Wiseguys Pizzeria & Pub

Good stuffed Chicago style pizza. It does take a while to make it, so if you're really hungry plan on ordering an appetizer. We had garlic bread this time, but we have also enjoyed the mozzarella sticks and split a salad. We went at 5:30 on a Friday and were able to be seated right away. The dining area has always been dark and cozy, but with March Madness going on they were playing basketball on most of the tvs. Like halfway through our meal they turned up the volume so much so that the conversation at our table turned to shouting to be able to hear each other. They have a good drink menu here, and when the weather is nice they have a patio that they allow you to bring your dog to while you eat 😊. Also on Fridays they have fish fry options on the menu as well.

I just wanted to say thank you for all the meals I've had over the past several years with my religious historian friend Chester. Unfortunately our friend has died. We always loved going into Wiseguys and getting a beer and pizza together. He was a good friend and will be missed. Thank you for having the best place to eat to have friends with. Great staff, great service!

I was looking for some good pizza. I didn't want the cookie cutter chain style pizza. This place is definitely legit. I went with the hand tossed and it did not disappoint. Perfect balance of chewy/crunchy crust. I really enjoyed the cheesy goodness.
Keep up the good work. This is definitely my new favorite in the valley.

Our 1st time Here and the food was awesome A pizza was Delicious My four-year-old daughter got spaghetti And finished before everyone And she said it was super good Full bar Good fish tacos on Friday and all sorts of sandwiches restaurants Atmosphere and decorations are supremely cool The restaurant is dim And I liked it

This is my favorite pizza in Appleton. The food is always delicious. Some of the servers are better than others. The garlic flapper pizza is great. Drinks are kinda pricey.

Amazing place, cozy atmosphere, very nice staff. Ordered the homemade alfredo and added chicken, mushrooms, spinach, and artichoke. Super tasty and filling. Definitely trying the pizza next time!

There's nothing worse then a bland pizza but that's Not what you'll get at Wiseguys pizza.

Great zesty sauce.

We really liked the hand tossed pizza and in loved the stuffed pizza.

I was really pleasantly surprised with this place .

The food was great - bruschetta, calzone and a pizza. Ashley was awesome. The place is very well decorated. My only, very slight, issue was that it was a little dark for me - turn up the lights just a bit.

My favorite pizza in the Fox Cities! From the hand tossed crust and the mild sauce, so delicious. Grace was my server-fast, friendly and attentive, my glass was never empty. Highly recommend! And will return!

Love this place. Their pizza is very good. If you like a bit of spice make sure to try the zesty sauce. Not to hot, just enough to add an extra burst of welcome flavor. My wife and I absolutely love their calzones! Dough is soft but holds together nicely. Great presentation. And every ingredient seems to be of the highest quality. We generally order to go and the service is always prompt. I keep telling my wife that we need to get babysitters and go their for date night because it is beautiful inside. Classy pizzeria at a fair price. Highly recommended!

First time. Pizza was great! Had the thin crust. Toppings were plentiful and delicious. Loved that I could get a tasty old fashioned with my pizza. Salad was so-so, but the pizza will definitely bring us back!

The deep dish pizza was great. Our server was excellent.

My favorite pizza in Appleton. Chicago stuffed pizza does take 40-50 minutes to cook but it’s worth the wait.

Even though they seemed short handed, the guys were always there with a soda or water refill. Chicago pizza was fabulous, My wife's thin crust looked and smelled great. Definitely go again

I don't know about these other reviews. Maybe they're used to Domino's or something. But their Pizza is amazing and Authentic tasting and you can tell it's made w love. Service is also great and friendly always on top. Great atmosphere. I like the music they play , 80s which is a plus for me, I couldn't stay still...lol... Keep up the great work. Also gotta add those boneless wings are to die for, best in the fox valley I would say.

Excellent Chicago style pizza. Pizzas take 40 mins to an hour to be made, the wait is well worth it.

Delish!!!!!! Our group of 6 stopped in tonight for pizza and sangria - all fabulous!

I enjoyed their incredible gluten free crust with triple mushroom - wow… heaven! YOU MUST INDULGE in the Betty Paige ( egg plant fries) AHHHH!!! The best we've ever had!

We really enjoyed the atmosphere, low lighting , cozy temp, friendly servers, delish food and wonderful beer & SANGRIA of the Gods!!

Our only suggestion is to add a hostess by the front door.

We waiting about 20 min and no one greeted us...and had to hunt down a server in the back to request a table.

Overall we liked the food and look forward to returning !! Thank you all for your hard work!

Superior Pizza. Crust as it is supposed to be, Sauce which has substance and great taste, the toppings are fresh and plentiful. The 14" we had was perfect for 2.

Great family feel

Visited for the first time last week, even though I've lived in town for years. Absolutely love this place. The Chicago pizzeria vibe is very authentic. Pizza is on a different level. Please allow ample time for ordering if getting deep dish. Definitely will be back!

Finally found my favorite pizza in Appleton. Nice atmosphere with soft lighting. Every time we go the service is excellent. We get thin crust with zesty sauce. The meatball poppers appetizer are the best meatballs I've ever tasted, mmm that sauce! Nice selection of beers too.