Jolly Pirate Donuts

Stopped by before we visited family. Great selection and good price. Less than $16 for a bakers dozen. The filled donut is fantastic. Long John’s is a little sweet. The butter milk donut however is hard a pass for my family.

Excellent in-house made doughnuts and cookies! I have been coming here for years, since I was a kid. I still love the freshness they bring to the table and my tastebuds. If you have time or are near reynoldsburg, please stop by and try!

The Best donuts, so fresh and the only donut shop that I have found that make cherry 🍒 filled donuts!!! My favorite kind 😋😋😋
Quick service,too! Thank you Jolly Pirate Donuts & all your employees for still being here!!! 🩷 You are appreciated!!! 🙂♥🍩

Love the honey curlers with chocolate on top. Taste just as good as the first time I had them over 40 yrs ago.

Super selection of a variety of fresh made donuts, taste like they were made only moments ago. Service is quick and friendly. Order a dozen and they give a 13th for free - pick from even the big specialty donuts for the free one. See the pics!

We stopped by for some Pumpkin doughnuts (since every where else it's Christmas). This shop is family owned and the doughnuts are made fresh daily. It was late on A Saturday so they were out of some options, but they did still have the Pumpkin. They were delicious and the lady working was really nice.

Friendly service and clean place. Great taste of coffee and donuts with low prices.

Always a solid option for anyone wanting a custom dozen of doughnuts. Much more cream filling than their competitors and slightly cheaper. Win win for my book

This place is an instant classic. Been around since the beginning and still offers service that brings a smile to your heart. What more could you ask for, they seriously provide the best donuts and even have a drive thru when you need it on the go.

The best donuts in Central Columbus are sold here, accompanied by exceptional customer service!

These are magical fluffy doughnuts that I can hardly believe exist.

BEST. DOUGHNUTS. EVER. Bonus points for making a baker's dozen when you buy a dozen doughnuts. Seriously can't go wrong here. Every single one I've tried so far my family and I have loved. My brother even comes here instead of having a cake for his birthday. (You get a free doughnut!) Just aces.

Love the lady Mrs Caroline with the beautiful nails who works there. Everytime I come here she is so friendly and very welcoming. Something you dont get nowdays. Such a beautiful spirit!

Great customer service and the donuts are delicious! This was my first time here and I'm very satisfied. Will be back again!

The premier donut shop for downtown Reynoldsburg. If you want another, go to Blacklick / North Reynoldsburg.

Cashier was nice, and quick on the draw for fulfilling my order.

The place wasn't messy or smelly, seems to be fairly well stocked, looks like everyone working there is paid well...
Yeah? Looks like everything is here and accounted for. No complaints

When we want that sweet treat I love the Mapke Long John! The jelly filled are delicious too!

Donuts were delicious but the lady behind the counter wasn't having a very good day, couldn't get her to smile at all.

Open late...good donuts!!! Just went today and I got 7 donuts. The front attendant was very courteous and we danced a little to some Christmas music that was playing in the lobby. She was wonderful.

We came in for the first time on a Sunday evening and we're shocked that there was such a big selection still. Everything was so fresh, fluffy and delicious and the ladies behind the counter were friendly and wonderful.

The best donuts in the country! The peanut donut is my favorite, but all of the cake donuts are superb. It’s always fresh and the service is excellent. And the prices can’t be beat.