Sal's Pizza Mamaroneck

Ohhh mannn! I needed a quick slice before going to the movies and this place did not disappoint! Best part of this area is that there are two restaurants across the street from one another that serve pizza. This one looked like I could get a quick slice. I was wrong! I had to wait on line to order two regular slices. My theory is if a pizzeria has a line it must be good! It def was! So good that I burned my top gums also cause I was in a rush. I loved the taste to the slice and the customer service was great. Everyone is on point and they work like a team! I can’t wait to go back there and order different dishes and not rush while eating. Can’t wait to enjoy their slices and pepperoni pinwheels! 🥳

Old school hole in the wall with outstanding pizza. Been eating Sal's for over 40 years now. Never had a bad pie. Sicilian and salad slice also worth trying if that's your thing. Cash Only!!!

Danielle cetani who said the Sicilian is not worth it must not know what good pizza is. I have eaten at Sal's since I was a kid in the late 80s. I now live in Fishkill NY in dutchess county and will drive an hour for a slice of Sal's Sicilian. I actually take an entire pie home 😮. Also salad slice is amazing because they have best Italian dressing around. That woman doesn't know pizza ignore her comment coming from a person from dutchess county where good Sicilian doesn't exist. Antonellas is the best option and it's a joke compared to Sal's ❤!!!

Known for one of the best Sicilian slices around (well earned reputation). But the their standard slices are phenomenal as well.

I’ve been coming to this place for years! Their pizza is one of the Best! It’s always busy because their quality pizza has made them renown in Westchester. The pizza here never disappoints, but one of my favorite items to order is their Grilled Chicken Salad with mozzarella. It’s delicious! I recommend this pizzeria even to my enemies! 😀

If you want the best Italian food and pizza around the New York City area, come to Sal's in Mamaronek. I've been coming here since I was a kid. I've tried everything and it's all delicious.

It’s still some of the best pizza anywhere - and the only spot I will travel an out of my way for. No one makes Sicilian like they do, and while salad pizza was a fad when it came out, Sal’s made it best and still does it right. Their plain slice is also a classic New York style. See why locals are hooked on it for generations.

Pizza is always great. Very friendly staff. This place is cash only, but they do have ATM on site. I have been going here since I was a teenager, and now I bring my sin here, and he loves their pepperoni pizza.

Me and my friend Dana really love it here. She says it's the best pizza in Westchester (she's German). Always our go-to!!!

Best Sicilian slice in Westchester.
Worth the trip.
Unique ambiance.

Ordered a full Sicilian pepperoni pizza for my family of five following the fireworks on the fourth of July. We ended up taking much of it home, which I'm grateful for because it's one of the best Sicilian pizzas I've had.

Reasonable prices (cash only), and even when the line is long, they know how to keep things moving.

I've tried other pizza places on Mamaroneck Ave, and Sal's is the clear winner.

Love this place. The chicken parm is as delicious as a fancy Italian restaurant and they'll bring it out to you with plates and silverware in the back if you dine in. Great pizza & take-out too.

Excellent pizza, fast service and the atmosphere is what you would expect from a little pizzeria. Definitely recommend

Seriously good, both the NY thin style and especially the Sicilian - get a corner slice with fresh basil.

Sal's is always awesome. Great for lunch, dinner, anytime. Take-out or dine in. Salad pizza is to die for.

Great pizza, lots of staff to help. It’s old school and only takes cash but they do have an ATM on property. I had a regular slice, salad slice, Sicilian and baked ziti with ricotta in my order to go. It was all really really good. I know people love their Sicilian and I understand why but I enjoyed the regular plain and the salad slice better. That’s just me. I prefer a thin NY slice of pizza. The Baked Ziti with Ricotta was outstanding and I will get it again. This place was busy but they manage it well and have a pretty good process for both dining in and taking out. Parking is the only problem but I parked a couple blocks away and walked. It was raining and it was still worth it. Go try this place.. You will enjoy it

So I’ve been coming here since 1990 and boy somethings luckily don’t change. Still my favorite pizza in the world.

Best pizza ever! Try their Sicilian, it’s a must.

The staff is highly qualified, they give you first-class attention and always make you feel at home.

Been coming here forever and got easily the best Sicilian pizza I’ve ever had. Other regular style pizza is decent nothing incredible. Staff are very friendly and prices are reasonable.