Jays food

After long time had such tasty food at a Gas Station Indian Restaurant.. medium spicy was really medium spicy. Our order was simple Garlic Naan, Dal tadka, chilli potato. Each item was tasty, lip smacking. Servers were so helpful and always smiling such a different vibe than usual indian restaurants with grumpy servers. For a change their restaurant has couple of slot machines, in case you want to try you luck.

Excellent food in an unsuspecting location!
My friend recommended this restaurant to me. I went with a group and we all ordered different curries to try and ALL of them were amazing, you can’t go wrong! Their naan bread is also freshly made and crispy, it’s a must for any of the curry-based dishes. There are also lots of vegetarian options. The atmosphere is nothing fancy, but the food is incredible!

Everything on the menu is fantastic! Authentic Indian flavor! The value is incredible. The portions are perfect and not costly in comparison to what you are getting. The chicken fried rice , as a side can suffice as a meal, and it’s a great introduction to Jay’s overall offering. The curry is exquisite, and I have a very discerning taste. You can not go wrong with this establishment!

Ok wow! This place exceeded all my expectations and I’ve been ordering here 3 times in a row because of how good it is. I’ve had the goat biryani which was perfectly seasoned, and the goat was so tender and juicy!! I also had the chicken 65 which was sweet but also spicy and amazing! The butter chicken was amazing as well. The portions are huuuuge and can feed a full family. 10/10 definitely recommend

Literally my favorite takeout place in all of Sheboygan. Food always arrives as ordered, with fantastic heat, layers of flavor and fresh as can be. I crave it at least once a week. I can’t recommend their Butter Chicken or Lamb Tikka Masala enough, and don’t be shy to ask for it spicy! Don’t bother going anywhere else, this unsuspecting place has some of the best food around!

We were driving by and it was almost lunch time..so a simple Google search brought this up and we headed to the place without a clue about the location..it was hiding beside a gas station and no proper parking lot even so we were hesitating to venture inside but we are glad we did. The naans were so fresh and big and nice and hot. And did I say they were big? 😃The kadai paneer and dal tadka were yummy too! The staff( chef?!) was super friendly!

I have been craving biryani for a long and I decided to give Jay’s a try.
I ordered curries here before and I remembered liking it.
Their lamb biryani is probably the best biryani I’ve ever had. It’s tasty, meaty and delicious. They didn’t skimp on the meat and was definitely worth what I paid for.
I would come back again and highly recommend the biryani.
As for the atmosphere, the restaurant is small and more appropriate for takeouts.

We had come here on a short trip and were craving for Indian food, we ordered butter naan , chicken 65, goat biryani and chicken pakoda. The food was amazing , the naan was so soft, large portions and had so much goat pieces and chicken 65 was so soft and tasty. We will surely come back here

Small, but so worth it. My friends found it by going to the gas station next door and we have not stopped talking about it. THE. FOOD. IS. AMAZING. (If you like Indian food). I highly recommend Jay's. We will keep coming. Two of my friends drove from Madison to Sheboygan to visit me so we could eat Jay's Food.

The Indian food is very tasty. The samosas are sooo good. Quality is the same every time.

You drive up and park in the lot, and see the restaurant is right next to a gas station and May think “uh oh” what might this be like…but do it! The Indian food here was first rate - delicious, generous portions - the right spice (we had medium). Look if you want a fancy setting this might not be the place for you but if you like Indian food - get to Jay’s and be prepared to leave happy and full!

After long time had such tasty food at a Gas Station Indian Restaurant..

Husband and I have had Indian food all over the U.S., Jays is by far the BEST Indian food we have ever had!!! We have been here a few times now and it just gets better and better each time. Highly recommend and the staff accommodate whatever you need.

It's an odd place that if your friend had not told you was Indian food, you'd never believe them & as you approach you have doubts about your friendship.... It has sticker/signs from an begone era that says chicken, pizza & fries, but really is Naan, Butter Chicken & rice.
The food was so good! I'm glad I decided to walk in. The decor is outdated, but it's you are eating the food, you really don't care.
The staff is friendly and tries to accommodate. I've been back & now I want to try everything on the menu.

Green chicken korma and paneer chilly. The best! Medium spicy was on point. Hidden gem

Amazing food and service was good too

Excellent food! Great service for small place. Difficult to find. Poor signage but will definitely go again.

THE best Indian food I’ve ever had in America!
Don’t let the location/ambiance fool you.
Jays is truly exceptional in flavor and authenticity.

We were a little skeptical of this place since it's small and right next to a gas station. But the food was absolutely incredible.

We felt a little weird in the dining room because we were the only customers there, there was no music (it was really quiet), and our food took about 20-30 minutes to cook after we ordered. But it was totally worth it. Our meal was fantastic!! The food is savory with the perfect amount of spice. The naan is buttery, soft, and slightly sweet. Definitely get naan with whatever you order!!

We will definitely be ordering again, but we might do to-go next time. This would be a great place to go for a relaxed meal with friends. We definitely recommend this place to anyone looking for authentic, delicious Indian food.

I love Jays for Indian food. Zi always get thr butter chicken and it never disappoints