New York Pizzeria

Friendly, attentive staff and delicious pizza! My wife and I ordered a small cheese pizza (12") then added pepperoni and few veggies. The crust was cooked to a golden brown and had great flavor and texture. Better yet we could fold our slices without losing toppings! Our pie had the right amount sauce and cheese giving it a nice balance. The toppings were plentiful without overloading it. It's definitely worth the stop!

Order 2 calzon told me pick up time. Was ready on arrival two nice sized correct ingredients.very tasty would order again.

Always good food only thing I would change is more sauce on the wings I like good saucy wings

Excellent food and excellent service from the young woman at the counter. Came in twice during my weekend. From someone who lives outside of NYC, I approve of the pizza quality :) Wings good too!

We’re staying near Cooperstown and found this delicious New York style pizza. Service was great and prices were reasonable.

We called NY Pizzeria last Wednesday night at 8:40 knowing that they close at 9 after a bad experience at another local establishment. I asked if they would be willing to make us 2 large pizzas and wings and deliver to us knowing the answer would probably be no because of their closing time. They were plesant, and very accomodating, and did indeed make and deliver dinner to us without any hesitation. The young lady who delivered actually was the one who took the order, and she lived in West Winfield (the opposite direction of where we live). Thank you for your excellent customer service. This was more than expected!

This has been our go to pizza place any time we are driving through the area. Quick, tasty, and affordable!

Best pizza I've had in a LOOONG time. Big pillowy, yet crispy crust was cooked thru (a big problem with pizza in PA is that it's always too doughy). Garlic knots were also great - they serve 3 giant knots as an appetizer.

Outstanding food and plenty left over to take back to the cabin for dinner and lunch the next day!

Good food, nice Patio, friendly Staff, reasonable prizes

Food was good service wad friendly

What can I say this place is amazing!! Always has been and I believe it always will be. Joe and his family have been offering up the best pizza outside of NYC at both locations since I can remember. There's two choices for traditional Italian New York Pizza and this place has the name written all over it hahahaha!! Well worth the short walk up Chestnut from down town!

Great pizza and wings! Outstanding service! We had car trouble today on our way to pick up our order and got stranded on route 20. They offered to deliver to us, so we could stay with the vehicle waiting for a tow, instead of us walking down to get it from Cooper Chrysler. Thank you for going helping us out and delivering a hot lunch!! It made a bad situation humorous and bearable.

We love the pizza here. The staff are friendly and professional and all the food is always great. Would highly recommend.

One of the best well made pizza's I've had in a very long time!! Made to perfection!!!

I've been going here since I was a kid, this place has always been owned by the same people for as long as I could remember. It was nice to come back after two years of being in Florida and seeing some familiar faces. I used to sneak out of lunch at school to go to the pizzeria with my senior friends. They always have had the best pizza. Considering I've been in Florida with their pathetic excuse for pizza, it was nice to come back up and have some NY style pizza. Always been the best.

Nice looking place. Wait time for my food was a little long but it was also busy that night. Loved the pizza but I think the wings should have had more sauce

Pizza is great!! [all chefs have been up to par lately!] Would recommend extra sauce on the pie! Appart from the pizza, strongly recommend the barbeque wings, they are mesquite with a nice bite or tang you probably won't find elsewhere!
Do stop in!

We have been traveling for several months in our RV and with our dogs. It is hard to find parking and outdoor sitting. We were able to park across the street and they had a couple of tables outside. Besides all those plusses for us, the pizza slices were terrific. We would highly recommend this place.

Always an on the way back from Oneonta to Syracuse stop for me because the Cheese Pizza is so fantastic. They never disappoint me! Love it!!!

This place is clean, the staff I delt with were very nice and polite. The extra large pie was about $18. I called in the pizza 20 minutes ahead and it was done on time. Would come back any day.