Lib's Supper Club

You will definitely want to make a reservation as they fill up fast. The service was very friendly and speedy. The food tasted like a good home cooked Italian meal. There was enough food in one meal for about 3 people. Definitely plan on some leftovers. The only downside for me, personally, was the dim lighting.

My wife and I had a great meal. She has surf and turf. I had down under shrimp. Fantastic. You will definitely have left overs. Linda did a great job taking care of us.

I have lived in the area my whole life but had never been to Libs Super Club. I made a reservation that I needed to modify and the gentleman that I spoke to was super accomodating. I am pretty sure he is the same person that greeted us at arrival. I was pleased with the atmosphere: moody and romantic but also classic. I was happy to see the place was busy. Our waitress was Octavia. She made the recommendation to get some drinks and she was not wrong. We ordered a Washington Apple and a Long Island Ice Tea and the bartender definitely pours heavy which was appreciated. Octavia also laughed and joked with us at the end of our meal which was both funny and surprising but welcomed. Meal wise, everything was great. I ordered the haddock and it was perfectly cooked and while I don't normally like tartar sauce, I tried it and it was really good. The Peas were simple but delicious. We also ordered the 16 oz filet which was cooked well. We both loved the Buffalo shrimp appetizer. The garlic shrimp that came with the filet was delicious in my opinion (the person who ordered it didn't love it, but that's ok, more for me). All in all, we had a really great meal and would definitely go back.

So nice! Mostly, polite folks working there. Had a small issue with drinks being cut of our group too early, as several had bus runs and came to our union dinner late. They should have honored those as we still had the area, space until 8pm. They turned 4 guests away from the bar and did not honor the drink cards, and it had just turned 7pm!
Otherwise, a nice set up, majority of the food was good. Great turn put of our friends and family of ECSD BUS transportation department were gathered.

In a weird spot but everything was amazing! Service, food, bar, atmosphere and even the history of the place made it an experience. Had the NY Strip and Shrimp Provencle and ate so much that I was miserable the rest of the night…but like…in a good way! I couldn’t stop eating. Probably the best shrimp I’ve ever had. Service with a huge smile. Prices are high but you definitely get what you pay for. Highly recommend!

My first time at libs was in 1982. Been going ever since. Always fresh and fabulous. The food is delicious especially my favorite the Gorgonzola chicken or filet with scampi. The best house Italian salad on the planet. Order the cheesy garlic bread!

Very good to great experience. Went for the Italian food and was not disappointed at all. Some of the best in the area. Make reservations and ask to be seated in the much more picturesque main dining room.

My family and I love Libs! The food is always amazing and the staff have always been friendly and accommodating. The restaurant is a bit dated, but that doesn't matter to us as long as the food is good! I highly recommend Libs to anyone that gets the chance to go!

Fun, quick seating (simply make reservations) absolutely outstanding food/drinks, and exceptional service. Price is very fair considering portion size! Ignore those temper tantrum 1/2 star reviews, and give Libs a well deserved try.

Consistently amazing food!! I've tried several dinners, & ALWAYS above average, great service & selection. Extra large portions!! We go back every other month...its a special treat! Pics L- medium strip steak w/chicken scampi. R-Blackened Prime Rib, med/well w/shrimp scampi...perfection💙

Haven't been here in a while- no reason not to come other than we are 30 minutes away. Enjoyed our meals and we'll worth the drive! Advise reservations- glad we thought to do that. No delays at all

Without a doubt the best NY Strip steak I’ve ever had. Cooked to a perfect medium rare with a perfect char on the outside. I also had the clams and sweet peppers as appetizers which were excellent as well. Pasta side dish was cooked perfectly and the marina sauce had that old world feel and taste. Will be back most definitely. Kelly was our server. She was attentive to anything we needed. I will definitely ask for her as my server again.

Looking for great food that comes with a great experience? Make a reservation for Lib's Supper Club. We celebrate our anniversary there every year and sometimes visit other days (we live 45 minutes away). Stepping inside this low-lit space is like going back in time to a popular celebrity hot spot, and their pictures along with Hollywood memorabilia are what you'll find decorating the walls. Straight ahead is a small, intimate bar with its friendly tenders busy mixing drinks and drawing drafts. Surrounding the bar are two dining rooms and two banquet rooms, so you never know if you'll be vicariously celebrating someone else's event at the same time. Attire varies so dress to your comfort. Lib's is known for steak and seafood with good reason; both are excellent. We usually get one of the Shrimp Scampi Florentine; warning ⚠ must love butter and garlic! The service is top notch and there's something special about listening to and seeing servers navigate their food carts to tables of happy patrons as you anticipate your turn. Portions are very generous, so plan on having some for lunch the next day. I highly recommend going to Lib's!

Hadn't been here in quite and i must say, I was happy with we went. Everyone in our Party of 5 said the same thing...Food was Great and that our Server Chad was Awesome!!

Incredibly delicious food! Everything from the cocktails to dessert were over the top. We considered the prices to be good, considering the amount of food that is served. We would certainly enjoy eating here at least once a week. It's that good!

I absolutely loved everything my plate and I saw how hard and fast Mr. Conner Hall works, and my appetizer and my side of pasta that Conner cooked is out of this world delicious. He is an awesome worker for such a young age. Absolutely awesome man. I give him and the restaurant 5 stars. I'm a very happy man here. Thank you.

Perfect for date night, or family meal. Lovely ambience. Waitress was really nice too. Can’t wait to be back!

Absolutely the best food and service ever! The portions are HUGE! Added bonus they have so many famous photos, including Donald Trump! Highly recommend!

Only been here once but will be going again. Best chicken Parmesan I've ever had. Both entrees were very generous in size with a price that wasn't as big as the plate. Many interesting things all around to look at such as signed pictures of famous people, some of which we were told visited this restaurant. To see this place from street you'd think it's not good, you'd be very wrong! Go here, try this, you won't be disappointed.

Little hole in the wall... definitely worth the trip. Awesome chicken Parm. If you are traveling we recommend you share ... The portions are large.