Retro Games & Toys Of LI

I've been buying from this store for months. They always have what I need and are willing to negotiate if you buy in bulk.

Absolutely, a GREAT place if you are a Cine-file like me. Excellent prices, friendly knowledgeable people and a really great place to find both movies as well as games. They have quite a large collection, especially the Massapiqua store. That place is huge, but Levittown is good too.

Love coming here Everytime, the prices are very cheap and service is excellent from the father info to the Girls getting what you need and cashing you out. They never miss and always have what im looking for. 1000% recommend

Amazing selection of funko pops, pokemon and video games. Great service

Extremely friendly and helpful staff. They have an awesome 7-day exchange policy, and After I bought an N64 I couldn't get it to work at my house. When I got to the store they gave me tips on how to clean the cartridge, completely swapped out The console, cables and Even the game for a different one that they had. And when I got home it worked like new. Would definitely shop there again.

Retro Games & Toys of LI is incredible! They have helped me build the foundation for a large and complete VHS collection. It was 100% worth the drive from Brooklyn to see what they had. This is truly a family business, and Jerry went above and beyond to make us feel like valued customers. I will be coming here for all my video game and VHS needs in the future.

I absolutely love coming here and buying some of my all time favorites games. Great prices and amazing deals. I highly recommend anyone to come here for their retro games fix.

Picked up a GameCube for my best friend. They tested and provided cables and a controller. Even a warranty! They're great.

Highly recommend this place to collectors and anyone who misses that old school gaming experience. It is family owned and everyone was knowledgeable about what they were selling. The person who helped me had to be a teenager but i was amazed about how much she knew. All around great experience

This is an excellent retro game stores. Prices are very reasonable and you might have to have some free time to browse because although the store is small there are many kind of retro items that you can spot that is of your interest. Tanya is extremely nice and will try her best to help answer any questions. I highly recommend this store if you are a retro game collector and toy collector!! Thank you for having this great store available!

*UPDATE*
The store has moved from the 1st floor to the mezzanine floor of the mall. The store is now two times bigger and is even more incredible now!!!!!! 🙌🙏

Amazing selection of classic games and toys! Friendly and quick service. Great prices, way better than nyc’s prices. They also test the game/accessory/console you want before you buy it. If that exact one doesn’t work, they’ll get another one and test that one too. It’s just the things like these that make this store great. Go here if you are collecting games or just want to take a walk down memory lane.

Great place for retro stuff in LI. Unlike their competition 3 blocks away, all games and items are priced. Awesome staff which I believe is owned and runned by a family. Shame its hidden in the plaza and was hard to find at first but totally worth visiting. Will return multiple times in the near future for all my retro needs.

Great shop with lots of amazing and hard to find trinkets/collectables. Love going in there to see what's new as the inventory is always changing. The collections of goods spans from the 50s to early 2000s with everything from toys, home goods and electronic devices/games. On my top 10 places to stop in and shop/sell/ trade.

Amazing store the people work there are very nice. And their price for retro games. Controllers, Accessories are fair. Highly recommended for those who want to purchase some old school games and console.

Such a cool store such a wide selection of old retro games just went there and bought some ps2 games and accessories can’t wait to go back

Staff was very knowledgeable, and did a thorough test of the console I was interested in! Love seeing all the retro odds and ends toys here. Will definitely go back.

Great shop. Sold my old video games here and got a great price (more then I thought). I shopped around and they offered/gave me the most for it.

Great little retro store, the only guys that had a good NES in great condition for $65 also got Ninja Gaiden 2 & Super Mario/Duck Hunt owners are good people helped me out and tested all in front of me

The owner has the most amazing collection of 1980’s and 1990’s games I’ve seen yet.

Just about any game I’d want to rebuy from the classic systems is here, along with connections for SDTV. He has plenty of peripherals as well- along with board games and classic toys.

The people working there are helpful and knowledgeable. I love how much retro stuff they have. It was like going back to the 1980s and 1990s. I bought a Nintendo Game Cube with some games and I love it!