing to pay the high prices in Scarborough for a delicious pizza, definitely not in Westbrook, I feel like I was robbed.

I called and spoke to the GM at this location who personally re made the pizzas and had them delivered to my location in 15min. Now that’s service! He made things right and the pizzas were fantastic and exactly as expected. Thank you for taking care of us so quickly.

You can never go wrong with the garlic dough here, and every veggie pizza can be made vegan. It’s my favorite place to grab a pizza for take out or to stop by for a quick meal complimented by one of their rotating drafts.

I think this is the best pizza in the Greater Portland area if you're looking for something that goes beyond the standard cheese and or pepperoni pizza.
They have a wide variety of options to choose from, with different sauces and toppings paired in various ways, but all the ones I have had are well executed.
They also have some food other than pizza which I'm told is good, but I'm not going to go to a pizza place and order salad. If you are though, it's pretty good.

The waiter accidentally gave me a pizza I am allergic to. The reason this is a 5 star is because he was awesome and handled the whole situation perfectly. Everyone makes mistakes but he spoke up as soon as he knew what happened and comped us the entire meal and even sent me away with a gluten free cake. The next 3 days will suck but all in all my dining experience was wonderful and the waiter was very kind and apologetic. They train their staff well

The calzone is delicious--I love that you can choose different flavored crusts. Everyone else seemed very happy with their pizzas and sandwiches.

Friendly service and delicious food! My friend is gluten intolerant and on the way to the airport I picked up a portlander sub & eagle ridge (steak bomb) on their gluten free toasted roll that comes with pickles and chips and they were so very delicious!! My friend was very happy to have such a great meal be gluten free

I ordered online for a 6 o'clock delivery. It's 8 o'clock and no pizza. Called at 7 and they said The driver was out. Just called now and the guy on the phone was nice and refunded me but wasn't able to tell me if I am ever going to get my pizza. I'm frustrated because I love their food. But it's been three hours since I ordered and I don't think I'm going to get to eat dinner tonight. I'm so upset.

Update: the manager hand delivered my pizza and let me their driver was in an accident!! Every is okay and I'm really impressed. Thank you!!

If I could give a hundred stars I would. I have never left the Westbrook location feeling anything but happy and appreciated. All staff members are fantastic, friendly, respectful, helpful and just plain wonderful. The manager John is hands down... one of the best managers I've witnessed. He genuinely cares, knows his stuff, and won't stop until the customer is BEYOND happy. I had trouble with my rewards earlier and John was there to help and make things right. While Portland Pie pizza is to die for, I think half the reason I keep going back is the staff!!!! Thank you!!!

The pizza here is just ridiculously good. I’m so glad you can order by the slice as well, makes it super convenient and quick. My favorite is the buffalo chicken pizza, not too much on the buffalo but you definitely get good flavor and a nice amount of chicken. I love Portland Pie!

Great range of pizza topping! Enough to keep a diverse crowd eating together and having a good time.

Great service, the food is delicious and there's many options for those with restricted diets (vegetarian, vegan, gluten free, dairy free). It's a small restaurant so it can fill up pretty quickly, but if you don't want to dine-in it's pretty easy to order online. There's always a solid selection of local beers and they have a loyalty program that will save you a lot of money if you eat there frequently.

Wonderful nosh. Our party ordered two pies to go with the beer crust and both were excellent. If I lived locally I'd definitely be back to try some more of their selections. Good thing we ordered take away because the only downside to the restaurant is the serious lack of parking.

Portland Pie in Westbrook is very cozy. Theres a strong bar vibe throughout, and limited seating. They have a moderately sized TV by the bar as well.
I have celiac disease. I found that their gluten free pizza gave me little discomfort the day after. Theyre strict on cross contaminación, but one can't avoid flour in the air. Just let the cooks know of any allergies when you order!
Side note, their pepperoni is certified gluten free.
Their sauce is unforgettable.
2 bathrooms, no stalls, men and women's.
Shared parking is small around the back of the building, or street side.
Friendly staff.
I wish they offered deep dish pies.
I'd consider their prices $$

Danielle was great. She was extremely welcoming and gracious, and she introduced us to whoopie pies!

I've ordered take out from Portland Pie Co. a few times over the last couple of months. each time, I ordered the Acadia Turkey Apple sandwich on the Basil focaccia bread. The bread is amazing and the sandwiches are big enough to potentially last two meals. Each time I've ordered, the wait was only about 20 minutes (pretty good all things considered with COVID). Their hummus platter is also good, but I found it on the pricey side. I've yet to try their pizza, but I don't think there is a place in town that makes a better sandwich.