The Coffee Pot

I have been going to the Coffee Pot for a little over two years now and its my favorite place to get coffee. The vibe is great, the staff is warm and welcoming and they always treat me like their favorite customer. They answer all my questions with patience and understanding and make sure I get exactly what I want (sometimes I can be a little picky). Even though The Coffee Pot changed ownership recently, I can honestly say the new owner is doing a great job at making it feel like the exact same place. I will definitely be continuing to go there whenever I want some caffeine, a sweet drink, or even a nice bagel.

I really enjoyed The Coffee Pot. It's a beautuful coffee shop and a steady line of customers who were waited on quickly. My chicken noodle soup warmed me up quickly and was so good! My husband got a HUGE serving of chocolate cake that that was...oh-my-goodness delish!! We will be back! Soon.

This place is an absolute gem and worth visiting for the wall art alone (but the coffee is exceptional too!). Located on the Main Street, once you enter the doors it's as if you stepped into a delightful new world. It's spacious and elegantly decorated, plus there's plenty of seating options whether you'd like to choose a comfy chair near the bookshelves or a marble table with chairs to get some work done. I adore the Christmas-themed handmade painted art that was on display in the front windows and found out from the owner, while he made my tasty toasted marshmallow mocha, that he picks a new theme every year. I'm definitely planning to come back and visit in the very near future!

This is a family favorite when we visit from out of town. I've been going here for years before it was the Coffee Pot when I was living in Union City.

The coffee is still wonderful and the baked goods are fresh and delicious.

Even if you're not a coffee lover the visit is worth it for the architectural history alone. There is also a small library of books and on occasion they've had music.

the best atmosphere and the best coffee around (and that includes the area shops beyond darke county). as a longtime patron, eric and company have not missed a beat since the change in ownership. the staff is friendly and welcoming, whipping up excellent drinks while making you feel like you’re a part of the family. the best third place in greenville (along with the merchant house, which is just a couple of blocks down the street!).

Where to start?
A few friends and I had made plans to head out of town, but when we had to cancel the original plans, we decided to meet up here and spend time together.
We all loved our coffees. I got a peppermint latte.
My friend’s card had issues when she tried to pay, and she was told to not worry about payment, a gesture I find exceedingly kind.
We found a cozy corner to play games in until closing time. We cut it pretty close, but no one made any indication that we didn’t belong there any longer.
And last and probably least, but hardly…the bathrooms? Since when does a bathroom deserve mention? But theirs does!

Check it out, my friends. Check this whole place out!

The first thing I do most mornings is make my way to The Coffee Pot for my almost daily iced coffee. If I didn’t have prior obligations on some days it would be a daily ritual. Having said that, I still manage to make it over there at least 4-5 times a week and it’s the only place I’ll ever go for my morning coffee in Greenville. Never disappointed.

The staff is stellar. The owner Eric, and all of the baristas are beyond kind and helpful. Khara and Austin, in particular, really go above and beyond for all of the patrons and first timers, along with myself. My drink is ready by the time I get to the counter. Smells good. Looks good. Good vibes all around.

Less important(to me) but noteworthy things:
1. Awesome building
2. Cool atmosphere
3. Amazing food
4. Cool merch
5. Cool bathroom
6. Books
7. Comfy seating

I could stand here and write more about how much I love this place but I have to go to work so you’ll have to just go experience The Coffee Pot yourself because that’s what it is. It’s not just a coffee shop, it’s an experience in itself.

Loved this coffeeshop! I wish I could've spent the day there reading a book in one of the booths along the wall. So cozy! Loved the atmosphere, decor and selections. The iced mocha was tasty and the banana cream pie was yummy.

Truly loved my experience here, we come to Greenville every month to see my wife’s family, and will be coming here everytime. The customer service, food and drinks were nothing short of delightful. The only bad thing I have to say is this isn’t in my town. Thank you Austin for helping me pick what to drink! 😊

My favorite coffee shop of all time and I’ve been to several. I love the atmosphere. Friendly staff. Delicious bakery items and soups. Friendly staff.

Fabulous atmosphere. Wonderful coffee. Great food.

Great experience. I’m from southern Ohio and found Greenville on the map as a place to meet someone for the day coming from northern Indiana. We started the day at The Coffee Pot which did not disappoint! Beautiful venue, great food, and excellent staff. We will return! Kudos to whoever owns the building. Fantastic updo of beautiful older storefront.

Service dog friendly. Handicap accessible. Great to find whole bean grog. Would like to see monk fruit as a sweetner option.

Diary of coffee snob:
I remember when the first coffee shop popped up on this corner, "Broadway Joes" was the name. Being the introvert that I am, I appreciated and enjoyed the cozy and quiet atmosphere. The coffee was phenomenal and cheap. I'd sometimes stay long enough to work up an appetite and invite my friends to join me at the "Little Italian Cafe" for a delicious meal. Although "Broadway Joe's" went out of business (unfortunately, they were so cool and ahead of their time lol), a new shop took its place shortly after named "Sweet One O' One."" I visited a few times, getting what I usually would from the previous shop; however, it just didn't compare. I eventually stopped going and went searching (unsatisfied) for the same taste and nostalgic experience I had developed from my first ever hometown gourmet coffee shop. Not long after, "Sweet One' O One" went out of business and, in its place stood "The Coffee Pot." By this point, I realized that I'm kind of a coffee snob. I decided to give it a try, and like a "Ratatouille" critic moment, my first experience was joy. The atmosphere was cozy, quiet, with a chill indie esthetic. The coffee was almost exactly the quality I had experienced with "Broadway Joes." With that being said, over time the atmosphere has changed significantly due to social media. All the cool kids are drinking coffee, and this little gem that was the best kept secret now feels like a hot spot. If you're an extrovert, and you don't mind waiting up to 20 minutes for an excellent coffee, then look no further. I really enjoy the coffee pot when it's not busy because I wait no longer than 3-5 minutes for a coffee, they know my order, and it's excellent every time.
P.S.
For a sweet treat with a caffeine kick, I get a frozen white chocolate, almond milk, with an extra shot of espresso (this same drink is also good hot though, inconsistentdepending on who makes it) . During the cold months, I used to get a chaii latte. I would not recommend it anymore because they no longer use fresh tea, it's just Tazo chaii from the jug steamed and that makes me sad. (The old recipe used to feel like a cozy hug after the horse parade or during December.)
Their muffins are delicious as well. My husband enjoys the hot coffee, but I find it bitter. Does someone want to recommend a nice hot coffee?

The Coffee Pot never disappoints! Always a smiling, polite staff with a great variety of options on the menu no matter what you're after!

Enjoyed the Grogg! Great ambiance. Nice place to enjoy a good cup of coffee and pastry.

I’ve never had better coffee in any part of the United States. Amazing staff, and consistently clean restaurant!

Whenever I'm in Greenville, I always ask to go here for one of their mocha coffees. Then I usually go again later in my visit.The space is very open with high ceilings. It's a comfortable place to sit and relax while having a snack. As far as I know, it's hands down the best coffee place in town

Best desserts in town! Staff is very friendly and the environment is so cozy!

5 stars all around. If you leave anything less than 5 stars you’re lying to yourself.