Mister Goodies Ice Cream

Dude. This is the best ice cream. The servings are massive. It's like going to a fair without actually having to go to a fair. We've gone the last two nights in a row and will probably go back tomorrow night. I got a hot fudge sundae and it comes with whipped cream, peanuts, and a cherry as well. I got it both nights and will probably get it again. I haven't been able to finish it either night, there's so much (I'm getting a small). They have forty bajillion things on their menu, and all the items my group has tried so far have been great.

Definitely a great low-key casual date place to share some ice cream.

The best ice cream in the entire world, not to mention the cutest truck, and the sweetest employees. My husband and I have gone on “Goodies Dates” for years. I just had a baby this past year and I am determined that his first taste of ice cream is going to be mister goodies. 100/10 recommend

Visiting from Ohio. My son said it’s a Liberty favorite!! This is a Ooey-Gooey PB sundae. So good!!

Phenomenal flavor! Pictured below is sea salt caramel topped with cake batter. Extensive menu options catering to anyone's taste. Being from a coastal town with plenty of ice cream options Mister Goodies is high on my list.

My first visit & I'm impressed with the service & quality of their signature offering the chocolate fudge brownie topped with vanilla ice cream chopped nuts whipped cream & cherry on top!
Warm brownie helped melt the ice cream! Delicious! I ate the whole thing! Big one!

Great ice cream. Cheap, easy parking, big portions. Was a great end for an warm summer evening visiting with friends and family. Next time you are in Lynchburg, stop by. Can't wait to visit again.

Wow… just wow… what a wonderful treat. Be for warned, the portions are huge so order a small or bring a friend.

Phenomenal selection, even though it was packed, the lined moved quickly and we got our ice cream in short order.

Glad to see that they had some vegan/ dairy free options available! The oreo milkshake with almond milk was one of the best I've ever had.

Mr. Goodies in a crowd favorite regionally! They serve up some of the best soft serve and hard serve ice creams and decadent treats! My favorite is the iconic brownie sundae! Yum! I love this place!!!

On a hot summer night we rolled up to this neat little ice cream shop where we were greeted by Mrs. Goodie herself and given some good information and instructions which was nice since we had not been there before. Our party of 9 was served quickly and efficiently and our treats were a welcome flavor burst of enjoyment. There was a wide variety of things to choose from, but we had ice cream cones that were soo good. We sat around one of many outdoor picnic tables and had some nice family time. Thanks for an enjoyable end to our night.

A visit to Lynchburg is incomplete without a stop by this favorite establishment. Amble portions, great flavor, and wonderful community feel gives Mister Goodies that small town Norman Rockwell feel. Quick and friendly service completes the perfect summer night feel.

I was in love with the fact they rolled my ice cream cone in fruity pebbles and the had the soft serve mixed ice cream but they have several different soft serve flavors and they have different kinds of cereal to pick from

The ice cream creations are outstanding here! The sherbet texture was not smooth, but it was a minor fact against the other great ice cream selections. A must try!

I absolutely love this ice cream shop!! Their servings are HUGE!!! A kids size is what I eat most often, I love their soft serve it’s creamy, thick and doesn’t melt too fast. If you love Wendy’s soft serve, this place does it better!

After driving by it a few hundred times, I decided to pull in. 😌 so many flavors and a lot of options together with a great price, made this an instant hit.

Best Milkshakes around! Quick, quality service and always met with a cashier who is friendly and always gets our orders right and in our hands in a fast manner! Incredible treats that hit the spot on a hot day! No other place can make a better shake than Mister Goodies! Also love how they give back by having customers donate Toys for free treats!

This place is a staple in the community. There’s truly something for everyone and you’re sure to find something you like. They have dairy-free and vegan options, too!

Their soft serve cones are huge, so I wouldn’t recommend ordering anything bigger than a small unless you’re set on eating an extreme amount of ice cream.

Their sundaes are delicious and they’ve got rotating monthly specials! I’d also recommend their homemade hard ice cream.

Check out the line in this photo. I feel like it speaks volumes about Mister Goodies. If it wasn’t great, people wouldn’t wait in the long lines. With that being said, plan a little extra time when you come here. The line moves fairly quickly and if the weather is nice, it gives you a reason to be outside & socialize with your friends/family.

I ordered 2 Hot Dumplings and they were AWESOME!! The lady who took my order was beyond sweet and took her time with me. When I got my order it was amazing! The perfect amount of ice cream, whip etc. I asked the lady what the name was of the girl who made it and she said Avery or Ava one of the two (my hearing is off) And the lady who took my order said her name was Kaydan. Very happy with the customer service and the ice cream. Definitely coming back!

I C E C R E A M!!! Soft serve and hand dipped with all kinds of 'sprinkles' ! Will definitely be back! Don't let the crowd scare you off! We went on a WED night, and the tables and lot were full. Lots of dogs around, too! Walked up to the window, ordered, and had our ice cream in just a couple of minutes! Local spot!

The kids sized dipped cone was the perfect size! We also enjoyed the chocolate shake! A must try place for warm summer nights!