Sugar Mamas

Such great customer service and absolutely amazing cake! This review is long overdue as I ordered my wedding cake plus cupcakes for my wedding a few years ago. Can't say enough good things about this business. 🤩

📷 Photo Credit to MollyMcPhoto

On very short notice, Lexi made me the most beautiful cake for my 60th birthday! There were gasps when my guests opened the box. It tasted as good as it looks! A definite go to for a special occasion cake. Give her more notice though.

Lexi was absolutely incredible! She kept in touch with me throughout the pandemic while I was planning my wedding out of state. The red velvet cake is to die for!!!! She did a beautiful job on my order and I highly recommend you order from Sugar Mama’s! Thank you so much for making my day extra sweet! 😉🥰

An amazing cake! It looked spectacular and was delicious! The lemon filling was the best!
Thank you Lexi! You helped make our event and evening very special!

I cannot get over this cake!! I have never been so excited for leftovers. Lexi is so great to work with and strives to make sure she is providing what you want from the cake flavor, size, to the decorations. I stared at the cake for the whole night before the party because I couldn’t get over how beautiful it is! At the party, people thought they wanted to share a slice, but at all ended up eating their own after they tasted the deliciousness!!
We did a lemon cake with lemon curd in between and vanilla frosting. The cake was supposed to feed 50, but we could feed so many more!
I can’t wait to order many many more treats from Lexi! I will recommend Sugar Mama’s again and again!

Sugar Mama's baked the cake for our wedding at Shoshone Point on 10/3, *very* last minute (our original caterer dropped out mid-June). They were very responsive and helpful with the super short deadline. On top of that, the cake was *amazing*. When we took our first bite, we both paused and then kept shoveling cake into our mouths it was sooo delicious! Another fun thing - my husband's favorite cake is German Chocolate, so they made us a cupcake to have in our room at the end of the night (also scrumptious!). We cannot thank Sugar Mama's enough, they were the best!

While vacationing in Flagstaff (traveled from Cincinnati,) we were going to celebrate our sons birthday. We called in advance and spoke to Lexi. After some consultation from her we ordered a cake and scheduled a time to pick it up. Process was seamless, service was fantastic and the cake was more than perfect. Made a special occasion for our son. Thanks Lexi! I'd definitely recommend Sugar Mamas.

They saved my bacon. I needed a last minute birthday cheesecake and somehow she pulled off a honey lavender massive cheesecake in under 24 hours despite having more than full capacity of orders. Not only that, this was hands down the best cheesecake I've ever had and my wife concurs. The only other cheesecake that was even close was at Sarge's Deli in Manhattan. Sugar Mamas is legit!

Sugar Mamas was such a great choice for our wedding day! Very affordable, our cake looked beautiful and was huge!! Lexi was very flexible and easy to work with, she even came in on her day off to accommodate our wedding date! Thank you Sugar Mamas!

I ordered two cakes for my 60th birthday party and both were the best cakes I have ever had. My guests said so as well and I had a hard time getting to keep any leftovers for myself as everyone wanted to bring some home for later or for their family! Hearty, rich and a perfect combo of flavors, Sugar Mama's rocks!

I called to order some treats to thank my doctors and staff at the conclusion of a treatment course. When I called I was met with kindness and a genuine desire to help me find the best array of goodies. Not only was it a smooth process to order and pick up but the treats were amazing! I will certainly use Sugar Mamas again for any of my future bakery needs!

Called from out of state to order a cheesecake for my brother's birthday the following week. Lexi was excellent to work with, quickly handling the order and explaining the process to me. My brother picked up his cheesecake at the appointed time and was quite pleased with it. Highly recommend!!!

We had never heard of Sugar Mama's but seeing as how we were driving up from Phoenix for my daughter's 5th birthday I did not want to have worry about transporting a cake. So, I started looking for a local bakery in Flagstaff. Based on other reviews I selected Sugar Mama's & I could not have been happier! The chocolate dinosaur cake we ordered was awesomely rich, it was moist, the vanilla filling was so creamy & the fudge frosting was to die for! My first thought was one of remorse....for the fact that this bakery is not in the Phoenix area but is in Flagstaff. If you are looking for a cake that is amazing, look no further.

We had Sugar Mamas make five cakes, cupcakes, and chocolate covered strawberries for our wedding. Sugar Mamas desserts are beautiful and the flavor is out of this world! Lexi is very kind, easy to do business with, prompt, and creative. We will be life long customers to Sugar Mamas.

The cake was beautiful and tasted wonderful. Sugar Mamas made my daughter’s graduation a little bit sweeter!

I ordered a Vanilla cake with white choclate frosting for my husbands retirement party. It was absolutely delicious and everyone loved it. The decorative writing was perfect. Thank you Sugar Mamas Bakery!

This woman is as sweet as her baked goods!
She is my go-to for wedding cakes and desserts for my catering business, Quality from Scratch, she always amazes me, and my clients are thrilled every time!

Real Butter, need I say more? So many things to delight from fresh muffins, to cinnamon rolls with just a hint of lemon in the cream cheese frosting. Homemade goodness in every bite, whether a morning pastry or a tart for supper. You will not be disappointed!

Lexi's baked good are absolutely the best ever! Thank you for adding to the culinary delights of Flagstaff🌹

flavors are never overwhelming or too sweet! with lots of complex flavors depending on requested batter