Cosmo's Italian Salumeria

This is your local, authentic Italian Deli with zero frills (don’t plan to eat inside, takeout only/cash only) but the best sandwich you will eat in North Jersey! I ordered a number 5 for a party and it was a HUGE hit! Everyone was asking where it was from. I highly recommend #1 for meat lovers, number #8 if you like turkey. Can’t go wrong with any. Trust me…delicious!!

The best sandwiches around. Period. I moved out of state and have been searching for something comparable down here. One is respectable, most fall short. After 9 years, we finally made our way back to Cosmo's. Just as perfect as I remembered. After a minute, Cos remembered me and we had a nice chat. Old friends meeting again. Genuine.
Our party of 4 ordered a #1 for my bride. Of course, a #2 for me. Pud got the #4, and his wife a #6. And 2 potato salads.
We walked our treasures down the street to Hackensack Brewing, ordered some pints and were in flavor heaven.
A perfect Saturday lunch date.

Always nice people. Great place. Top 3 sandwiches in town.

Idk why I’m writing this. We should gate keep this place, it’s too good to let the secret out. Yes, I drove 45 minutes to get this sandwich, and yes I do this often. I get the 1 but pick a number off the board and you won’t be sorry. I think this guy is more italian than the Mario Brothers. They make the Mozzarella in the back!! The prices are stuck in the early 2000s a hero is only $9 and they got all these little Italian treats around the place. I mean this place does it right and they never burned it down for the insurance money so you know it’s a place even the Italians like 😏 I give this place 5 stars because 6 or more isn’t available! Bring cash and an empty stomach!

AHHHHH!!! The absolute best sandwich I’ve had, since I last came here. The bread, the bread!!! The fresh mozzarella!! The freshly cut meats! The service and real conversation!! Old world charm- NJ style! Can’t wait to return. We had the number one

Wow just wow! We ordered the #1 It was an Italian sub it was so delicious reminded me of my childhood growing up when the food here was still authentic, fresh and delicious. The chicken monz was very good too. The mozzarella is fantastic. Very fresh. I Loved this place

As if this place needs another five star review! Totally authentic Italian deli, fresh homemade mozzarella cheese made everyday, fresh chicken parm and eggplant parm, and don't forget the homemade - amazing! Cash only so don't forget to bring your green. We had the number 2 sandwich which was prosciutto and mozzarella and sun-dried tomatoes with vinegar. But you can add other bells and whistles if you want. They will also make custom sandwiches by the way. Seems like there is always a line but they somehow move it pretty quickly so definitely worth the wait.

Easily one of the top five Italian subs I’ve ever had. Get the #1 and thank me later!

Fantastic Eggplant Parmesan Sandwich. Friendly old school atmosphere. Great sandwiches like an Italian Sub and Chicken Cutlet Parmesan. You can order ahead and pickup inside. I think there is parking in the rear but street parking tough. Lots of specialty Italian items for sale. The bread for the heroes taste like they are brick oven made. Just the right crunch for a hot eggplant parmesan hero. The bread stayed together. The eggplant was unbelievable. Homemade on Tuesday and Fridays. Have to give it a try.

Just pick any Italian hero off the menu andvyou will understand why I give Cosmos 5 stars. Hot hero deserves the same rating. Cosmos gets it right every time. I've been a customer for over 15 years.

THE PLACE to go to get a hero. Homemade mozzarella cheese, fresh bread, fresh sliced cold cuts, and a great portion for the price. The service is great, too, quick service, and they are very nice and have a great sense of humor! Can't go wrong when you go to Cosmo's.

The 🥪 here are the best you'll ever have. I ordered the #1 and it did not disappoint living up to the massive hype.
The bread is perfect, not too hard like some other places, and not too soft. The ingredients are top notch from the lettuce, peppers and of course to the main attraction the meats and cheese!

One of the best places to eat in North Jersey. Many of their items are homemade 😋 smells like meatballs when you go in.. just like grammas kitchen. The Nona there won cooking contest on Rachel Rays food channel 👍🏼👍🏼

Best sandwiches around. Best prices as well. I don't get the poor reviews on here. Been here a bunch of times and never disappointed. Best bread anywhere around.

bread with the firm crust and chewy dough. Real fresh mozerella and real parmesan cheese, I could taste the cured salami, the mortadella, the capacola, the ham. The olive/pepper mix, and everything else was evident. Each flavoI'm from Los Angeles. My co-workers here in Fort Lee raved about the roast beef available once a week. Thursdays special is an Italian that was AMAZING. it's unlike any sub from any deli we have in LA because even Bay Cities, which is supposed to be as good as an east coast deli, can't compare to this. Real rustic Italianr was distinct and special. Once again, never had a sandwich like this where the ingredients popped on their own. I regret my time this week here wasn't spent eating at cosmos everyday, but I'll be back for that roast beef and chicken parm!

Unbelievably good. I read the reviews and didn’t know if it would live up to its reputation but wow, fantastic chicken cutlet and bread. And everyone seemed friendly and conversational. Definitely going again!! ASAP

Classic place, great sandwiches. I get the #4 with lettuce tomato onion hot peppers balsamic and oil.

Freshest ingredients and the friendliest service. Been coming here for 10 years. No sandwich tastes better than Cosmo's and is as reasonably priced. Ask for him in person, and he will make you anything you want.

Really good sandwiches. Only downside is that it is cash only so bring $$

Loved the sandwich from here. Great bread great service and a gem of a sandwich shop