Play It Again Sports Appleton

We love batting cages! I also appreciate how nice the Staff are! I used to bring one of the kids I worked with here and he was always so excited to hit with me and would make comments about how friendly the staff is and funny they can be.

Great place to find used sports equipment. They have something for everyone. Constantly changing inventory.

Huge baseball inventory. Batting cages with unlimited hits on pay by the hour. Limited hockey collection compared to Green Bay store

Stopped in to ask a question in regards to a vintage golf club and the guy behind the counter stated that it was a nice club but unfortunately not what the customers would be looking for but told me what I could do with it...

Buy and sell used sports equipment!
This is one of several locations.

Here you will find a store where you can buy and sell used sports equipment. They also stock new products as well. The selection is pretty good and the prices are very affordable compared to new.
This location is large, probably twice the size of the Green Bay location. The staff is also very friendly and they have no problem letting you browse the store. As with any second hand shop, you will need to stop in frequently to review the selection. They may not always have what you want.

I would recommend stopping in here before ordering online or going to a large retailer.

First time here and was surprised by their inventory!! SO many different options for all your sports need - and for great prices. They even have batting cages inside?!! Bought a used pair of ice skates, and the employee was very helpful and offered to sharpen the blades - for $7 - worth it!

A great place to get your athletic equipment

the batting cage rocks. we take our little guy here frequently. it is also a great deal. will continue to keep going back!!!!

I go here for the batting cages all the time with my dad. The staff are so nice and chill and the batting cages are really good for practice. I’ve got so much better from the batting cages alone. I’ve tried probably thousands of dollars worth of bats there

Great place, me and the family stopped it from a motorcycle trip and picked up a new baseball glove and some balls and the people working were very helpful.

Very helpful staff. Will return.

Have used them for equipment from disc golf, weight lifting, skiing, baseball and other outdoor sports. Have a good selection of new and used gear. Owner made right a situation I had with equipment and will use them in the future.

Went looking for ice-skates and found a almost new pair very reasonable price. An employee of the store showed my child how to lace them up and make sure they fit correctly. The store had a very large collection of everything I was very impressed with the selection the price and the service

Large, well equipped store with friendly staff. We went to our locally owned and operated store seeking bindings for a snowboard. Scored what appeared to be never or nearly never used Flow Alpha bindings for $50. We were first interested in base plates used to mount the bindings to the board. A staff member, despite being busy, took the time to look in their parts bin, and then get the manager involved. Finding none, we took time to look around and a third, knowledgeable staff person helped us out.

This store has a lot of equipment, new and used, including batting cages. They also have a pretty generous return policy for new and used equipment AND they rent out some equipment.

Not all stores are the same but this Appleton store should be the standard.

Workers were very knowledgeable and friendly.

Great place to buy gear for a majority of sports. They sharpened my skates in under 10 minutes and the guys were super nice!

Best place for my kids who play so many sports but outgrow equipment each season. Keeps it affordable for them to keep playing!

They were very professional in helping me find the best snowshoes for my wife. Not the most expensive ones, but the right ones. I've bought a lot of new and used quality equipment from them, and have never been disappointed.

Have exchanged a lot of items here. My kids also used the batting cages as well. $6 for a all day use wristband. $2 more and they test swung the current year bats. Tried out at least $2500 worth of bats to see what felt the best. Also have baseball glove repair in store. Great place.

I was recommended this place from a couple of friends, they also gave me a $5 coupon. I came to get some disc golf discs to play with my friends. I am pretty novice.

One of the workers spent 20 min helping me, absolutely outstanding knowledge and customer service. I left feeling blown away because this type of service is hard to come by... lifetime customer right here. Keep it up.