Carlo's Gourmet Pizzeria, Restaurant & Caterers

Awesome pizzeria. Very friendly very attentive. Food is fresh and hot. Prices are very affordable. Atmosphere is delightful. I go with my wife and my son probably once every two weeks for dinner. Great place highly recommend.

I lived in Marlboro 20 years ago, so when I was visiting the old neighborhood, I was pleasantly surprised to see Carlo's still in business. I didn't see Maria, but the same great food, etc... some traditions should never change!! 👍

such an amazing experience learning to make pizza and gnocchi!! one of the BEST girls night out in a long time!!! thank you Carlos pizza for all of your cooking knowledge and hospitality- cannot wait to do it again

Fantastic gluten-free options and friendly staff. The food is always fresh and worth the drive from Staten Island. Long-time customer and will continue to recommend to friends and family.

I attended a birthday party here for my son’s friend. The atmosphere was awesome, it was like a big open kitchen. They welcomed a third party company to come in and entertain the kids. The food was delicious and the staff was very friendly and welcoming. I look forward to eating there again!

Place is nice looking and clean. Friendly staff. A wide variety of menu options and so many different slices. Food is excellent. Highly recommend Carlo's Gourmet Pizza if you in the area.

Great location for kids parties. I’ve been to this location many times as a hired face painter and everyone seemed to have a great time. The staff is friendly and professional, always present to make sure everyone is comfortable and taken care of.

Aside from the store, they have a party room, where kids can make their own pizza, and an extra room where parents can sit down and enjoy themselves, too…

After hearing people rave about Carlo's, I finally stopped in.
I'm sorry I didn't stop in sooner.

They can't do enough for their guests. No alcohol is served here. I am not sure. But I think you can BYOB.
They have an extensive Gluten-free menu 😋 ❤

Super fun Pizza making birthday party at Carlo’s. Thank you Matt for teaching us how to make pizza!

We just had our son’s 9th birthday party at Carlo’s and it was awesome!! The kids loved making their own pizzas, and the adults had fun too! The pizza was delicious, the room was bright and cheery, and Matt the Chef was wonderful with the kids! Several said it was the best party they have been to! Couldn’t have asked for a better experience!

Carlo's has the best pizza! They offer traditional pizza and thin crust pizza too! We love the eggplant thin crust pizza the best! The staff are so friendly and courteous. Their dining area has tables with tablecloths, beautiful! We recommend dining at Carlo's when you want delicious food!

My wife and daughter's have gone to 2 birthday party's here and they had so much fun! Also delicious Pizza 🍕!

Wonderful! It started out awesome when I called to order, and everyone's energy on the phone was on point. I placed my order, got an eta, and when I showed up my order was ready to go! Very friendly staff, and the food was even better! I shared a large calzone with my partner, and it was fantastic. You know my reviews are honest when I eat the food too fast to take a picture of it for my post!

Ordered back to back and i wished i took pictures of yesterdays feast instead of todays lonely lunch lol pizza is good , kids loved the chicken tenders w honey mustard.. caesar and buffalo wraps are delish.. altho i prefer the buffalo wraps more.. penne with vodka sauce also delish and thanks for accommodating my small requests !!

Great little place that we found accidentally while driving from the shore. They have an extensive gluten-free menu with pizza, pasta, and even a few appetizers like fried calamari which was very good. I also had gluten-free eggplant rollatini but it was a bit bland for my taste. We'll come back for sure to check out the pizza too.

I’ve dined in and taken out. Carlos Gourmet Pizza is the Best pizza I’ve ever eaten and I’ve eaten the BEST . I love the thin crispy crust, delicate flavorful sauce, and just the right amount of cheese! I feel loved when I eat a slice (or two) of Carlos Gourmet Pizza

We had my daughter’s 5th birthday here and everything from the food to the service was amazing. The staff did a great job with setting up the room and the kids (and parents) had so much learning how to make pizza! Would definitely recommend having your next party or event there!

Our family orders pizza from Carlos, and it is delicious. We love this restaurant and decided to have my daughter's 13th birthday here. The food was delicious, and I can't say enough kind things about John, the owner, and Jenn and Regina who helped with our party and made sure that there was always enough food and beverage on hand for our guests. I would give more than five stars if Icould. .

Excellent pizza and great customer service.

They took a page out of Michael Scott’s business strategies and delivered a sample box of delicious pizza. Any business willing to do something like that randomly for a business complex deserves all our support. 100% recommend this place to anyone, the owner and staff are probably as great as the pizza

Love their vegan pizzas - not many places out there offering vegan pizzas - very fresh and flavorful everytime