Taste of Italy

While they have so many fantastic foods to choose from, my favorite is their subs. It seems basic, I'm sure, but the quality of the cold cuts (and that they are actually cut PROPERLY) and the bread they use just makes it the best around like what used to be common place before chain places took over. This is a family business that's been serving our community in Tinton Falls for years and has some of the loveliest people working there.

Place is delicious. Would recommend the taste of Italy sandwich item, sub, whatever it tastes good.

This place is a hidden gem!!! The Fiesta is unreal. Their paninis are the first thing I get whenever I come in from new York

We LOVE Taste of Italy! The Brooklyn Sub and the Francis Ford Coppola Sub (we substitute chicken breast for turkey) are our favorites! We also enjoy their chicken salad and 3 bean salad as well. We've also tried their Eggplant Rollatini and it's delicious!!! Their frozen cheese ravioli is also a favorite of ours. I'd like to take a sample of everything they make, because it's so tasty!!! 🤩

Very friendly and helpful. A little pricey but so worth it.

I have been a customer for several years. I keep coming back because not only is the premade food , sauces & soups fresh and delicious, the butcher meat’s & cold cuts are top of the line and the staff is friendly and accommodating. I am so impressed with The Taste of Italy that I recommended them to cater my company lunches.

I cannot say enough amazing things about Jimmy P's! We had a catering order being delivered yesterday and as they were coming in, I dropped and broke two bottles of wine. The husband and wife team who were delivering jumped in and mopped up the wine (after finding a mop!) while I cleaned the broken glass! The food, as always, is incredible, but the service is second to none! Customers for life!

This is one of the best food establishments In New Jersey. I know Jimmy a long time his staff and quality of food is absolutely phenomenal. I live in New York I've been coming down to Jersey Shore 63 years. You want the best of the best go eat in a taste of Italy

Love this place food is great, good service. Just remember when you walk in to.grab a ticket on left side for your order number.

Amazing place!! Incredible Italian dishes of every kind, never disappointed! Staff is friendly and helpful. Prices are very reasonable for such high quality. Recommend the spinach lasagna 😋

You get what you pay for and it couldn't be more true than Taste of Italy. Really nice people, they go out of their way to help you and make sure you are happy. Food is top notch.

They are the caterer for South Wall Banquet Hall. We had our wedding celebration there and everything was lovely. Mike was very accommodating and helpful. He and his team really did a great job. Everyone loved the food and had a great time. I loved the penne vodka and I normally don't even like that dish. The giant cannoli was a great touch at the desert table too.

Taste of italy is the BEST Italian deli and meat market around. The meatball mix chop meat is so fresh and the homemade mozzarella is delicious as well as the hot fresh baked bread. We are there at least twice a week. Love this place.

Always great Italian food. Me and my wifes go to for Italian sandwiches. My #1 recommendation is the red stuffed peppers.

Great home Italian food weather if it is a sub or a good good eggplant rollatini. They have a good butcher part. Great bakery. Best Italian bread in the area. And very very friendly staff. All around five star rating for everything they do. Also there expresso soda is out of control amazing.

Full service Italian deli, featuring
Cooked or ready to cook Italian
Delights. Always clean & well
Stocked. Eat in if desired. Not
To be missed the bread and
rolls baked fresh daily.
Absolutely delicious!!!!

Once again, Jimmy and Taste of Italy has done a magnificent job as always. Taste of Italy is my go to for everything, everyday lunch and dinner, Holidays, Events. The food is amazing and service impeccable. Thank you for all that you do for us.

Awesome food. Especially when you are coming back after a long and eventful day on asbury park Beach

Got veggie pasta and veggie lasagna

The guy was gracious enough to give a whole loaf of bread with it.

Always, always, always....this place has the best sandwiches, best prepared foods, and all things needed to cook from an Italian point of view!! Really good food!!

Great authentic Italian deli. The sandwiches are delicious and they have so many great imported products, cheese, sausage, etc. Also you must try their frozen ravioli, they have many varieties, eggplant, lobster, etc.