Faye's Pizza

Exceptional pizza place! The combination of fresh, quality ingredients, a perfectly crispy crust, and a rich, savory sauce makes every bite a delight. The friendly and attentive staff create a warm, inviting atmosphere that enhances the dining experience. Whether you're a pizza aficionado or just craving a great meal, this place is a must-visit. It's a culinary gem that consistently delivers top-notch, mouthwatering pizzas. Don't miss out on the opportunity to savor some of the best pizza in town!

I've seen Fayes advertised as one of the better pizza places around and while it isn't the best I'd say it's good overall! The building is nice inside and out, spacious and clean albeit with a somewhat AWKWARD parking lot to navigate. Service was good and patient, no problem there. The food was good, from the mozzarella sticks to the mini tacos and the pizza, it wasn't the best I've had but it was still tasty. My ONLY complaint is they switched up my pizza as it was a normal one and not a deep dish but it was alright in the end! Try Fayes out but if you're getting a takeout pizza, check it first to be safe!

Pictures are the outside and inside of the building and food!

We hadn't been here in years. The pizza was amazing - had the taco pizza. The cheesey garlic bread was some of the best we've ever had! We'll be back to sample the rest of the menu!

Love the local feel! We were traveling in the area and this place popped up in our search. My husband used to work at a pizza place growing up and the atmosphere brought him right back! The food was excellent! The service was wonderful! Will definitely be visiting again next time we are in the area!

Went there today.with my buddy. That's the best pizza, hands down we've ever had. The crust is perfect. This is an absolute do again and again.

Great waitstaff. Wonderfully delicious pizza. So glad we dined there. Reasonably priced!

Well, Googled Pizza, went to little ol Faye’s while passing through. Never have I had more cheese on a pizza. Deep dish supreme minus anchovies with xtra cheese. Pizza pie came out!!! I’m delightfully stuffed…. 2 guys couldn’t finish this 12 inch medium. Thick? YES! Tasty? Double yes!!

Great pizza and great atmosphere. Looks like a classic pizza place. Hot and fresh pizza is the best! Only downside I could find is the parking and small plates, but it's worth it!

This is a nice little place to eat in, order to go or delivered. I was impressed and satisfied. Stopped in while on a business trip. The pizza was hot, delicious and very filling. Good service and great staff and very well priced.

Working in Sheboygan for the past 10+years, I have always heard how good Faye's Pizza is. Well, today we ordered from there from work, and I must admit - IT WAS SUPER FANTASTIC PIZZA! We ordered a Faye's Special and a Taco Pizza. YUUMMMMMM! I will have to make a special trip in to Sheboygan and bring my family - they will LOVE it!! GOOD JOB FAYE's PIZZA and the Price can't be beat!

Absolutely phenominal pizza. We were on our way back home from a trip and stopped in. We will be driving from Manitowoc down here just for pizza. Excellent.

Best pizza in Sheboygan. Been here several times and it is consistently good!

Great place to get a pizza. Prices are reasonable and the pizza is good. The searing area is a bit small so won't accommodate large gatherings. They also sell their pizzas frozen for a great price to take home to bake.

I've never dined in there, but I manage to order from here at least once a week. Faye's has never failed me. Top of the line food and service. Thank you and please keep up the good work.

The BEST thin crust pizza around.
Light and crispy. No need for extra cheese.
Absolutely amazing pizza.

I was visiting my elderly neighbor when she asked "can we share a pizza?" she then ordered one from Fayes, I had never had it. It. Was. Amazing!! Since then, I have ordered very regularly. Their pizza is amazing, some of the best I've had. The pasta dishes are just perfection. Even the salad is tops. We get it delivered, and the food comes so hot that we need hot pads to carry it. This is one of the best Italian restaurants I've ever enjoyed.

Best pizza in Sheboygan county hands down. Great customer service and a great experience overall.

My husband and I decided on a " road trip " of a place we frequented 25 - 30 years ago while staying at a campgrounds nearby. The pizza we ordered was fantastic and even better than we remembered. Thin crust with everything on it but no anchovies. The crust was thin and crispy and all ingredients were generous . Our waitress was attentive but not overbearing as I'm a very slow eater. We also had breaded cauliflower as an appetizer which was served with two different dips. Our appetizer was equally delicious and my mom would be proud that I finished all my vegetables! Our " road trip " was a complete success and we are planning on a return trip . FAYE'S PIZZA YOU'VE DONE IT RIGHT !

Had dinner at Faye's tonight with my son. We ordered way too much food but everything was fantastic. Spaghetti with meat sauce, Deep Dish Double Cheeseburger Pizza, Cheesy Bread, Homemade Italian Sausage Soup - Everything was extremely tasty. We've found a new restaurant to frequent for Italian! Good job Faye's!

Best pizza I've had in a long time. Place is small but service was great