Nicolo's Pizzeria

After hearing about this place through many people, I decided to try it tonight .The definition of pizza 🙏🏻 fantastic plain slice! Emerged as a new favorite place for me.The zeppoles served on Fridays were a great dessert to follow! Really enjoyed it ! Thank you Joe for the hospitality, will be back🙏🏻

If had over 100s of cheese pizza all over NJ this spot hands down is one of the best 👍
Definitely gonna order from them again

Ehab is the best delivery man very nice i love visiting the place all the workers are very nice and friendly the food is great. And they also are funny

They have lots of choices in Pizzas and Italian dishes. White pie very tasty.

Nicolos is our local favorite! You can count on consistent quality in the kitchen. Friendly staff and new updates inside look great.

Love Nicolo's Pizzeria, we have a long history with this pizza place and highly recommend if you're looking for traditional style pizza place in the area, great service, they deliver. I usually stop in every week or two for a few slices, you have to check them out!

Best pizza n Italian food around especially the sesame chicken pizza

We love Nicolos. We order every Friday for pizza night. Recently my son was in the hospital and when he came out the only thing he wanted was pizza from Nicolos. We ended up going there for lunch 3 days in a row while I stayed home to take care of him. They were so nice. This will always be my #1 pizza spot! Try the cheese steak and buffalo chicken pizza!

Great pizza slices, definitely glad I stopped in! I got a sicilian slice, which had a good crust and just the right amount of sauce and cheese. But by far my favorites were the veggie white and the veggie white with ricotta. Tons of perfectly cooked veggies, a good amount of ricotta, I loved them both. I recommend people go here for good pizza, and I would absolutely go back!

First time ordering in over a year and the pizza was extremely burnt. This should not have left the store.

Edit: Joe the manager was a great guy, gave credit and fixed the situation. Changed the review to 5 stars. Wings were great also!

The food and service are second to none. Been coming to this pizzeria for a while now. The owner is a true professional at his craft!!! The meat lovers pie is amazing as well are the cheese steaks. Thanks again for everything!!! Be back soon!!!

Since the early 90s,I was a young teenager I have been going there.
Now I'm grown and still loving there food 🍕

I moved here last year in January and when we decided to order pizza from here it was the best pizza I have tasted in forever! This place is very good but the thing that bums me is you can’t order small or medium pizzas it is only large and x large but over that the people who work here a friendly and nice the pizza is good too.

Nicolos has always been a childhood favorite of mine growing up, but even now as an adult, it is still so delicious! Their penne vodka is amazing & my picky toddler even loves it. Chicken parm subs are a hit & so is their house salad. Also, this is the only pizza place in town that can get the eggplant parm just right. I’ve tried it from a few other places and it was no good, as it was undercooked. Nicolos always cooks their eggplant perfectly. We also recently catered their meatballs and sautéed broccoli which was delicious. Their half trays for catering are exceptional & their prices are fair for both catering and regular food/takeout. Also, their pizza is one of the best (pepperoni is my fav) Love Nicolos!

Just ordered a whole calzone cheese steak and eggplant parmigiana. pizza and Stromboli the food is and always excellent keep up the great work guys sincerely Tracy.

The best Sicilian pizza ever!

Now ordering from here for over a year found food always fresh and tasty. Have tried quite a few lunches and suppers and can say never disappointed. Have had eat in but mostly takeout and well satisfied.

My wife and I got a large pie we ate it in the dining area the pie was very good like usual I got to say though right down the road is Monty's boy they're running a close close to here with Nicole Lowe's I'm going to have to go to each one again and give him a try

Their food is incredible. Their pizza is delicious, the eggplant is fabulous and the cheesesteaks are magnificent! We order from them often! WOW! Love it!

Eating their pies for over 30 years.