Nicky's Pizza

We ordered around 8pm tonight (Monday) on a whim because we hadn't had Nicky's in years! The staff was super friendly, our sausage pizza was amazing and huge! The cheese curds were plentiful and delicious as well! Their ranch tastes homemade and was great with the pizza and curds! We got a ton of food for the price and definitely will be back!!

Love this place! It’s a great little hole in the wall with impeccable service and really tasty food! The Holy Moly Mushroom pizza is so damn good! And the fried cheese curds are like crack!!!

Always love and look forward to getting pizza here. Always cooked to perfection and the staff is kind and courteous. I strongly recommend getting a pizza from here as it's some of the best I have ever had.

I was in town on business and mapped out local pizza places. I don’t consider myself an expert, but I’ve eaten pizza in lots of places. The crust was crunchy , the toppings were generous, the sauce was a perfect compliment and not overwhelming, and the service was quick and considerate. And a pro move...I took this to go and they put plastic over the cheese to prevent sticking to the paper. Nice touch. I’d recommend stopping if you’re in the area. Only downside was finding the parking in the rain and snow.

If you in the mood for a crispy thin crust pizza Nicky's is a great option. We ordered the Deluxe, no Gr peppers and added Gr Olives. Great sauce, and the onions appeared to sautéed prior to baking. Very Happy with the product. We order at approximately 515 on Sunday evening, delivery took about 35-40 minutes. Warm and fresh will,be back.

I had the Sheboygan pizza. It was some of the best thin crust pizza I've ever had. The crust was flavorful and the edge had a great crispy crunch. The balance of flavors was wonderful. The owner waited on us and he was a great host. If you're looking for an amazing pizza, go to Nicky's. Go now.

Ate at Nicky's on a Sunday for lunch. No other customers were in the restaurant, but being a football day, they were making lots of pizzas for delivery. We had great service. Drinks were served quickly and replenished. The pizza was hot and crispy and delicious! The restaurant is small, and clean, but sort of dark. We will definitely go back to try more of their pizzas. There was a great selection of pizza options and also a "make your own" section of the menu to get the exact toppings on a pizza that you would like.

Just tried their new menu... I had the chicken and cheese enchilada meal. EXCELLENT! My son had the steak taco meal...he LOVED IT! Love the rice and beans too! Enchiladas were full of tender chicken, tacos loaded with steak ...definitely will be back to try more!!

We just had one of the best thin crust pizzas that we have ever tasted!! Not only was the pizza amazing the staff is just as amazing. The young man serving the pizza had a hurt ankle. He said he came in so his boss would not be short staffed. Impeccable work ethic. And his hospitality was exceptional. Thank you for the great time. We will be back!

Good pizza, they will really be missed when they close. Thanks for all the years of awesome pizza

Got stuck in Sheboygan on our way to Oshkosh. Stumbled across this pizza joint, good pizza and the staff were super friendly

I bought a Gyro and fries with light on onions and fries, John gave me two of that sauce that I cant spell. I had to drive 30 minutes home, was killing me. Just nuked the fries and that was a amazing gyro. Fries were great, and that oreo dessert was awesome. Glad I tried it! Nice going John, I will be back for sure.

When you walk in the door your nose will tell you the food is going to be great.The BBQ chicken pizza was amazing! LOVED the crust and the ingredients were top quality. You wont find very many places that can deliver a quality pizza like Nicky's can.

Got 2 thin crust pizzas and one pan pizza for carry out. Delicious pizza! If you're getting the pan pizza make sure you have lots of napkins.

Me and my husband did a taste test between Faye's and Nicky's Faye's had about out of the 16 about half the pieces didn't have sausage. I feel that the sauce and sausage is way more flavorful. If you have a choice choose Nicky's.

This place has amazing pizza, but I tend to enjoy their chicken wings and recently I got a gyro that just amazed me it's balance of flavors! Always impressed with this place, thank you for doing such a great job! (they even have a gluten free menu!)

Ordered delivery tonight with my boyfriend. The man who dropped off the food was extremely polite, and the chicken, potato wedges, and mozzarella sticks were absolutely fantastic. I'm very satisfied. Their pizza is also very good.

Even though we came in late the staff was overly friendly and on top of it! Food was amazing. Prices vs portions are good! I live in Milwaukee and I would come back! Awesome place! Pizza and Stromboli were yummy!

Excellant food! Cute place and friendly. Was craving crispy chicken and it was super. I wish I was in town long enough to try the pizza. If I ever pass through again I'll make a point of it. Grandson's teriyaki chicken was wonderful too. Made from scratch, crispy and tender.

Best Chicken around and also great desserts! Customer service can be very busy depending on time of day! Mornings and afternoons are usualy not very busy untill around 4 till 11:00. It will get hectic and sometimes get backed up. We do take complaints very seriously and will refund, retake, and remake orders if necessary for the highest satisfaction of our customers!