Top Tomato Supermarket

The Bay St Top Tomato is very clean, organized & has very pleasant employees. I do all my shopping there on a weekly basis. I recently redeemed my receipts for a great deal being offered if you spend either $500 or $250, within a months time. I chose a 1/2 tray of Chicken Marsala as my gift & it was overstocked with chicken cutlet, super tender & over all delicious! If you need a pick up & go meal, they also have many to select from & I’ve never been disappointed. 5+ stars place!

I have been on Staten island for 30 yrs and this is the place to come from shopping to catering your event. They have awesome prices. Fresh fruits and vegetables everyday. Seasoned meats. Fresh pastry. I love the Deli department the guys their are awesome they are so engaging and helpful the deli food is so good. The Cold cuts combo prices are great. Today I finally I had the pleasure meeting Nick(owner). The store is so organized and so clean. Great job to your staff keep on smiling and being professional and courteous to your customers Nice in receiving 10 percent off as an health worker(RUMC) it made my day being recognized.Please let me know if you can donate holiday food baskets to our needy families for the holidays . We always order from your catering dept we look no further your the best Thank you!

Always great, fresh produce, and even nicer people. The owners are great!

Love their homemade prepared foods! Deli department! Stuffed chicken breast, stuffed pork chops, stuffed portobello mushrooms, spinach quiche! Fabulous selection, and always fresh! So fortunate to have them right here on Bay Street!

Top Tomato Super Store located at 1071 Bay Street, Staten Island, NY, has everything you need! Clean, good prices, lovely and friendly people. Customer service was A1!

Great deli. Staff is usually quick about handling the lunch rush

Great local place for deli and meats (that’s what I usually shop for here.) They also have a decent produce selection that does vary and shelves, fridges stocked with basics. The cashiers are always friendly and do their job efficiently.

Great for fresh produce at reasonable prices, also carries a lot of Italian specialty items. Always stocks fresh arugula, basil, and escarole virtually year round, and there are not many places even on Staten Italy where you can say that. Decent cheese and beer selections too. Come here for the fruits and vegetables and specialty items, not the limited selection of supermarket staples like paper products obviously. But overall, totally changed the neighborhood for the better when they opened some years back.

Well stocked. Clean and tidy store. Staff are very nice, helpful and professional. Prices are reasonable.

Well stocked and very clean store.
Cashiers and manager are very courteous and helpful. Prices are reasonable. Speaking for myself, only the seafood price maybe a bit high.

A special thank you to Rob at Top Tomato at Bay St. for the delicious food that was catered for my Christmas dinner. I enjoyed it with my family and had a great day with my grandchildren.

Placed order for catering, the food was fresh and the order was delivered on time. Friendly staff and excellent service. I would recommend this store for catering to anyone. Thanks for your professionalism.

they had exactly what i was lookign for, store was very well organized and the employees were extremely helpful especially the cashiers. Would definitely recommend!!!

I love this store, everything is cheap . Fruits and vegetables are fresh. The foods at the deli are also delicious.

The cashiers and the workers are also friendly.

The prices are pretty cheap and they have pretty quality goods, and the staff are pretty okay. Just because it is very close and there is no 4.5 star rating, I'll give this a five star.

Really good prices, excellent variety of fresh fruits and vegetables. I like the new oil and balsamic vinegar in glass refill bottles.

There breakfast sausage (is the Best) and meats are quality. I love all there homemade goods. Thanks for good quality Top Tomato 💜

More expensive than other neighborhood supermarkets. But WELL worth it! I don't buy anywhere else.

Small but great grocery store. Everything was organized and pretty decent produce selection.

I’ve been in top tomato shopping and is the greatest super market I’ve been in! Love their products