Casola's Pizza & Grill

I came here upon recommendations from a few people and reviews on Facebook. It's only 15 minutes from my house and I can't believe I have never been here before. They were so friendly and helpful. Our waitress, Ellie, was so kind. The special calamari they have on the app list Was probably the best I've ever had. Pastas were great. Their credit card machine wasn't working and we didn't have enough cash, they were so accommodating. Thankfully we were able to leave our credit card number. I can't think of another place that would be so understanding about that. Amazing little place, can't wait to return!

My wife and I visiting family and ended up coming here to spend some time alone. We were surprised by the high quality of food and the very inviting atmosphere. We got the vodka penne pasta and the rib eye cheese steak both very good and filling. recommend everyone stop here to eat if they end up near this cute small town!

It has been a wonderful experience from beginning to end. Be sure to make reservations if you’re eating in. The staff are pleasant and bubbly. Greeted and served with smiles

Everything was great. Differently, different types of pizza I've had but still had great flavor. I'm just not useto the humidity in New Jersey.

Broccoli rabe is a must! prepared with sausages and garlic sauce, perfection!

Our first time here, will definitely be back. Cozy atmosphere, staff was so pleasant, kind and attentive. Food was amazing! Tuna appetizer, fried calamari, Salmon salad were spot on and then some, and the Seafood Paella was best we ever had.

The food was excellent. Our server recommended the Margherita pizza. We got that and an italian sub. Portions were good. The outside seating area was nice. I will always come back here when I’m in the area

Very nice Italian family place. Great decor. Tables are spread out, so there is some privacy. Location is a little out of the way, but worth the trip. We only had pizza, but it was very good and we'll be back to try other dishes. Bathroom was spotless.

Loved this place! Great atmosphere, great staff and delicious food!! By far the best Rigatoni Bolognese I have ever had! Will definitely be back! Thanks for a great experience 👍

Stopped traveling through from JFK airport. Just may have to drive back one day for dinner. Food was delicious and service was perfect!!

Casola's is one of the finest Italian restaurants in the tri-state area. I've had their Pizza (several styles), wings, 3 entrees and 2 desserts over the last year. All were amazing and too delicious to describe here. The staff and management are hard working, quick moving, and always polite. I highly recommend Casola's for any of your lunch or dinner plans. My fiance and I often choose Casola's for a nice, quiet date night that will now include our yearly anniversary. Outdoor dinning area is excellent and very clean, as is the restaurant itself. Casola's is now my favorite restaurant in town, so come on by and enjoy this great place!

We had the Buffalo Wings and the Philly Cheesesteak. Hubby said that was gorgeous and I asked for my last rites. Need any more convincing? 😁

Best Pizza I've had yet on the east coast! I had a great time here. Super friendly staff, great atmosphere, marvelous pizza. If you're in the area, it's a MUST STOP! Will definitely return.

Food was superb many items to choose from pizza to entrees. Small and folks packed in. Dine in & pick up. BYOB.

Very delicious food and wonder staff too, very pleasant experience.

Love this restaurant. Look forward to coming in summer and dining outside. They told us they have music in summer. Nice people

Excellent artichoke pesto chicken!
Amazing pistachio cake. Highly recommend

I am used to pizza at the Jersey Shore where I live and NYC where I work but I have to say this pizza is GREAT!..... Definitely check them out!

This is not only a great pizza place, but our waitress was the best we've ever experienced. She came to check on us multiple times, refilled drinks, and was just super nice. Food was excellent and not overpriced. When we were ready to leave the owner came over and talked with us awhile too. Such a nice place and pleasant experience. My daughter chose Casola's based on reviews and she nailed it. She's in charge of where we eat on vacations from now on.

Great food and love the pizza. Walter