C.J. Maggie's

Enjoyed our lunch here yesterday! Cozy atmosphere, huge menu, great service. I had the Sicilian sub and my husband had the chicken pot pie. Both were generous sized and delicious. Even my side salad was fresh and tasty.

Great spot for lunch or dinner. The pot pie was super good with large chunks of chicken. The Mac-cheese is good and the dinner salad is quite large. Portions overall are large, you will not leave hungry. Suzanne our server was great and offered honest menu suggestions since it was our very first visit. Thank you Suzanne for make our visit memorable.

Wow! This place was amazing! I had no idea it was a chain till I came to leave a review. It was so good and fresh and the staff was amazing. I seriously thought it was a local family place.

We found it online from Google reviews and it looked amazing. When we pulled up it looked like it was closed. Luckily for us, someone walked out while I was back on Google looking for another place. They said the restaurant was still open so we went in.

My hub and I bought opted for pasta, I got the lasagne and he got the Mediterranean pasta. Hands down the very best restaurant pasta I've had! It was stacked high and had a cup of sauce on the side. His dish was fresh and light. He did say his chicken was lacking a little flavor itself but overall the dish was amazing. We had a fresh warm loaf of bread and then he finished it off with fresh raspberry ice cream. Our bill for all of that was only $38.

Totally impressed and I highly recommend it.

This place is amazing. I got a hamburger here and it was absolutely delicious. They used fresh ground beef and it tasted homemade. Also like the ambience here it’s very low light and intimate. My server was very friendly and kept my drink cup full. If I’m ever in town again, I will definitely come back here.

Our last night in the area and stopped in for dinner after a hike. So glad we did. Service was great. Had the cheese fries and we both got a codzilla and baked chips. Portions were huge and it was so big I couldn't even finish it. Best part was the home made ice cream. Best ice cream ice ever had hands down. We will most def be back if we are ever in the area again.

Had to make a rare visit to Elkton and the person I was meeting with took me for lunch. What a great little place. The food and the service both excellent. Had a great lunch with plenty to eat in a great little atmosphere.

Such a great find on a quick adventure trip! Menu was diverse and extensive, food was good, decor was quirky vintage, price was good, service was quick and friendly. If we’re ever back in the area, we would definitely come back.

As anyone who has seen any of my reviews knows I’m picky about my food. I Finally found a place worthy of my taste buds. And the service was awesome better come hungry cause they give you your money’s worth. Don’t remember the waitress’s name and I’m sorry. I Had the stuff pork loin wife got the shrimp salad n the nachos we are still nibbling on the nachos which reminded me to post a review. Hat’s off to CJ Maggie’s it’s 21:15 and still full we even walked to Walgreen’s cause we were on the bike to help burn it off didn’t help. The waitress knew we were doing it to n laughed.

This was a cute little place. The service was good and the food was great. I think it had the best calzone, made in a wood fire oven.

Visiting family and went here for Monday evening dinner. TONS to choose from!
I picked the pork loin with stuffing and caramel glaze. It was SOOO GOOD.
That's said, if even in town again, I'd likely ask for extra glaze 😉 the sides were a great size (enough for sharing)
Two other dishes got good high praise (nachos and something sorry I forget the name)
One dish out of four was found wanting-the French dip sandwich. Maybe skip that one in future 🤔

I had a delicious salad here for Dinner. And a very delicious Chicken Alfredo for lunch the next day and OMG!, had to be about the best Chicken Alfredo I ever Had. The service was really great too. Thnk u for your kind Service. From a Southern California Gal🙋🏽‍♀

Really cool local place. We were there early so the host had a hard time finding us, but the waitress was excellent! Great feel good food, excellent homemade ice cream.

This place has great food!
The restaurant has fun, eclectic decor, and it's clean. The wait staff is great! We had chicken and beef fajitas, artichoke spinach dip and sweet teas. A great lunch with left overs!

The place is so cute inside, there is an inside and outside area . The food is delicious, so flavorful, full portions. 10 out of 10. 4 people with drinks and dinner entrees $75...service was great too. Cassie!

This was our first time eating at
C J Maggie's. We were staying in town to hike Seneca Rocks and to take a train ride to Upper Tygart Falls on the Durbin and Greenbrier Valley Railroad. We had Zucchini Strips for an appetizer and Jambalaya and Chicken Fettuccine Alfredo as the entree. It was amazing. The portions are huge. It was plenty for two meals. The salad dressings are all homemade and delicious and the service was great. Will definitely be back when we are in the area again. 👍👍👍

Great atmosphere and great food. Had the French dip this time around and it was fantastic. The rest of the table got pizzas and enjoyed them as well. Their bar was closed while I was there but it looks super nice. This is a frequent stop when we're passing through Elkins. Wish they would open one in Huntington!

We were passing thru Elkins, WV and thought we’d try this place out. Glad we did! The food is delicious, the portions are huge, the prices are (more than) fair and the service was excellent! Our server was Carlee and she was so friendly and funny, and yet very professional. She (literally) runs to be sure you have what you need. You don’t wait on anything. My husband got the Stuffed Pork Loin and Apples with Onion Straws and a Salad. I got the 3 piece Pollock, Onion Straws and French Onion Soup. We could not finish our meals. This is a definite, must stop place!

Good restaurant! The restaurant is popular with both locals and guests of the town. Be prepared to wait 20 minutes for free tables on Friday night! The service is good, the waiters are polite and friendly! The menu is varied and everyone can find what he needs. The portions are very big! Our food was delicious and our family had an enjoyable evening at the restaurant.

Huge portions! Hundreds of choices! Number one place to eat when you are in Elkins. Our table had tacos, quesadilla, calzones and more. All excellent!!

Our hotel recommended MAGGIE'S. Food was not only delicious but so plentiful my husband & I had another meal. The most exceptional thing was my husband left his cell phone, not realizing it until the hotel front desk phoned to tell us it would be delivered later that night. The bartender went to the trouble of finding where we were staying AND delivered the phone to our hotel. We left a hefty tip at the front desk, but they refused to take it, saying it was no trouble. Really? What and 😇. If management is listening, you should be proud of your employee for going above and beyond. We are so grateful for this gift of kindness. Thank You for not only an excellent dining experience but for your great care.