Seeboth Delicatessen

I wish to begin by stating that this review is not a critique but rather a testament to my genuine admiration for this establishment. I regularly make a journey of over 40 miles solely to indulge in their delectable offerings, which, until today—March 2, 2024—have consistently exceeded expectations.

Allow me to illustrate with an example from today's visit: I ordered a breakfast sandwich, a perennial favorite of mine, which was as delicious as ever. Alongside it, I opted for the "American fries," a nostalgic treat reminiscent of Wisconsin's culinary delights.

However, what I received for my take-out order was not the usual crispy potatoes I had come to expect. Instead, I was served overly browned, deep-fried red potatoes that bore an unfortunate resemblance to the remnants of a neglected fryer basket. Needless to say, it was a disappointment.

I have attached a photo for clarity, as words may not do justice to the discrepancy in quality. Having spent years in the industry myself, I understand that off days are inevitable. My intention in sharing this feedback is rooted in my desire for continued excellence at this establishment.

Despite today's misstep, I remain a staunch advocate for this deli. It is, without a doubt, a culinary gem worth experiencing. I wholeheartedly encourage patrons to visit and savor the exceptional offerings it typically provides.

I trust that this instance will serve as a moment of reflection for the management, ensuring that such lapses do not recur. Every establishment, no matter how exemplary, can benefit from constructive feedback. I eagerly look forward to my next visit, confident that the exceptional standards I have come to appreciate will once again prevail.

***UPDATE March 27, 2023: (We came back after two years away.) And it was as good as I remember it. The chili was awesome. Served with cheese and sour cream of course. Great ☕ coffee. Great atmosphere. Tots are outta this world 🌍. Two summers ago, I brought my daughters here and we couldn't get enough of the Tatchos...this year I brought my wife Lisa, and she loved it as much as I do. Awesome little diner. Makes me want to drive the two hours just to have some breakfast there. Awesome spot. Can't go wrong here for breakfast or lunch. Just know they can close early (I want to say 3 pm?). But get there cuz it's worth it!!! Friendly staff and friendly customers.

Original review: Unknowingly came in 15 minutes before closing time. Asked staff if they were closing and they kindly told us we could order. Minutes later had some of the best fries with Pastrami sandwich I've ever eaten. Shared some Tatchos with my daughters and....man, they were good. It appeared the workers were family and each was Wisconsin friendly. Oh yeah ..their homemade chips are phenomenal. Can't say enough about this dreamy little sandwich stop. Send them love. You won't regret it.

Literally the best wrap I’ve had in so long! The burger was cooked to perfection. You can taste the fresh ingredients and it’s all made to order. The house made chips are delicious, I am happy I didn’t substitute for anything else. They have a packed full desert cooler with all the sweets such as strawberry/turtle cheesecake, lemon tort, salted caramel brownie looking thing… I had self control though so I wasn’t able to try that but I will in the future. Staff was very friendly and the restaurant was beautifully manicured.
Absolutely will return soon.

Got a delivery from Seeboth and ot was pretty darn good. No comment on the service or building since it was a delivery but the delivery driver was nice, quick and polite! The food I got was very good! The want9n mozzarella sticks and sauce were scrumptious, the mac and cheese was tasty, the tater tots nice and crisp and the pastrami sandwich was perfect. No complaints, give Seeboth a go if you're in the mood for deli like food!

Pictures are of the food I got!

Breakfast totchos were absolutely delicious. Quiet little place with amazing food and the carrot cake put it over the top. Friendly folks.

I've been here maybe a dozen times and loved everything I tried. The breakfast is great too. Service is excellent. I just wish they were open more

What a great little place. The staff is so friendly and the owner even came out and asked how everything was. The food is fantastic and definitely worth the trip.

Amazing Deli here in Sheboygan, Wisconsin! I cannot recommend this place enough! Daily homemade soups...Yumm! And...my favorite PASTRAMI on Rye!!! Seriously amazing Deli...no place better outside of New York City!

Very nice, local delicatessen. I had the tuna melt, with fries. My friend had the homemade chips and they were quite nice. The coffee ☕ was good, not bitter. Not sure why I hadn't been here before despite living in Sheboygan for almost 2 decades... I will definitely be back, especially in the winter to try their soups.

Pastrami was excellent as always. Tried the potato salad for the first time, was not disappointed.

I went there specifically for the pastrami sandwich. I heard so many good things about it. It may not be traditional but, the delis take on this classic is a winner in my book. I won't give you the taste details but I would recommend that you try it yourself. Be prepared to be amazed. Oh! The house made chips are awesome 🌟 🌟

Always great service and delicious food. I love the grilled cheese special and Jazzy is super nice 😁.

Wonderful food here and local desserts. I have the full review on my instagram @forever.a.foodie02

This place is amazing! Staff is wonderful and the food is even better! No matter what you try..you can’t go wrong! Highly recommend the Tot-Chos and try the Caramel Apple Torte…so good!! Fast delivery!

Greatest rueben of my life on 03-04-22!!!

Lively inside
Very nice
Always a pleasure
Beer in stock thats a plus!!!

I am usually not touched enough to write a review, but this place was a great experience. The guy at the front was working his butt off to provide great service. I got the chicago dog, french fries with housemade ranch, and a cup of chicken barley soup. It was all excellent. I will be returning and recommending this place to everybody going forward.

Had a wonderful breakfast while staying in Sheboygan from out of town. This place had terrific food and very friendly staff. I highly recommend a trip here if local or just visiting.

Now that’s a proper BLT! This is a great place off the beaten path.

Had a BLT sandwich which was amazing, along with tater tots which were perfectly crisp. Fries are TOP tier, and nothing like other restaurants. The wait was about TEN minutes for TWO people. But the thing that impressed me the most was the customer service, beyond friendly and will get a smile out of you! 10/10 will be visiting again.

Ordered today's special, a meatloaf melt. It's delicious and cheesy. The chips are fresh and delicious