The Onion Tree

Top notch Italian/Indian super spot. Lamb curry was delicious as was the potato soup. Paneer Kebab was generous with a nice mint sauce. Wild Montauk bass served with rice was great. Seating is a little tight. Service was helpful and friendly. We had the forbidden rice pudding for dessert which was fabulous.

A few weeks ago I had the pleasure of dining at The Onion Tree with my brother and his friends for his birthday. And it was honestly one of the best dining experiences I have had in a long time. The ambiance of the restaurant is great, as it feels lively while maintaining a cozy and friendly vibe during the dining experience.

We sampled quite a few dishes on the menu and two of the standouts for me were the braised short rib pizza, savory and delicious and the oatmeal lamb dish, which had a wonderful blend of flavor and texture. But the food is outstanding and every dish was absolutely delicious.

Thanks to the owners and staff for a wonderful experience, if any place deserves 5+ stars it is here. Looking forward to my next meal here!

Visited to celebrate my wife’s birthday. Had a great time, food was delicious, service was outstanding. We will be back with some friends very soon.

The Paneer Pizza and everything we had was fantastic.

Thank you Chef Jay for making my wife’s birthday so special.

This is our second time ordering from the Onion Tree, and it certainly won’t be the last. The chicken tikka masala pizza is so flavorful and the crust is always baked to perfection. Our stove broke so we haven’t been able to cook - naturally, we had to order some delicious pizza! I can’t wait to try some of the more traditional Indian dishes on the menu, too. Thank you Onion Tree for coming in clutch with delicious and unique food!

Great place to eat with good food. Cozy atmosphere. Super friendly staff. There is a small outdoor space. The oven for the pizzas are small so if you order a lot of them it takes a little while. Pizzas are personal size.

This place was everything i expected and more. The service was excellent. Personally we got the palak paneer(mustard green with cheese) pizza which had excellent taste, crust was crispy , definitely suggest. For the main course we tried the butter chicken and the dal(lentils with kidney beans) . Both excellent, with great flavor profiles. All entrees came with rice , two rotis( bread) and a cucumber salad. Suggest getting reservations a week in advance as the place is popular. Ample street parking right infront.

Creativity overflows at this truly amazing restaurant. Every dish is more flavorful than the other, pictures don’t do any justice and if you know the original dish their version is a joyful mindfu@k. The drinks were a mixologist dream and dessert was outstanding. Can’t wait to be back for dinner and their pop up specials. Hats off to overly talented ingenious chef!!

Awesome !! Great food, great service, good atmosphere... Very happy and had a good dinner !
The food is very delicious, tasty, flavorful and really Indian!
Service was super nice, clean.
Restaurant is very cozy, quiet, everything was good !
I recommend it and will definitely coming back

I love this place! The food is clean, fresh and delicious. Same for the drinks. I had a blood orange margarita which was made with fresh juice, not too sweet, and perfectly balanced. Our server, Carmine, was very knowledgeable about the menu and very passionate about the food he is serving. I’ve eaten here twice already and both times the experience was perfect. Highly recommend. Taco Tuesday is a must!!

Amazing food, must try spicy Egg paratha

Amazingly good pizzas and Indian food. Atmosphere is cool as well. Get this chicken tikka masala pizza.

Quaint place tucked in the heart of Sea Cliff that was very busy during our visit - that’s always a good sign! The pizza was yummy and tasted fresh (it was gone before I got to take a pic lol) and the Dosa waffle was a unique appetizer that was creatively done and very flavorful. The meals were also excellent - my family ordered the chicken tikka masala and the butter chicken (see pics). We loved everything! This was also a great spot for a future date night, we will definitely be back!

Truly fantastic & unique. Very authentic, both the indian cuisine & the napolitano style pizza. Jay’s recipes are masterful & well-executed. Highly recommended.

The spicy margarita was also great, & the drinks menu is full of interesting choices.

Food is amazing! Fresh, flavorful, and original concepts. The prices can't be beat and the service was wonderful. Thank you Kevin, Raquel and Jay! PS photos don't do the food justice.

Great place to have brunch in Long Island, they have a very varied menu and I loved the methodology they use for the options and they were also very friendly to offer me bottomless orange juice since I was not in a mimosa mood, the atmosphere is very pleasant and peaceful, perfect to go with friends or just you.

The Onion Tree is a standout dining spot. The relaxed ambiance sets the stage for an impressive blend of authentic Indian and Italian cuisine, featuring dishes like chicken tikka masala pizza. The staff is friendly and attentive, making for a memorable experience. Onion Tree is a must-visit for those looking for a unique culinary adventure that combines great flavors with genuine hospitality.

Cozy and inviting atmosphere, perfect local vibe (murals of Hendrix and Jerry always a good option) and gorgeous craft cocktails cheffed up by the friendliest bartenders. Oh and the food is just exquisite. We had the tikka masala pizza and the palak paneer and one is better than the next. If you love Indian food, go. If you are Indian food curious, go. If you’ve never tried Indian food, GO!!!

The food was next level. Everything was so delicious and the chefs made recommendations that were spot on. Yum. Yum. Yum.

Absolutely loved this place! They have very unique dishes that you can’t get at any other restaurant. Everyone was welcoming and very friendly. I loved watching my pizza get cooked right next to my table. Where else can you get Palak paneer pizza?!

Love this spot! I've never had a bad meal for both brunch or dinner... plus you can't turn down bottomless brunch!!
One of the owners is always there, and they are incredibly sweet people that will remember your name the next time in!
Their pizza and burgers are amazing, and brunch is a phenomenal twist on a typical brunch menu.